Cost-effectiveness of routine use of pooled nucleic acid amplification testing

Sep 28, 2010

Detection of acute HIV infection (the stage of disease immediately after HIV acquisition but before HIV antibodies are detectable) with pooled nucleic acid amplification testing (that detects the presence of HIV genetic material in the blood before antibodies are detectable) is feasible but not cost-effective in all settings.

Rather, pooled nucleic acid amplification testing after testing for antibodies with third-generation enzyme immunoassays (which can detect the first antibody to appear after infection) or rapid testing is only cost-effective when targeted to settings with very high HIV incidence, such as clinics that serve men who have sex with men (MSM). These are the findings of a study by Angela Hutchinson from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia, USA, and colleagues published in this week's .

The authors combined effectiveness data from a clinical trial of pooled nucleic acid amplification testing in three settings in the USA (sexually transmitted disease clinics, a community clinic serving MSM and HIV counseling/testing sites) with a "micro-costing" study of pooled nucleic acid amplification testing and a mathematical model of . They then calculated the costs per quality-adjusted life year (QALY) gained (the cost-effectiveness ratio) by identifying and notifying people with acute HIV infection through screening using pooled nucleic acid amplification testing compared with repeat antibody testing at different intervals, including annual testing (the recommended testing interval for high-risk individuals).

The authors estimated that each QALY gained from pooled nucleic acid amplification testing following annual antibody testing would cost US$372,300 and US$484,400 for the counseling/testing sites and sexually transmitted disease clinics, respectively, a result which is generally considered to be not cost effective. However, this method was cost-saving for the clinic that served MSM. The cost-effectiveness ratio increased for the counseling/testing sites and sexually transmitted disease clinics when the antibody testing interval was decreased to 6 months but remained cost-saving for the clinic that served MSM. However, with an antibody testing interval of 5 years, pooled nucleic acid amplification testing was cost-saving in all three settings. Yet the authors noted that most of the benefits that made it cost-effective during the 5-year interval between retesting occurred long after the acute phase, when antibody testing could have been repeated.

The authors conclude, "Pooled screening [nucleic acid amplification testing] for [acute HIV infection] following negative third-generation antibody or rapid tests is not cost-effective at recommended antibody testing intervals for high-risk persons except [for those] in very high-incidence settings."

Explore further: Indiana HIV outbreak, hepatitis C epidemic sparks US alert

More information: Hutchinson AB, Patel P, Sansom SL, Farnham PG, Sullivan TJ, et al. (2010) Cost-Effectiveness of Pooled Nucleic Acid Amplification Testing for Acute HIV Infection after Third-Generation HIV Antibody Screening and Rapid Testing in the United States: A Comparison of Three Public Health Settings. PLoS Med 7(9): e1000342. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1000342

Related Stories

Testing times: Detecting HIV in resource-limited settings

Nov 29, 2007

Integrating HIV testing programmes into primary medical care can help achieve early diagnosis of HIV infection, even in relatively poor areas, research published in the online open access journal AIDS Research and Therapy ...

Is HIV testing during labor feasible?

Feb 27, 2009

Cameroon is a sub-Saharan African country with high HIV rates yet many pregnant women do not know their HIV status. Research published in the open access journal BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth has shown that HIV testing during ...

HIV testing for children must be improved

Jul 20, 2010

National HIV programs should recognize that HIV testing and counseling systems designed for adults do not meet the needs of children. Therefore, according to Scott Kellerman from Management Sciences for Health, Virginia, ...

Recommended for you

HIV prevention and risk behaviors follow weekly patterns

6 hours ago

The peak time for seeking information on topics related to HIV, such as prevention and testing, is at the beginning of the week, while risky sexual behaviors tend to increase on the weekends, according to a new analysis by ...

Mathematical model seeks functional cure for HIV

7 hours ago

(Medical Xpress)—Individuals with the natural ability to control HIV infection in the absence of treatment are referred to as elite controllers (ECs). Such individuals maintain undetectable viral loads ...

Indiana HIV outbreak, hepatitis C epidemic sparks US alert

Apr 24, 2015

Federal health officials helping to contain an HIV outbreak in Indiana state issued an alert to health departments across the U.S. on Friday, urging them to take steps to identify and track HIV and hepatitis C cases in an ...

Why are HIV survival rates lower in the Deep South than the rest of the US?

Apr 22, 2015

The Deep South region has become the epicenter of the US HIV epidemic. Despite having only 28% of the total US population, nine states in the Deep South account for nearly 40% of national HIV diagnoses. This region has the highest HIV diagnosis rates and the highest number of people living with HIV of any ...

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.