Aussie family speaks out about lead-poisoned child

Aug 03, 2010

The mother of a schoolgirl at the centre of a lead contamination dispute in a north Australian mining town Tuesday spoke of her concern about her daughter's deteriorating health.

Daphne Hare said her eight-year-old daughter Stella was spending increasing amounts of time in hospital with health and related to the elevated levels of in her blood.

"She's not a well child at the moment. She's got gastro-intestinal problems... and intellectual disabilities," Hare told AFP.

"She's having problems in areas where (teachers) explain things to her, and ten seconds later she's forgotten what they said," she added of her daughter's struggles at school.

"She's receiving counselling to deal with her ."

The Hares are one of seven families suing Anglo-Swiss mining giant Xstrata over alleged lead toxicity in the town of Mt Isa, where a study this week estimated one child developed lead poisoning every nine days.

Blood tests revealed dangerously high levels of lead and 10 other metals in Stella's body, and her lawyers are set to argue this caused her health problems and can only be the fault of XStrata.

Stella first started showing symptoms three years ago, when she was just five years old, and Hare said it had been "very, very hard financially and emotionally".

"We had everything once, and now we're just living to make ends meet," she said.

A study published in the Medical Journal of Australia this week found about 11 percent of the 400 children born every year in the town had excessive lead in their blood, and there was little question about its origin.

"The evidence is clear. There is a single primary source of environmental lead in Mt Isa: the historic and ongoing mining and smelting activity," wrote study author Mark Taylor.

Xstrata has operated two copper mines and a copper smelter in Mt Isa since 2003, and denies being the source of the contamination.

"Mt Isa has one of the most intensive air quality monitoring systems of any city in Australia, which directs our smelters to shut down whenever emissions may potentially impact the community," said Xstrata spokesman Steve de Kruijff.

Lawyer Damian Scattini, who is representing Hare and other affected families, said the report was "yet another nail in the coffin of the defendants' contention that it's all naturally-occurring and benign".

"It's beyond question: the fact that the lead emanates from the mine and the smelter," he said.

For Hare, however, the case went beyond compensation or a question of sums.

"You can't put a price on a child," she said.

"For me it's about what they're doing with these kids. It's about justice for these children."

Explore further: Alcohol apps aimed at young

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

2nd lead poisoning case hits China, 1,300 sick

Aug 20, 2009

(AP) -- China detained two factory officials after 1,300 children were poisoned by pollution from a manganese processing plant, state media said Thursday, days after emissions from a lead smelter in another ...

Active submarine volcanoes found near Fiji

Jun 19, 2008

Several huge active submarine volcanoes, spreading ridges and rift zones have been discovered northeast of Fiji by a team of Australian and American scientists aboard the Marine National Facility Research ...

Overweight child removed from home

Jul 13, 2007

A mother in northwest England is fighting to get her 8-year-old daughter back after the town council removed the girl because she was extremely overweight.

Recommended for you

Alcohol apps aimed at young

1 hour ago

Apps with names like 'Let's get Wasted!' and 'Drink Thin' have led a James Cook University Professor to call for Government action on alcohol advertising on mobile devices.

Proponent of the G spot takes on a critic

1 hour ago

Ashley Furin had a "very satisfying" sex life with her husband, she said. Then, seven years into their relationship, she had "an experience that rocked me to my core." They had found her G spot.

Child-safety expert offers tips for holiday gifts

2 hours ago

Christmas is the most wonderful time of year, but it can quickly turn tragic if we're not careful, according to Bridget Boyd, MD, pediatric safety expert at Loyola University Health System.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Bob_B
5 / 5 (1) Aug 03, 2010
In the USA corporations are people too, and they are being threatened by individuals that try to cause them harm simply because they make money, and money is a corporations life-blood. Therefore this mother is trying to murder a person that provides for many others. In the USA, she would be put in prison for those thoughts and actions.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.