Brain study shows that the opinions of others matters

Jun 17, 2010
Brain

Simon Cowell may appear to relish arguing with his fellow judges when they disagree with him, but new research out today suggests that - at least at a neuronal level - he would find their agreement much more satisfying.

Researchers at the Wellcome Trust Centre for at UCL (University College London) in collaboration with Aarhus University in Denmark have found that the 'reward' area of the is activated when people agree with our opinions. The study, published today in the journal , suggests that scientists may be able to predict how much people can be influenced by the opinions of others on the basis of the level of activity in the reward area.

In a study of 28 volunteers in the UK, Professor Chris Frith and colleagues examined the effect that having experts agree with a person's opinions has on activity in their ventral striatum, the area of the brain associated with receiving rewards. Expert opinions about a piece of music produced more activity in this brain area when the subject shared the opinion. Expert opinions could also alter the amount of ventral striatum reward activity that receiving the music could produce - depending on how likely the person was to change his or her mind on the basis of those opinions.

Before the task, each volunteer was asked to provide a list of twenty songs that they liked, but did not currently own. They were asked to rate the songs on a scale of one to ten depending on how much they wanted the song (a score of ten indicating that they wanted the song very much).

The subjects were then placed in a (fMRI) scanner, which records brain activity by measuring related changes in . They were shown, one of the songs they had requested and one from a set of the previously unknown songs by Canadian and Scandinavian artists and were asked to indicate a preference between the two. The researchers then revealed to the volunteer which of the two songs the two 'experts' preferred.

When the reviewers agreed with the subject's own choice, the team found that the subject's ventral striatum, the area of the brain associated with rewards, became active. Activity in this area tended to be strongest when both reviewers agreed with the subject.

The researchers confirmed the role of the ventral striatum by randomly assigning tokens to the songs and measuring its effect on brain activity; the ventral striatum was most active when a token was awarded to a song chosen by the subject. (At the end of the task, the subject knew that they would receive the ten songs with the most tokens.)

"We all like getting rewards and this is reflected in in the ventral striatum," says first author Dr Daniel Campbell-Meiklejohn from the Centre of Functionally Integrative Neuroscience, Aarhus University, Denmark. "Our study shows that our brains respond in a similar way when others agree with us. One interpretation is that agreement with others can be as satisfying as other, more basic, rewards."

Once out of the scanner, the subjects were asked to rate their choices of songs again. The researchers found that the majority of people had changed their opinions dependent on the experts' views.

Seven people changed their opinions opposite to the reviewers - in other words, if the reviewers agreed with their choice, they tended to rate the song lower and vice versa.

However, most subjects appeared to be positively influenced - they were more likely to increase the rating of one of their songs if the reviewers also liked it and decrease the rating if the reviewers disliked it. In these subjects, the researchers found a link between activity in their ventral striatum when receiving the song as a reward and the opinions of reviewers: the more positively the song was reviewed, the greater the activity when receiving the song.

"It seems that not only are some people more influenced by the opinions of others, but by looking at activity in the brain, we can tell who those people are," says Professor Frith.

Explore further: Know the brain, and its axons, by the clothes they wear

More information: Campbell-Meiklejohn, DK et al. How the Opinion of Others Affects our Valuation of Objects. Current Biology; 17 Jun 2010

Related Stories

Impulsiveness linked to activity in brain's reward center

Dec 20, 2006

A new imaging study shows that our brains react with varying sensitivity to reward and suggests that people most susceptible to impulse -- those who need to buy it, eat it, or have it, now -- show the greatest activity in a r ...

Praise = money?

Apr 23, 2008

Why are we nice to others? One answer provided by social psychologists is because it pays off. A social psychological theory stated that we do something nice to others for a good reputation or social approval just like we ...

Recommended for you

Know the brain, and its axons, by the clothes they wear

Apr 18, 2014

(Medical Xpress)—It is widely know that the grey matter of the brain is grey because it is dense with cell bodies and capillaries. The white matter is almost entirely composed of lipid-based myelin, but ...

Turning off depression in the brain

Apr 17, 2014

Scientists have traced vulnerability to depression-like behaviors in mice to out-of-balance electrical activity inside neurons of the brain's reward circuit and experimentally reversed it – but there's ...

