Surgery halves death risk for stroke patients versus 'stent' treatment

Feb 26, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- People at high risk of having a stroke are half as likely to have a stroke or die following surgery to repair damage to an artery in the neck, rather than ‘stenting’ treatment, according to UCL research published in the Lancet today.

These findings emerged from a major trial carried out at the UCL Institute of Neurology, which was funded by the Medical Research Council and The Stroke Association.

‘Stenting’ is a treatment that relieves pressure in the carotid artery using a wire mesh tube or ‘stent’, which is then fed through to the neck using a in the groin. It was introduced as an alternative to , in which an incision in the neck is made directly to the artery, but which has been known to increase a person’s risk of heart attack.

The results of the study showed that the rate of stroke or death within 30 days of treatment for patients was 7.4 per cent in those treated by stenting, compared with 3.4 per cent in those treated by surgery. Until now there has not been any conclusive proof over which method was safer and offered the lower risk of complications.

Both groups involved in this study, involving over 1,700 patients, had a very low rate of of less than 0.5 per cent. Patients were selected who had already had a ‘mini stroke’ and were therefore at a much higher risk of going on to have further strokes.

The trial forms part of the International Carotid Stenting Study, which aims to compare two forms of treatment designed to lower a person’s risk of stroke which is significantly increased by the narrowing of the in the neck and caused by cholesterol.

Martin Brown, Professor of Stroke Medicine at the UCL Institute of Neurology and Consultant Neurologist at the National Hospital for Neurology and , said: “The results of this trial demonstrate convincingly for the first time that surgery is a safer option for patients than stenting when dealing with patients at risk of stroke. As a result, we believe that surgery should therefore be the treatment of choice in these circumstances. However, there will still be a role for carotid stenting, particularly for those who are not suitable candidates to undergo surgery.” A second study funded by The Stroke Association has shown, using MRI images, that in addition to the increased risk of symptoms from stroke, patients treated by stenting were also much more likely to have additional brain damage. This was found to be caused by small particles released during the stenting process, too small to cause symptoms.

Dr Peter Coleman, Deputy Director of Research for The Stroke Association said: “Preventative procedures for patients who have the warning symptoms of a transient ischaemic attack or ‘’ are essential to help stop people going on to have a major stroke. These procedures do carry risks, mainly from arterial plaque that can become dislodged, travel up into the brain and cut off the blood supply causing a stroke -thus causing the very event the procedure was designed to avoid.

“The important findings in this study show that surgery to open an artery and clear the blockage appears to be safer than a less major procedure where a metal mesh tube (or ‘stent’) is inserted into the blocked artery. We look forward to further studies that help reduce the stroke risk for patients undergoing preventative surgery.”

Explore further: Imaging study reveals white-matter deficits in users of codeine-containing cough syrups

More information: Paper: www.lancet.com/journals/lancet… 10)60239-5/abstract#

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Recommended for you

Common infections tied to some stroke risk in kids

3 hours ago

A new study suggests that colds and other minor infections may temporarily increase stroke risk in children. The study found that the risk of stroke was increased only within a three-day period between a ...

Celebrities in 'Ice Bucket Challenge' to fight disease

14 hours ago

Steven Spielberg, Justin Bieber and Bill Gates are among many celebrities pouring buckets of ice water over their heads and donating to fight Lou Gehrig's disease, in a fundraising effort that has gone viral.

Study helps explain why elderly have trouble sleeping

15 hours ago

As people grow older, they often have difficulty falling asleep and staying asleep, and tend to awaken too early in the morning. In individuals with Alzheimer's disease, this common and troubling symptom ...

Targeted brain training may help you multitask better

17 hours ago

The area of the brain involved in multitasking and ways to train it have been identified by a research team at the IUGM Institut universitaire de gériatrie de Montréal and the University of Montreal.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Popawsandy3
not rated yet Feb 28, 2010
Strange the exact opposite was reported on news today.See: Stents as Good as Surgery at Preventing Stroke
Less Invasive Approach Works as Well as Gold Standard
By Charlene Laino
WebMD Health News
Reviewed by Louise Chang, MD

Feb. 26, 2010 (San Antonio) -- A less invasive approach for clearing clogged neck arteries proved just as effective and safe as surgical treatment for preventing strokes in high-risk patients, according to the largest comparison of the two procedures.

Stenting, in which flexible mesh tubes are used to prop open blocked blood vessels, is widely used to clear plaque-clogged coronary arteries, which cause heart attacks. More recently, it has been used to open blocked neck arteries that lead to strokes, but surgery called carotid endarterectomy remains the gold standard.

The new study shows that "we now have two good options for patients," says researcher Wayne Clark, MD, of Oregon Health & Science University.

The choice may come down to the individual patient's ag