Benefits of shared electronic patient records more modest than anticipated

Jun 16, 2010

The benefits of the Summary Care Record (SCR) scheme, introduced as part of the National Programme for IT (NPfIT), appear more modest than anticipated, according to a study published in the British Medical Journal today.

The findings are based on an independent evaluation by researchers at University College London and come as the new coalition government announces a review of the scheme.

The Summary Care Record is an electronic summary of patient medical records accessible over a secure internet connection by authorised NHS staff. In 2008, the English government began to roll out the scheme nationally with the aim of improving the quality, safety and efficiency of care, especially in .

But the scheme has proved controversial with a range of alleged benefits and drawbacks, from better clinical care and fewer to high costs and threats to confidentiality.

Researchers set out to evaluate the scheme over a three-year period (2007-2010). They analysed data across three sites, including over 400,000 encounters in participating out-of-hours and walk-in-centres and 140 interviews with policymakers, managers, clinicians and software suppliers involved in the scheme.

By early 2010, 1.5 million SCRs had been created, but the researchers found that creating SCRs and supporting their adoption and use was a complex, technically challenging and labour-intensive process which occurred much more slowly than originally planned.

In participating primary care out-of-hours and walk-in centres, they show that an SCR was accessed in 4% of all encounters and in 21% when an SCR was available. These figures were rising in some but not all sites.

Individual clinicians accessed available SCRs between 0 and 84% of the time. This varied considerably depending on setting, the type of clinician and their level of experience.

When accessed, SCRs seemed to support better quality care and increase clinician confidence in some encounters. There was no direct evidence of improved safety, but findings were consistent with a positive impact on preventing medication errors.

The research team found that SCRs sometimes contained incomplete or inaccurate data, but they did not see any cases where this led to harm because clinicians used their judgement when interpreting such data and took account of other sources of information. SCR use was not associated with shorter consultations, nor did it appear to reduce hospital admission - benefits which were anticipated by policymakers.

The evaluation also showed that successful introduction of SCRs required collaboration between stakeholders from different worlds, with different values, priorities, and ways of working. The authors say that these differences may have accounted for many of the misunderstandings and frictions occurring at the operational level. And they suggest that the programme's fortunes will depend on the ability "to bridge the different institutional worlds of different stakeholders, align their conflicting logics, and mobilise implementation effort."

They conclude: "This evaluation has shown that some progress has been made in introducing shared electronic summary records in England and that some benefits have occurred. However, significant social and technical barriers to the widespread adoption and use of such records remain and their benefits to date appear more subtle and contingent than early policy documents predicted."

In two accompanying papers, also published on bmj.com today, experts debate whether summary care records have the potential to do more harm than good. Mark Walport, Director of the Wellcome Trust believes that the national electronic database of patient records will make valuable contributions to better care, but Ross Anderson, Professor of Security Engineering at the University of Cambridge, argues that it is both unnecessary and unlawful.

Explore further: Medtronic spends $350M on another European deal

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Electronic health records may lower malpractice settlements

Nov 25, 2008

Use of electronic health records (EHRs) may help reduce paid malpractice settlements for physicians, according to a new study. The study, which appeared in the November 24 issue of Archives of Internal Medicine, showed a tren ...

No more dithering on e-health

Mar 01, 2010

Canada is lagging behind many countries in the use of electronic health records and it is critical that the country's medical and political leaders set targets for universal adoption, states an editorial in CMAJ.

Recommended for you

Cold cash just keeps washing in from ALS challenge

7 hours ago

In the couple of hours it took an official from the ALS Association to return a reporter's call for comment, the group's ubiquitous "ice bucket challenge" had brought in a few million more dollars.

Medtronic spends $350M on another European deal

23 hours ago

U.S. medical device maker Medtronic is building stronger ties to Europe, a couple months after announcing a $42.9 billion acquisition that involves moving its main executive offices across the Atlantic, where it can get a ...

Mind over matter for people with disabilities

Aug 26, 2014

People with serious physical disabilities are unable to do the everyday things that most of us take for granted despite having the will – and the brainpower – to do so. This is changing thanks to European ...

Ukraine's former world's tallest man dies

Aug 25, 2014

Ukraine's tallest man, who briefly held the world record but gave it up to live as a recluse, has died due to complications from the condition that saw him never stop growing, local media reported Monday.

User comments : 0