Galileo revisited: How ribbons roll

Sep 08, 2010 by David L. Chandler, MIT News
The MIT team made a variety of “ribbons” using polymers that have different degrees of flexibility. Image: Pascal Raux and Pedro Reis

Galileo Galilei’s experiments on the motions of falling and rolling objects, described in his 1638 book, “Two New Sciences,” are considered by many to be the beginning of modern science. Now researchers at MIT have conducted a variation on his experiments that has produced unexpected results.

Galileo used rigid materials — metal balls and a wooden ramp — for his tests on how bodies move down an inclined plane. Since then, a few tests have been done with solid balls rolling down a flexible surface. But until recently, nobody had tried rolling flexible objects down a solid plane. MIT professors Pedro Reis and John Bush, along with visiting student Pascal Raux and visiting professor Christophe Clanet, have now carried out experiments using a variety of flexible, hollow cylinders  — essentially wide rubber bands — with different degrees of elasticity, and have derived a set of equations to describe the behavior of these "rolling ribbons." The work was described in a paper published in July in the journal .

Flexible ribbons initially settle into an oval shape because of gravity, and one might expect them to get rounder as they roll due to centrifugal force. But the opposite occurs. The faster the ribbons roll, the more they lose their circular shape, eventually assuming a two-lobed “peanut” shape. At even higher speeds, the sagging middle droops so far that it comes in contact with the bottom of the ribbon, causing friction that makes the loop suddenly lurch backward. The researchers say the behavior is the result of “a delicate coupling between rolling, bending and stretching.”

Though this was basic research, Reis speculates that the resulting analysis might ultimately be useful for applications as varied as predicting the motions of microscopic cylinders called carbon nanotubes, the behavior of drill casings in deep wells, and the way blood cells move through veins and arteries. ( are known to have a similar characteristic peanut-like shape, but that shape has never been fully explained.) Bush, a professor of applied mathematics, explains that “one of our goals is to better understand the role of flexibility in locomotion.”

The research was prompted by a suggestion from Clanet, who taught a course at MIT during a stint as a visiting lecturer. He is a professor working at the Laboratory of Hydrodynamics at the Ecole Polytechnique in Palaiseau, outside Paris. Raux, a student visiting MIT from Paris, was the lead author of the paper.

Video courtesy of Pascal Raux and Pedro Reis. This video illustrates the shape transformation of a flexible polymer ribbon, otherwise circular, when rotated on a treadmill.

Why has it taken almost four centuries for scientists to take this next step from Galileo’s work? Reis explains that despite their apparent simplicity, the behavior of flexible structures is often nonlinear — that is, it requires more complicated mathematical equations to describe than that of simple rigid objects, and so the analysis wasn’t feasible before the advent of computers. And in addition, only relatively recently has it become easy to make objects out of flexible polymers with any desired degree of elasticity and shape using modern fabrication tools.

In this case, team members had to create the flexible cylinders from scratch — they employed a polymer that dentists use to make casts — because commercially available versions, such as wide rubber bands, do not have precise enough shapes with constant thickness.

Lakshminarayanan Mahedevan, a professor of applied mathematics at Harvard University, has published research on a different variation of Galileo’s experiments but was not involved in this work. Mahedevan says this basic research “has implications for how surfaces in contact move relative to each other.” But what really matters, he says, is the basic principles discovered in this way: “The particular manifestation is less important than the general principles that underlie these types of deformations.”

As with much basic research, the ultimate usefulness of the work is hard to predict, although there are clear examples of areas where such rolling behavior occurs. But for the researchers, there was a real thrill in finding a way to extend work that has such a fabled history. “One thing that made it really neat for us from the start was the connection with Galileo, to take an experiment that has been a classic” and extend it in a new direction, says Reis, the Esther and Harold E. Edgerton Assistant Professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering and Mechanical Engineering.

This story is republished courtesy of MIT News (, a popular site that covers news about MIT research, innovation and teaching.

Explore further: Cold Atom Laboratory creates atomic dance

Related Stories

MIT method allows 3-D study of cells

Apr 24, 2006

MIT bioengineers have devised a new technique that makes it possible to learn more about how cells are organized in tissues and potentially even to regrow cells for repairing areas of the body damaged by disease, ...

The Physics Of A Bump In A Rug

Oct 20, 2009

Scientists often have to make sacrifices for their work. Physicist Dominic Vella chopped his bathroom rug into strips, and L. Mahadevan's coauthor ran off with his bookshelf. With these sacrifices, these two ...

Trimble Introduces Future-Ready GNSS Positioning Technology

Oct 06, 2005

Trimble announced Wednesday that it has developed a software-based technology supporting Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) to maximize flexibility and minimize cost in end-user positioning products that will use a ...

Recommended for you

Backpack physics: Smaller hikers carry heavier loads

10 hours ago

Hikers are generally advised that the weight of the packs they carry should correspond to their own size, with smaller individuals carrying lighter loads. Although petite backpackers might appreciate the ...

Extremely high-resolution magnetic resonance imaging

10 hours ago

For the first time, researchers have succeeded to detect a single hydrogen atom using magnetic resonance imaging, which signifies a huge increase in the technology's spatial resolution. In the future, single-atom ...

'Attosecond' science breakthrough

11 hours ago

Scientists from Queen's University Belfast have been involved in a groundbreaking discovery in the area of experimental physics that has implications for understanding how radiotherapy kills cancer cells, among other things.

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Sep 08, 2010
?? I refreshed the page but still no video

Ah well
5 / 5 (2) Sep 08, 2010
I thought the shape of the red blood cell was optimal because it:
* maximises surface area, which is good both for interchange of dissolved oxygen and carbon dioxide and also for increasing drag within the blood plasma which sweeps them along,
* minimises regions of internal volume not reachable by diffusion, and
* all but eliminates the potential for snagging within small capillaries.

not rated yet Sep 08, 2010
This is news?

"The faster the ribbons roll, the more they lose their circular shape, eventually assuming a two-lobed “peanut” shape."

Of course, otherwise the tracks of an army tank would loosen and become unattached.