The pros and cons of Miscanthus -- uses more water, leaches less nitrogen

Sep 09, 2010
Miscanthus at maximum biomass tops 11 feet, shown with Emily Doherty for scale. Credit: Photo courtesy S. Long Lab, University of Illinois

In the search for the perfect crop for biofuel production, Miscanthus has become the darling to many. But in an effort to not be charmed by its enormous potential for biomass production, researchers at the University of Illinois are taking a careful look at the pros and cons of its behavior in the field.

A recent study analyzed water quantity and quality in plots of Miscanthus, switchgrass, corn, and soybeans and found that Miscanthus used substantially more water, but reduced the potential for to water bodies.

"We found that Miscanthus tends to dry out the soil much more than corn, soybeans, or switchgrass later in the growing season," said Greg McIsaac, environmental scientist in the College of Agricultural, Consumer and Environmental Sciences. "This would likely reduce runoff, stream flow and surface water supplies later in the summer and in early fall, when streams are typically at their lowest. It could reduce the amount of water available to those who are downstream in late summer and early fall."

Switchgrass behaves like Miscanthus early in the growing season, drying out the soil. It then goes into a reproductive mode and uses very little water in the late summer and fall.

McIsaac said that Miscanthus's impact on water supply may be small if it is planted on only a few acres in a . "The severity of the impacts will likely vary depending on the nature of the soils and . In areas where water is in short supply, switchgrass may be preferable, understanding that switchgrass creates much less biomass than Miscanthus," he said.

"It will likely be in the farmer's economic interest to plant the most productive crop, which may also use more water than their current crops. When and where this occurs over significant areas, downstream water users should consider how it is going to influence their water supply. They may need to develop plans to address more frequent , or perhaps attempt to influence the planting decisions through incentives or policy. It is something to be aware of and plan for if Miscanthus or a similar water-demanding crop becomes economically attractive to farmers," he added.

The fact that both Miscanthus and switchgrass use more water early in the growing season than corn and soybeans could be seen as a benefit because flooding is often a problem that time of year. Drying out the soil earlier in the spring would reduce from spring rains, he said, and thus reduce flood flows.

The study also looked at how nitrogen moves or "leaches" into the ground water beneath the four crops. With corn and soybeans where the field has tile drainage, the fertilizer and soil organic nitrogen gets converted to nitrate which is highly soluble and moves with the water to the tile drains. From there it moves out to the ditches and streams, causing problems for drinking and contributing to the hypoxia in the Gulf of Mexico.

The Miscanthus and switchgrass plots in the study received no added fertilizer and grew vigorously without it. Consequently, it wasn't surprising that the unfertilized Miscanthus and switchgrass had much lower leaching than soybeans or fertilized corn.

McIsaac explained that there are several factors at work, not just the absence of applied fertilizers. "The roots in perennial grasses go deeper into the soil. They're more extensive and they are active earlier in the growing season - so if we had perennial corn, it might behave more like these grasses. But even with soybeans, where we also didn't apply fertilizer, the amount of leaching was almost as high as with corn. So it's not just the absence of fertilizer, it's also the perennial roots that retain more soil nitrogen."

"We did not apply fertilizer to Miscanthus or switchgrass because the study was designed to look at a low-input biofuel," McIsaac said. "The results showed that you can get high productivity without fertilizing Miscanthus, at least for the first three to four years. It is likely that if you apply fertilizer to Miscanthus and switchgrass, there would be more leaching than what we saw in our study, with no application. But because of the root activity, I would expect fertilized Miscanthus and switchgrass to leach less than fertilized corn. To be certain, this needs further study."

Explore further: New research on Earth's carbon budget

More information: Miscanthus and Switchgrass Production in Central Illinois: Impacts on Hydrology and Inorganic Nitrogen Leaching appears in the September-October edition of the Journal of Environmental Quality.

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Switchgrass lessens soil nitrate loss into waterways

Aug 09, 2010

By planting switchgrass and using certain agronomic practices, farmers can significantly reduce the amount of nitrogen and nitrates that leach into the soil, according to Iowa State University research.

If corn is biofuels king, tropical maize may be emperor

Oct 16, 2007

When University of Illinois crop scientist Fred Below began growing tropical maize, the form of corn grown in the tropics, he was looking for novel genes for the utilization of nitrogen fertilizer and was hoping to discover ...

First parasitic nematodes reported in biofuel crops

Mar 17, 2010

Researchers at the Energy Biosciences Institute (EBI) at the University of Illinois have discovered widespread occurrence of plant-parasitic nematodes in the first reported nematode survey of Miscanthus and switchgrass plants ...

Recommended for you

New research on Earth's carbon budget

13 hours ago

(Phys.org) —Results from a research project involving scientists from the Desert Research Institute have generated new findings surrounding some of the unknowns of changes in climate and the degree to which ...

User comments : 0

More news stories

Magnitude-7.2 earthquake shakes Mexican capital

A powerful magnitude-7.2 earthquake shook central and southern Mexico on Friday, sending panicked people into the streets. Some walls cracked and fell, but there were no reports of major damage or casualties.

Impact glass stores biodata for millions of years

(Phys.org) —Bits of plant life encapsulated in molten glass by asteroid and comet impacts millions of years ago give geologists information about climate and life forms on the ancient Earth. Scientists ...

Researchers successfully clone adult human stem cells

(Phys.org) —An international team of researchers, led by Robert Lanza, of Advanced Cell Technology, has announced that they have performed the first successful cloning of adult human skin cells into stem ...