Health care reform 'important' even to those who want new law repealed

Apr 13, 2010

Fifty-eight percent of Americans (96 percent of Republicans, 10 percent of Democrats and 54 percent of Independents) support repealing the health care reform legislation that was signed into law by President Barack Obama in March, according to a new national survey conducted April 6 - 10 by researchers from Indiana University's Center for Health Policy and Professionalism Research (CHPPR).

Americans 18 to 34 years of age were most supportive of repealing the legislation with more than 70 percent supporting its repeal.

"This is somewhat surprising given that some of the most vocal opposition to reform in the past came from older Americans while younger individuals seemed less opposed," said Aaron Carroll, M.D., director of CHPPR. "While at first glance these findings may seem to tell a clear story, results from other portions of the survey demonstrate that the repeal question may be less about actual policy goals than previously thought," he added.

"Many have assumed that those advocating for repeal in polls wanted Congress to take no action on until the law was abolished. However, we find that 48 percent of Americans actually are supportive of Congress continuing to work on reforms as opposed to focusing on any other topic," said Dr. Carroll. "In fact, 51 percent of those who supported repealing the legislation also were in favor of Congress continuing to work on health care system reforms."

When asked how imperative they thought it was for Congress to work on "establishment of a public option that would give individuals a choice between government-provided or private health insurance" in the upcoming legislative session, 67 percent of Americans rated this as important.

This finding is even more striking given the fact that 59 percent of all those in favor of repeal rated the public option as important. Moreover, so did 67 percent of all and 59 percent of all Independents.

"It may be that the repeal question is more of a surrogate for whether people support the platform of the Republican party," said Dr. Carroll, "rather than how they want Congress to devote its time. Further work is needed to see if that is true."

CHPPR will be conducting a follow-up survey to try and answer this question.

In addition to gauging public support for the repeal of the health care legislation, the current survey also asked about areas on which should focus in the upcoming legislative session. Respondents showed overwhelming support, regardless of political affiliation, for Congressional attention to federal deficit reduction (82 percent) as well as reform of financial system regulation (73 percent) in the upcoming legislative session. Falling lowest on the list of issues was addressing climate change, with only 32 percent of Americans finding this to be an issue of importance. Other topics polled included reforms to the pharmaceutical industry (60 percent), the medical malpractice system (55 percent), and immigration (54 percent).

Explore further: Doctor describes importance of interpretation in patient care

More information: A full report on the survey can be found at chppr.iupui.edu/research/repealsurvey.html

Provided by Indiana University School of Medicine

5 /5 (1 vote)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Prioritizing health-care reform components

Feb 06, 2009

Faced with a barrage of pressing issues, the Obama administration has placed health-care reform high on its agenda. The timing bodes well for change, according to Aaron E. Carroll, M.D., director of the Indiana University ...

Recommended for you

Obesity and stress pack a double hit for health

2 hours ago

If you're overweight, you may be at greater risk for stress-related diseases like type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease and cancer, according to a new study by Brandeis University.

Sales influence consumer food shopping habits

4 hours ago

(HealthDay)—Consumers are more likely to buy high-calorie foods (HCF), but not low-calorie foods (LCF) on sale, according to a study published in the U.S. Center for Disease Control and Prevention's Preventing Ch ...

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

wiyosaya
5 / 5 (2) Apr 13, 2010
To me, this article suggests that the way to "fix" the new law is not to vote out democrats and let republicans repeal the reform, but to enhance the reform with a public option. IMHO, if the recently passed "reform" is repealed, then it will likely be decades before any real reform is passed - given the current political climate.
LariAnn
2 / 5 (1) Apr 13, 2010
Not surprising to me that the 18-34 years of age group is most supportive of repeal. They are the ones that will pay the most for the least, as most of them are healthy and won't get anywhere near their money's worth for the forced health tax they have to pay into the system. No one wants to have their hard-earned money taken from them by force, especially not young people who might have better things to do with their money and energy.
MikeLisanke
5 / 5 (1) Apr 16, 2010
Finding that people want real health care reform is not surprising. It would be wonderful if health care reform meant something other than guaranteeing health care industry profits. Its clear to almost anyone that this was primary to negotiations with the health care insurance industry.
Nobody has addressed the cause of health care costs which is the reason a public health care option was ruled out. We need more primary health care providers and less use of expensive unnecessary diagnostics (used by physicians to prevent malpractice cases). IMHO.