Rapid whole-brain imaging with single cell resolution

Apr 17, 2014

A major challenge of systems biology is understanding how phenomena at the cellular scale correlate with activity at the organism level. A concerted effort has been made especially in the brain, as scientists are aiming to ...

User comments : 9

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

marjon
not rated yet Jun 17, 2010
we can tell who those people are,"

The next step for creating the subservient race.
getgoa
not rated yet Jun 17, 2010
I don't know if all this research is very rewarding, but it is very controversial to know all these facts in my opinion;distancing what is sacred to what is relevant is very dangerous.
bottomlesssoul
not rated yet Jun 18, 2010
@marjon
we can tell who those people are,"

The next step for creating the subservient race.
Or, use that information to help that person identify this personal weakness and so maybe arm themselves against it.

And maybe withhold voting rights and ability to run for public office until they can establish they can think for themselves ;-)
Canman
not rated yet Jun 18, 2010
Prediction: next 50 years, neuroscience revolution and impact on society will be at the same level as industrial revolution, maybe more.
marjon
not rated yet Jun 18, 2010
@marjon
we can tell who those people are,"

The next step for creating the subservient race.
Or, use that information to help that person identify this personal weakness and so maybe arm themselves against it.

And maybe withhold voting rights and ability to run for public office until they can establish they can think for themselves ;-)

Why bother voting? The people 'who can think for themselves' can be in charge. We will call them the alphas.
Anthony_Casey
not rated yet Jun 18, 2010
The implications of this and subsequent research is, to put it mildly, astounding.

Imagine drugs or nano-treatments that stimulate this region of the brain/response creating a submissive population.

Or imagine a brighter future. One where a lack or individualistic opinions is thought of as depression is today. We could have drugs/treatments that help sheep-like people feel less rewarded for being agreed with by supposed experts, giving them more confidence in their own opinions and ideas.
Titok_Kurniawan
not rated yet Jun 19, 2010
"It seems that not only are some people more influenced by the opinions of others, but by looking at activity in the brain, we can tell who those people are," says Professor Frith.That statement is very interesting for me. With the progress of science and technology all can be disolved.But of the most interesting is about endorphins because my activities are always associated with endorphins hormone.Please to be published an article about the endorphins. Thank you in advance.
Skultch
4 / 5 (1) Jun 19, 2010
Evolutionarily speaking, experts = parents and small group leaders. Small group cohesion was also advantageous. This article suggests that we evolved to learn from "experts" more than others and be rewarded by being agreeable. This should not be a surprise.

I don't see how something so fundamental to our learning could be "easily" controlled by drugs without serious negative side effects, but I'm no neuroscientist. Also, the world probably needs followers to function. That is all.
HealingMindN
not rated yet Jul 12, 2010
I don't see how something so fundamental to our learning could be "easily" controlled by drugs without serious negative side effects, but I'm no neuroscientist. Also, the world probably needs followers to function. That is all.


Reminds me of that slave race run by the dominion who gave them a regular dose of "reward" to control them on Deep Space 9.

More news stories

Filipino tests negative for Middle East virus

A Filipino nurse who tested positive for the Middle East virus has been found free of infection in a subsequent examination after he returned home, Philippine health officials said Saturday.

Study says we're over the hill at 24

(Medical Xpress)—It's a hard pill to swallow, but if you're over 24 years of age you've already reached your peak in terms of your cognitive motor performance, according to a new Simon Fraser University study.

NASA's space station Robonaut finally getting legs

Robonaut, the first out-of-this-world humanoid, is finally getting its space legs. For three years, Robonaut has had to manage from the waist up. This new pair of legs means the experimental robot—now stuck ...

Ex-Apple chief plans mobile phone for India

Former Apple chief executive John Sculley, whose marketing skills helped bring the personal computer to desktops worldwide, says he plans to launch a mobile phone in India to exploit its still largely untapped ...

Egypt archaeologists find ancient writer's tomb

Egypt's minister of antiquities says a team of Spanish archaeologists has discovered two tombs in the southern part of the country, one of them belonging to a writer and containing a trove of artifacts including reed pens ...

Airbnb rental site raises $450 mn

Online lodging listings website Airbnb inked a $450 million funding deal with investors led by TPG, a source close to the matter said Friday.