60 minutes of exercise per day needed for middle-aged women to maintain weight

Mar 23, 2010 by LORI J. SHANKS
60 minutes of exercise per day needed for middle-aged women to maintain weight

(PhysOrg.com) -- If a middle-aged or older woman with a normal body mass index wants to maintain her weight over an extended period, she must engage in the equivalent of 60 minutes per day of physical activity at a moderate intensity, according to new findings by Harvard researchers at Brigham and Women’s Hospital (BWH).

“There is plenty of research on treating overweight and — that is, looking at strategies for weight loss among overweight or obese persons, but very little research on preventing weight gain in the first place. Most overweight and obese persons who lose weight do not successfully maintain their weight loss over time, and so, from a public health perspective, preventing that initial weight gain is important,” said I-Min Lee, an associate professor of epidemiology at Harvard School of Public Health (HSPH), epidemiologist in the Division of Preventive Medicine at BWH, and associate professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School.

The findings are published in the latest issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association.

Lee and colleagues analyzed data reported from more than 34,000 healthy U.S. women in the Women’s Health Study over 13 years to examine the relationship between the level of daily and weight change over time. Women in the study reported their leisure-time physical activities every two to three years. Each time that physical activity was assessed, women were divided into three groups, according to the amount of time they spent engaged in physical activity.

The most active group of women spent the equivalent of 420 minutes a week (60 minutes a day) or more engaged in moderate-intensity physical activity. The second group engaged in the equivalent of at least 150 but less than 420 minutes a week of moderate-intensity physical activity, and the least active group engaged in the equivalent of less than 150 minutes a week of moderate-intensity physical activity. An example of a moderate-intensity physical activity is brisk walking.

These three levels of physical activity were chosen based on the 2008 federal guidelines for physical activity, which recommended at least 150 minutes a week of moderate-intensity physical activity for health, and a 2002 Institute of Medicine report on recommended dietary intakes, which suggested that 60 minutes a day of moderate-intensity physical activity was needed to prevent being overweight, although the scientific basis for this level of activity has been questioned.

Over the duration of the 13-year study, the average weight of participants increased by 6 pounds, which is a rate of weight gain similar to that of comparably aged women in the general population. Compared with the most active women, both the group physically active for 150 to less than 420 minutes a week, and the group physically active for less than 150 minutes a week gained significantly more weight than the most active group. The two less-active groups also were significantly more likely to gain at least 5 pounds, compared with the most-active group.

Researchers discovered that the findings differed significantly, according to women’s (BMI). Physical activity was associated with less weight gain only among women with a normal BMI, which is less than 25. An average U.S. woman who is 5 feet, 5 inches tall must weigh less than 150 pounds to have a normal BMI. Among heavier women, physical activity — at least, within the levels that study participants undertook — was not related to less weight gain.

In this study, researchers were able to identify a group of “successful weight maintainers.” These were women who started with a normal BMI and managed to maintain their weight, gaining less than 5 pounds at each weight assessment, throughout the study. These women, 13 percent of participants, consistently engaged in physical activity that was the equivalent of 60 minutes a day of moderate-intensity physical activity.

Researchers concluded that:

• Among middle-aged and older women consuming a usual diet with no calorie restriction, moderate-intensity physical activity for 60 minutes a day is needed to maintain normal BMI and prevent weight gain over time.

• The 150 minutes a week of moderate-intensity physical activity, which can be achieved by 30 minutes a day, five days a week, and which is recommended by the federal government, while clearly sufficient based on data from many studies to lower the risk of developing chronic diseases, is insufficient for prevention, without restricting caloric intake.

• Among women who are already overweight or obese, physical activity — at least, at levels carried out by participants in this study — is not related to weight change, emphasizing the importance of controlling caloric intake for weight maintenance in this group.

“These findings shouldn’t obscure the fact that for health, any physical activity is good, and more is better,” Lee emphasizes. “It is important to remember that weight is only one aspect of health. Many studies have shown that being physically active for even 30 minutes a day, five days a week, significantly reduces the risk of developing many chronic diseases, such as cardiovascular disease, some cancers, and type 2 diabetes.”

Explore further: Computer screening could help patients and healthcare

More information: JAMA. 2010;303[12]:1173-1179.

Related Stories

How much are you really exercising?

Oct 04, 2008

People struggling with obesity often underestimate how many calories they are actually consuming, which can hinder weight loss efforts. It should follow that the same person would overestimate the amount of exercise they're ...

Guidelines urge physical activity during pregnancy

Oct 08, 2008

Moderate physical activity during pregnancy does not contribute to low birth weight, premature birth or miscarriage and may actually reduce the risk of complications, according to a Michigan State University professor who ...

Recommended for you

High-calorie and low-nutrient foods in kids' TV

9 hours ago

Fruits and vegetables are often displayed in the popular Swedish children's TV show Bolibompa, but there are also plenty of high-sugar foods. A new study from the University of Gothenburg explores how food is portrayed in ...

Chemical companies shore up supplement science

9 hours ago

As evidence mounts showing the potential health benefits of probiotics, antioxidants and other nutritional compounds, more and more people are taking supplements. And the chemical industry is getting in on the action. But ...

More Americans in their golden years are going hungry

9 hours ago

In a country as wealthy as the United States, it may come as a surprise that one in 12 seniors do not have access to adequate food due to lack of money or other financial resources. They are food insecure.

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Husky
5 / 5 (2) Mar 23, 2010
well, that is not cool! Red Queen syndrome, doing all the running you can just to stay in place...now i would like to see a similar study revolving around High Intensity Interval Training with middle aged women. Couldn't that save them a bunch of time while maintaining the weight?
AlejoHausner
1 / 5 (1) Mar 23, 2010
This is bad science. It infers causality from correlation: women who exercised tended to be women who did not gain weight, but that does not mean that the exercise CAUSED the weight loss.

In case I sound pedantic, I should point out that the study actually goes against a lot of good research about exercise and weight loss. The consistent finding in the literature is that exercise does NOT help with weight loss.

The causality is probably backwards: thin people probably have an inability to turn the calories they've eaten into fat (perhaps they are deficient in insulin). Hence their body has an excess of calories to burn off, and they can't help but be physically active. On the other hand, fat people tend to immediately turn their food into fat (they have excess insulin). This leaves them with no free calories, and a natural propensity to move less. Their bodies have no energy to spare.

In other words, thinness causes exercise, not the other way around.

Alejo Hausner
Husky
not rated yet Mar 23, 2010
ah, but exercise does help people with diabetes to get a grip on their insuline response, especially vigorous exercise
snowman95
not rated yet Mar 23, 2010
Another example of how out of touch researchers are with the lives people lead. Get real! Virtually no one gets that much exercise, or has the time or energy to. At the end of a hard day's work it won't happen, except for the few who have physical jobs or who get a high from exercise. Give us practical information, please. It's always been said that only a combination of diet and exercise works. 150 minutes of exercise per week is hard enough. Clearly, as we age we must eat less.

More news stories