'This message is brought to you by:' Super Bowl alcohol ads serve mixed messages

Feb 03, 2010 by Amy Patterson Neubert

(PhysOrg.com) -- Alcohol advertisements, including those aired during sporting events, can be misleading with their taglines promoting responsible drinking, says a Purdue University professor.

"The 'Drink Responsibly' message lacks specific characteristics and interpretations," says Adam E. Barry, an assistant professor of health and who has studied how these messages are employed and interpreted. "This vague terminology is not explained and, at the same time, viewers are seeing and hearing conflicting messages about drinking. There is inherent conflict with what they are depicting in their advertisings and the message of .

"The commercials during the Super Bowl can be just as captivating as the game, so it's important we pay attention to what the are saying and how those messages are interpreted."

Barry's concerns stem from the fact that the alcohol industry is borrowing the responsible drinking message, which was originally developed in the 1970s as part of several alcohol prevention campaigns.

"This was originally a prevention message that was hijacked by the alcohol industry and is now a central component of their marketing and advertising," he says. "In addition to the subjective nature of the message, I think there is an inherent ethical issue. The objective of these commercials is to sell more beer, yet brewers are using a public health message that would imply less, not more."

Barry would like to see experts in public health fields establish what responsible drinking actually means.

For example, Barry's research shows that the manner in which define and practice drinking responsibly has the potential to be hazardous to their health.

"Young people believe one aspect of responsible drinking is 'knowing your limit,'" he says. "We found that most young people identify their limit through a trial-and-error process. But alcohol affects you cognitively, so how can you truly perceive your limit. This could lead to a number of problems such as poisoning or drinking and driving."

Explore further: The strangely familiar browsing habits of 14th-century readers

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Outdoor alcohol ads boost kids' urge to drink

Jun 27, 2007

In the world depicted in an alcohol billboard, bikini-clad babes clutch icy bottles, frothy beer flows over frosty mugs and the slogan reads, “Life is good.” Ads like these may target adults, but children are getting ...

Alcohol adverts attract the young

Feb 06, 2009

Alcohol advertising and marketing may lead to underage drinking. A large systematic review of more than 13,000 people, published in the open access journal BMC Public Health, suggests that exposure to ads and product placem ...

T'is the season to be jolly?

Dec 28, 2008

As the party season approaches, a timely reminder of the issues surrounding the binge drinking culture are again highlighted by research into 'young people and alcohol' a team lead by Professor Christine Griffin, at the University ...

TV shows convey mixed messages about alcohol

Mar 25, 2009

Efforts to dissuade youth consumption through negative alcohol consumption depictions can be thwarted by portrayals of positive consumption in prime-time television programming. A new study in the Journal of Consumer Affairs re ...

Recommended for you

New study offers insight into how to best manage workaholics

May 22, 2013

(Phys.org) —Workaholics tend to live in extremes, with great job satisfaction and creativity on the one hand and high levels of frustration and exhaustion on the other hand. Now, a new Florida State University study offers ...

The tea party and the politics of paranoia

May 22, 2013

Members of tea party claim the movement springs from and promotes basic American conservative principles such as limited government and fiscal responsibility.

The new retirement: No retirement?

May 22, 2013

For growing numbers of Americans, the new retirement may really mean no retirement. That's the conclusion of an article in the current issue of the ISR Sampler, the annual magazine of the University of Michigan Institute ...

User comments : 0

More news stories

Submerged structure stumps Israeli archaeologists

The massive circular structure appears to be an archaeologists dream: a recently discovered antiquity that could reveal secrets of ancient life in the Middle East and is just waiting to be excavated.

Controlling mood through the motions of mitochondria

(Medical Xpress)—Regulating the distribution of power in neurons is done by a system that makes the national electric grid look simple by comparison. Each neuron has several thousand mitochondria confined ...

A quantum simulator for magnetic materials

Physicists understand perfectly well why a fridge magnet sticks to certain metallic surfaces. But there are more exotic forms of magnetism whose properties remain unclear, despite decades of intense research. ...