Flexible treatment intervention associated with greater improvement in anxiety symptoms

May 18, 2010

An intervention in primary care settings that allowed a choice of cognitive behavior therapy, medication, or both, along with computer-assisted treatment support for patients with common anxiety disorders, resulted in greater improvement in anxiety symptoms and functional disability compared to usual care, according to a study in the May 19 issue of JAMA, a theme issue on mental health.

Peter Roy-Byrne, M.D., of the Uni­versity of Washington School of Medicine, Seattle, presented the findings of the study at a JAMA media briefing on .

"Improving the quality of mental health care requires continued efforts to move evidence-based treatments of proven efficacy into real-world practice settings with wide variability in patient characteristics and clinician skill. The effectiveness of one approach, collaborative care, is well established for primary care depres­sion, but has been infrequently studied for anxiety disorders, despite their common occurrence in primary care," the authors write.

Dr. Roy-Byrne and colleagues conducted a study to examine whether a flexible treatment delivery intervention in primary care would be better than usual care (UC) in reduc­ing symptoms of anxiety and in improving certain measures of functioning, health-related quality of life, and quality of care de­livered for the 4 most common anxiety disorders—panic disorder, , social anxiety disorder, and posttraumatic stress dis­order (PTSD). The intervention the researchers designed, Coordinated Anxiety Learning and Management (CALM), allowed choice of (CBT), medi­cation, or both; included real-time Web-based outcomes monitoring to optimize treat­ment decisions; and a computer-assisted program to optimize delivery of CBT by non­expert care managers who also assisted primary care clinicians in promoting adherence and optimizing medications. "In this way, CALM seeks to accommodate the complexity of real-world clinical settings, while maximiz­ing fidelity to the evidence-base in the context of a broad range of patients, cli­nicians, practice settings, and payers," the authors write.

The randomized controlled effectiveness trial of CALM compared with usual care took place in 17 primary care clinics in 4 U.S. cities. Between June 2006 and April 2008, 1,004 patients with anxiety disorders (with or without major depression), ages 18 to 75 years, were enrolled and subsequently received treatment for 3 to 12 months. Follow-up assessments at 6,12, and 18 months after the beginning of the trial were completed in October 2009. Anxiety symptoms were measured with the 12 item Brief Symptom Inventory (BSI-12).

The researchers found that the scores on measures of anxiety symptoms were significantly lower for patients in the intervention group at 6 months, 12 months and 18 months. "At 12 months, response and remission rates (CALM vs. UC) were 63.66 percent vs. 44.68 percent, and 51.49 percent vs. 33.28 percent, with a number needed to treat of 5.27 for response and 5.50 for remission."

"The flexibility of treatment (e.g., varia­tion in number and type of sessions, and in criteria for continuing further treat­ment, use of both telephone and in-person contact), the targeting of multiple disorders, and the clinical ef­fectiveness across a range of patients and clinics suggest that the CALM treat­ment delivery model should be broadly applicable in primary care. However, implementation of this model will re­quire reimbursement mechanisms for care management that are not cur­rently available," the authors write.

"Nonetheless, the success of the model tested here demonstrates that addressing mul­tiple common mental disorders in the context of one delivery model is fea­sible and effective and could serve as a template for the development of uni­fied approaches to management of the multiple psychiatric comorbidities that are the rule rather than the exception in both the general population and in clinical practice."

Explore further: Growing up poor affects adults' sense of control, impulsiveness when faced with economic uncertainty

More information: JAMA. 2010;303[19]:1921-1928.

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Anxiety disorders surprisingly common yet often untreated

Mar 12, 2007

A new study by researchers led by Kurt Kroenke, M.D., of the Indiana University School of Medicine and the Regenstrief Institute, Inc. reports that nearly 20 percent of patients seen by primary care physicians have at least ...

Program helps improve management of chronic pain

Mar 24, 2009

Patients with chronic pain who took part in a collaborative care intervention that included patient and clinician education and symptom monitoring and feedback to the primary care physician had improvements in pain-related ...

Recommended for you

Research proves physical, psychological power of love

7 hours ago

New Western-led research says pausing to think about your romantic partner generates 'good stress' and adds an energy boost to your day. The study, Energized by love: Thinking about romantic relationships increases positive ...

User comments : 0