Intel settles AMD claims but isn't off the hook

Nov 12, 2009 By JORDAN ROBERTSON , AP Technology Writer
FILE - In this Oct. 14, 2009 file photo, an Advance Micro Devices (AMD) logo is shown on a computer at Best Buy in Mountain View, Calif. Intel Corp. is paying $1.25 billion to Advanced Micro Devices Inc., its largest rival in the market for computer processors, to settle all antitrust and patent suits, the companies said Thursday, Nov. 12, 2009. (AP Photo/Paul Sakuma, file)

(AP) -- Intel Corp. is paying Silicon Valley rival Advanced Micro Devices Inc. $1.25 billion to squash a legal battle over Intel's sales tactics, a rift that led to antitrust charges against Intel in several countries and was headed toward a costly and nasty trial next year.

The settlement announced Thursday between Intel and AMD - which make essentially all the microprocessors that serve as the brains in today's personal computers - doesn't let Intel off the hook. It still has to deal with the antitrust charges that AMD pressed governments to file.

The biggest case is in Europe, where regulators have fined Intel a record $1.45 billion over what they described as Intel's illegal tactics to bully PC makers into choosing Intel chips over AMD's. EU spokesman Jonathan Todd said that the European Commission "takes note" of Intel's settlement with AMD but that it does not change Intel's duty to comply with European .

Intel is also fighting an $18.6 million fine in Korea, and a federal lawsuit filed last week by New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo, who accused Intel of abusing its market dominance to "rule with an iron fist." The U.S. Federal Trade Commission also is investigating.

The settlement does allow Intel to duck a trial set for March in Delaware over a federal lawsuit AMD filed in 2005.

The lawsuit reflected AMD's long-standing accusation that Intel has kept AMD's market share from rising no higher than about 20 percent by threatening PC makers and offering for avoiding AMD chips. AMD's lawsuit quotes one manager from Toshiba comparing Intel's incentives to "cocaine." It also cites executives from Gateway complaining that Intel's threats of retaliation for working with AMD beat the executives "into guacamole."

Intel has defended its rebates to big Intel customers as legitimate - and good for PC buyers who enjoyed lower prices.

AMD shares soared $1.19, or 22 percent, to $6.51 in morning trading. Intel shares fell 6 cents to $19.78.

The settlement has precedent. In 1995 the companies, which are headquartered mere miles from each other, made peace over different issues. That deal gave AMD the right to keep producing chips based on a design known as the "x86 architecture," which both companies still use today.

A trial over the latest issues could have been dangerous for both companies.

Intel risked heavy penalties if it lost. A verdict against it also could have increased the momentum for cases like those that have come in Europe, New York and Korea.

Meanwhile, AMD, which is struggling to whittle down $3.7 billion in debt and pull off a major restructuring, could have found the trial prohibitively expensive. The companies have not said how much they have spent on legal fees related to the case, but it's easily in the tens of millions of dollars.

Intel also had a cudgel against AMD. AMD's restructuring has included the spinoff of its manufacturing arm to cut costs, a move that Intel says violated the x86 licensing agreement. AMD argued the spinoff didn't need a new license to make chips that incorporated Intel's technology, but Intel argued it did.

That spinoff is critical to AMD's turnaround after losing billions of dollars while trying to compete dollar-for-dollar against Intel in manufacturing, a fight AMD ultimately conceded it couldn't win.

Under the terms of the new agreement, AMD and Intel entered into a new, five-year cross-licensing deal. Intel dropped claims that AMD breached the earlier agreement. And AMD is dropping all litigation against Intel and withdrawing its regulatory complaints worldwide.

Intel has also agreed to "abide by a set of business practice provisions" as part of the settlement, but the companies didn't specify what that means.

Intel said that with the $1.25 billion settlement, its spending in the current quarter will now be $4.2 billion rather than the $2.9 billion it had previously forecast. It also expects its tax rate to be 20 percent rather than 26 percent. All other expectations are unchanged, said.

©2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Explore further: HP sales inch up while profit drops

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

NY files antitrust suit against Intel (Update)

Nov 04, 2009

(AP) -- New York's attorney general hit Intel Corp. with an antitrust lawsuit Wednesday, claiming the company used "illegal threats and collusion" to dominate the market for computer microprocessors.

Intel: $1.4B EU monopoly fine based on mistakes

Sep 15, 2009

(AP) -- Intel Corp. is claiming in court documents that European Union regulators made serious mistakes in levying a record euro1.06 billion ($1.45 billion) fine for monopoly abuse last May.

Intel hit with $1.45B fine in Europe

May 13, 2009

(AP) -- Intel Corp. was fined a record $1.45 billion by the European Union on Wednesday for using strong-arm sales tactics in the computer chip market - a penalty that could turn up the pressure on U.S. regulators ...

Recommended for you

HP sales inch up while profit drops

4 hours ago

Hewlett-Packard on Wednesday reported that its quarterly revenue was nudged up by improved computer sales, but its profit dropped as the veteran technology firm tried to renew its momentum.

Restaurants experimenting with pay-in-advance tickets

7 hours ago

With restaurant patrons increasingly jumping on the Internet to make reservations, some high-end eateries here and across the country are adding a new tech wrinkle: having their clientele pay for their meal in advance using ...

Chip maker Infineon to buy California firm for $3B (Update)

9 hours ago

German chip maker Infineon Technologies AG says it has agreed to pay $3 billion in cash for California-based semiconductor firm International Rectifier, which produces power-management components used in everything from cars ...

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Damon_Hastings
5 / 5 (2) Nov 12, 2009
I sometimes wonder how much more advanced CPUs would be today if Intel weren't so hell-bent on suppressing competition and innovation. AMD's technology was far more advanced than Intel's back in 2001: faster, cheaper, more power efficient... and since Intel had no 32/64 hybrid chip whatsoever, AMD was perfectly poised to basically run away with the entire 64-bit market (i.e. the future of computing). Intel needed to buy a LOT of time to finish its own hybrid. In short, Intel was peeing its pants. And these are the reasons why Intel started extorting customers to stop them buying from AMD. This gave Intel time to catch up, and eventually surpass, AMD's technology. And it worked beautifully: Intel's chips are indeed faster and cheaper than AMD's chips today.

But what if AMD had been allowed to continue its phenomenal rate of technological progress? How much faster, cheaper, and more power-efficient would our computers be today?
frajo
1 / 5 (1) Nov 12, 2009
Remember that 386 trick? Forcefully crippled 386DX were sold as 386SX.
Damon_Hastings
not rated yet Nov 12, 2009
Yes, another shining moment in American capitalism. :-P

In Steinbeck's book "The Grapes of Wrath", west-coast farmers used kerosene to destroy huge piles of oranges (to drive up prices) while displaced midwesterners literally starved to death while watching the piles burn. Not the same, I suppose, but your comment struck the memory. :-)
YawningDog
5 / 5 (2) Nov 12, 2009
The Microsoft-Intel mob has done all in their power to suppress competition using any methods, fair or foul. I avoid both company's products out of sheer revulsion. It's my little drop in the bucket.