Study: Chapter 13 bankruptcy little help in saving homes

Mar 29, 2010

Current chapter 13 bankruptcy laws do little to help filers save their homes from foreclosure, according to a study published in the Journal of Legal Studies.

The research, conducted by Michelle White of the University of California, San Diego, and Ning Zhu of UC Davis, finds that only about 1 percent of filers who would have otherwise defaulted are actually able to save their homes under chapter 13. This is despite the fact that 96 percent of chapter 13 filers are homeowners—an indication that it is seen as a “save your home” procedure, the authors say.

Chapter 13 bankruptcy is designed to help homeowners save their homes in three ways. First, it delays foreclosure proceedings and gives homeowners a chance to catch up on overdue payments. Second, it allows judges to eliminate burdensome lender fees. Third, it enables judges to partially or completely discharge credit card and other unsecured debts. This so-called credit card subsidy is designed to free up money that filers can then put toward their mortgages.

Using bankruptcy data from Delaware, White and Zhu constructed a model to determine whether the credit card subsidy actually helps filers avoid foreclosure. They found that for one-third of filers, the money freed up by the subsidy is not enough to save their homes, and many other filers have enough income to save their homes even without the subsidy. White and Zhu estimate that 85 percent of the credit card subsidy dollars go to people who could have saved their homes anyway. The proportion of filers who would have lost their homes but were able to save them thanks to the subsidy turns out to be around 1 percent.

“Overall, the credit card is not an effective program for reducing ,” the researchers conclude.

The Cramdown Effect

Under current law, judges cannot change the terms of mortgage loans. But in recent months, lawmakers have introduced several bills that would give judges the power to restructure or “cram down” mortgage debts in chapter 13. White and Zhu were able to tweak their model to estimate the impact of cram-down authority if it were to become law.

Cram-down authority would allow mortgage debt to be split into two parts: a secured portion equal to the market value of the home, and an unsecured portion equal to the remaining principle after the home value is subtracted. Judges would have the option of discharging the unsecured portion of the mortgage.

According to the model, the proportion of filers who save their homes when they otherwise would have defaulted goes from 1 percent to 10 percent under cram down. “For these debtors, cram down reduces future mortgage payments by an average of $134,000,” White and Zhou write.

The price tag for banks would be substantial. White and Zhu estimate that cram-down authority would cost lenders around $30 billion.

The most recent cram-down legislation was defeated in the House of Representatives last December.

Explore further: Economist probes the high cost of health care

More information: Michelle J. White and Ning Zhu, “Saving Your Home in Chapter 13 Bankruptcy.” Journal of Legal Studies. 2010 39:1, 33-61.

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Study: Bankruptcy rates reflect policy, not people

Jun 22, 2009

What do high bankruptcy rates in states like Tennessee and Utah tell us about the people that live in those places? Not much, according to a new 50-state bankruptcy study published in the latest issue of the Journal of La ...

Recommended for you

Economist probes the high cost of health care

Mar 27, 2015

When Zack Cooper arrived at Yale as assistant professor of public health and economics, he gained access to a first-of-its-kind dataset. Working with the non-profit Health Care Cost Institute, Cooper and ...

Cash remains king in Chile but its days could be numbered

Mar 26, 2015

For more than a year now, Chileans have endured a crisis of cash access. Despite global moves toward new forms of payment such as contactless and mobile transfers, the crisis in Chile highlights the continuing ...

Will you ever pay off your student loan?

Mar 25, 2015

Would-be participants of higher education must be given full and transparent advice before they accumulate debts as students that follow them into the workplace, according to a report published in the International Journal of ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Mar 30, 2010

7 days a week, Monday-Sunday 8am- 5pm. If we are on the phone, leave a message and a good time to return the call, or email us at

Bankruptcy can bring your relief in many ways, including:

* Brings Debt Relief
* Stop Bill consolidation
* Stop Creditor Harassment
* Stop Mortgage Foreclosure
* Get rid of judgments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.