Different dosing, administration of corticosteroids for severe COPD shows comparable outcomes

Jun 15, 2010

In contrast to clinical guidelines, new research finds that the vast major­ity of patients hospitalized for severe symptoms of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) were initially treated with higher doses of corticoste­roids administered intravenously, with analysis indicating that these patients had outcomes comparable to patients who received the recommended and lower-cost, less-invasive treatment of low doses of steroids administered orally, according to a study in the June 16 issue of JAMA.

COPD is the fourth leading cause of death in the United States, affects more than 6 percent of adults in the U.S., and accounts for $32 billion in direct health care costs. "In 2006, there were approximately 600,000 for acute exacerbation COPD, making this 1 of the 10 leading causes of hospital­ization nationwide," the authors write. "Systemic corticosteroids are beneficial for patients hospitalized with acute exacerbation of COPD; however, their optimal dose and route of administration are uncertain."

Peter K. Lindenauer, M.D., M.Sc., of Baystate Medi­cal Center, Springfield, Mass., and colleagues investigated the use of cortico­ among patients hospitalized for acute exacerbation of COPD at 414 U.S. hospitals in 2006 and 2007. The researchers com­pared the outcomes of those initially treated with low doses of steroids ad­ministered orally to those initially administered steroids at higher doses intravenously during the first 2 hospital days. Among the outcomes the researchers analyzed included a composite measure of treatment failure, defined as the initiation of after the second hospital day, inpatient mor­tality, or readmission for acute exacerbation of COPD within 30 days of discharge.

Of 79,985 patients, 73,765 patients (92 percent) were initially treated with higher doses of steroids administered intravenously, while 6,220 (8 percent) began low doses of steroids given orally. A total of 1.4 percent of patients initially treated with intravenous steroids died during the hospitalization and 10.9 percent experienced the com­posite treatment failure outcome, whereas 1.0 percent of orally treated patients died during the hospitalization and 10.3 percent experienced the compos­ite outcome. A total of 1,356 patients (22 percent) initially treated with low-dose oral steroids were later switched to in­travenous therapy.

The researchers found that in analysis that adjusted for various factors including patient, hospital, and physician characteris­tics, the risk of treatment failure among patients given low doses of steroids orally was not sig­nificantly different from those treated with high-dose steroids intravenously. Also, pa­tients treated with low doses of ste­roids administered orally had shorter lengths of hospital stay and lower costs.

"In this large observational study, we found that, in sharp contrast to the rec­ommendations contained in leading clinical guidelines, the vast major­ity of patients hospitalized for acute exacerbation of COPD were initially treated with high doses of corticoste­roids administered intravenously. This practice does not appear to be associ­ated with any measurable clinical ben­efit and at the same time exposes patients to the risks and inconvenience of an intravenous line, potentially unnec­essarily high doses of steroids, greater hospital costs, and longer lengths of stay," the authors write.

"In light of the greater risks and higher costs as­sociated with high-dose intravenous treatment, opportunities may exist to improve care by promoting greater use of low-dose steroids given orally. Given the large numbers of patients hospital­ized with COPD each year in the United States, a clinical trial comparing these 2 approaches to management would be valuable."

Explore further: Experts question value of common superbug control practices

More information: JAMA. 2010;303[23]:2359-2367.

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Evidence lacking to guide treatment for sudden hearing loss

Jun 18, 2007

Although steroids are the most widely used treatment for sudden hearing loss, little scientific evidence supports their use or that of any other therapies for this condition, according to a systematic review and meta-analysis ...

Recommended for you

New analysis questions use of acute hemodialysis treatment

12 hours ago

A common approach to treating kidney failure by removing waste products from the blood did not improve survival chances for people who suddenly developed the condition, in an analysis led by experts at the University of Pittsburgh ...

WHO: West Africa Ebola death toll rises to 1,350 (Update)

12 hours ago

Riot police and soldiers acting on their president's orders used scrap wood and barbed wire to seal off 50,000 people inside their Liberian slum Wednesday, trying to contain the Ebola outbreak that has killed ...

User comments : 0