Survey highlights major Canada-US differences in people in middle age

Jun 02, 2010

Middle-aged Canadians are much less worried about the future than their American counterparts, some of whom are close to panic, says an Alberta researcher who has just finished a survey in both countries. And she says the differing attitudes today may foreshadow growing differences between the two countries as that cohort move into old age.

Susan McDaniel, a sociology researcher and expert, has been working on a comparative study of Canadians and Americans in late middle age, between the ages of 50 and 64. She presents some of the findings at the 2010 Congress for the Humanities and Social Sciences taking place at Montreal's Concordia University.

McDaniel says that by coincidence, researchers started doing interviews when the recession hit in 2008. Those interviews highlighted huge differences in the attitudes and expectations of Canadians and Americans in the same age group.

"The Americans were generally close to a panicked state," says McDaniel, explaining that the bursting of the housing bubble and the decline of the had the entire cohort worried that their plans for retirement were shot. Health care was another major concern, particularly for people who feared they might lose health insurance if they lost their job.

"Essentially, they were saying 'I'm feeling I've lost control, I can't plan'," she says, adding that researchers were surprised because that attitude runs counter to the image of Americans as being independent people responsible for their lives and their future. Canadians, on the other hand, were worried - but not panicked. And overall, they continued to feel they had some control over their lives.

The 50-to-64-year-old age group is a sandwich generation, often caring for elderly parents on the one hand, and still responsible for their children on the other. In the meantime, they are trying to save for retirement, which for many is now on the horizon.

One thing the study found was that more middle-aged Americans than Canadians are living in multi-generational households. McDaniel says the study was not able to identify why; however she wondered whether it was an effect of the housing bubble, as children who have lost a house moved back in with their parents.

The study also showed how the disrupted expectations for old age - and how there's a big difference in expectations between Canada and the U.S.

Americans, says McDaniel, often reported that their expectations for retirement had been shattered. Canadians, however, felt that while some things might be more difficult, socialized medicine would keep them from going bankrupt.

McDaniel says that as this cohort moves into old age, differences and expectations will play out.
If the differences in the 50-to-64-year-old age group continue as the cohort ages, she says the experience of old age could end up being very different in Canada than in the U.S.

Most people looking at old age today, she adds, base their views on the experiences of people who are old now - people who came of age when jobs were plentiful, housing cheap and diversity rare.

"To build our thinking on the basis of what's going on with these people today is wrong," she says.

Explore further: Poverty rate drops for the first time since 2006

Provided by Canadian Federation for the Humanities and Social Sciences

4 /5 (7 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Canadians lead longer, healthier lives than Americans

Apr 29, 2010

Compared to their neighbours south of the border, Canadians live longer, healthier lives. Research published in BioMed Central's open access journal Population Health Metrics has found this disparity between the two countr ...

Older people are nation's happiest

Apr 16, 2008

Americans grow happier as they grow older, according to a University of Chicago study that is one of the most thorough examinations of happiness ever done in America.

New economic woes hit boomers, seniors hardest

Nov 24, 2008

Millions of older Americans stand at the epicenter of the current financial crisis and the implications must be confronted, said experts today during a symposium at The Gerontological Society of America's (GSA) 61st Annual ...

Older Americans: How they are faring in the recession

Sep 16, 2009

(PhysOrg.com) -- Older Americans have weathered the financial crisis relatively well, although many now expect to work longer than they did just a year ago, according to a University of Michigan study released on Capitol ...

Recommended for you

Poverty rate drops for the first time since 2006

8 hours ago

The poverty rate in the United States has dropped for the first time since 2006, bringing a bit of encouraging news about the nation's economy as President Barack Obama and Congress gear up for the November elections.

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Phideaux
not rated yet Jun 02, 2010
This survey answers everything except for who, what, when, where, how, and why.
gmurphy
5 / 5 (2) Jun 02, 2010
This survey shows just how effective a supportive social infrastructure is at maintaining a higher quality of life for the recipients.
slaveunit
5 / 5 (4) Jun 02, 2010
@gmurphy, couldnt agree more here in australia we have troubles with our health system but no one goes broke for medical costs. the insane commentary re american health care shows how many americans have been hoodwinked by corporate interests who bandy the word comunism around.
yet if you look at cuba the health outcomes there are within a few percent of the US and they spend a fraction on health.
Americans are scared cos they have spent there whole lives saying screw the community i wont pay taxes to govt systems and they know when things go bad for them no one will help them and they will end up on the street where people will step over them as they die there and do nothing.