Better care, pay less: Some communities find a way

Sep 07, 2009 By LAURAN NEERGAARD , AP Medical Writer
In this photo taken Thursday, Sept. 3, 2009, patient Linda Rankin, 60, of Selinsgrove, Pa., is prepared for hip replacement surgery at Geisinger Medical Center in Danville, Pa. Within hours of her surgery Rankin was helped to her feet. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster)

(AP) -- If you pay the mechanic $1,000 to fix your transmission and it breaks again next week, the garage should find and fix the problem for free. So if you get an infection following open-heart surgery because the doctor forgot an antibiotic, why are you charged extra to clear up the wound?

At Geisinger Health System in Pennsylvania, pay a flat fee for bypass surgery and you'll get essentially a 90-day warranty on your heart fix. Complications? The hospital has to eat the cost. It gambled that following a checklist of best practices would help patients recover faster and cost less - and so far, it's winning the bet.

It's a radically different approach to a that even many doctors agree rewards volume of care over quality. Yet around the country are hospitals and health systems like Geisinger that President calls "islands of excellence," places quietly trying innovative changes to improve patient care at below-average prices.

Places like:

-La Crosse, Wis., where astoundingly, nearly 95 percent of senior citizens have living wills to guide end-of-life care, meaning more hospice care and less hospitalization while dying. That has Medicare paying about $18,000 for the last two years of a beneficiary's life here, compared to nearly $64,000 for end-of-life care in Miami, the nation's priciest health market, according to the Dartmouth Atlas of Health Care.

-Cedar Rapids, Iowa, where two competing hospitals worked together to create a community clinic that lowered side effects and hospitalizations of patients who use a risky blood thinner.

Next they want to tackle reducing unnecessary CT scans. Some 52,000 CTs were performed in one year for a population of 300,000, 5,000 alone for headaches when just 1 percent find a brain problem. That doesn't mean all the rest weren't necessary, but limiting them is important since CTs emit much more radiation than a regular X-ray, says Dr. James Levett of Physicians Clinic of Iowa, who heads the community's medical collaboration.

-Everett, Wash., where monthly reports compare how doctors prescribe generic drugs or pricier brand-names, and patients get a checkup call when they leave the hospital to make sure they're following up with their regular doctor.

They're different approaches. But they aim to cut overuse of health care - like avoidable hospitalizations, or repeating tests because one doctor didn't send another a copy, or unnecessary visits to specialists.

"Does the public buy the idea that more care is not better? The answer is no. Yet you're doing it," Dr. Donald Berwick of the nonprofit Institute for Healthcare Improvement told a recent meeting of La Crosse and nine other communities that spend about $1,500 less per Medicare patient than the national average but rank well for quality.

It's sobering: The respected Dartmouth Atlas shows that in parts of the country, Medicare pays double or triple the price to treat the similarly ill - yet people in more expensive areas don't get better quality care. By some measures, they fare worse. The differences can't be explained by big cities' higher living costs. Volume of care is the chief driver, says Dr. Elliott Fisher of the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy. He says 30 percent to 40 percent of hospitalizations alone are avoidable.

Some health systems limit overuse by putting doctors on salary instead of the usual fee-for-service. Fisher says physician teams help, too. Instead of waiting a week for a specialist to run a heart test, the family doctor asks a collaborating cardiologist which test to order and consults with the result.

Then there's Geisinger's approach, called ProvenCare. Surgeons at the Danville, Pa., hospital turned national guidelines for heart bypass into a specific checklist of 40 best practices - like ensuring that antibiotics, blood thinners and other medications are given correctly before and after surgery, and that proper pre-surgery tests are in. Miss a step and the operation's canceled.

At the program's start, 60 percent of patients got every check. Today, all do.

Then came the price test: Patients insured through Geisinger's insurance unit are charged a set price for the surgery and all pre- and post-operative care, that 90-day warranty.

"We were pretty nervous that this could be upsetting an apple cart," says associate chief medical officer Dr. Alfred Casale.

But ProvenCare patients are recovering faster, rehospitalizations for complications have fallen 40 percent - and the and its health plan have saved thousands of dollars, he says. So Geisinger expanded ProvenCare to half a dozen other areas, from joint replacement to obesity surgery, and is negotiating with other insurers to join.

The lesson: "There were things that would get dropped, and we didn't know that until we started auditing it," says nurse Linda McGrail, joint replacement coordinator.

©2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Explore further: Researchers observe major hand hygiene problems in operating rooms

Related Stories

Increasing health care value improves health care quality

Sep 24, 2008

Finding better ways to deliver healthcare to patients is key to ensuring that Medicare is able to meet the needs of the nation's baby boomers according to a new paper by Geisinger Health System published in Health Affairs.

UCLA expert blames American values for health-care crisis

Dec 04, 2008

To heal our ailing health care system, we need to stop thinking like Americans. That's the message of two articles by UCLA's Dr. Marc Nuwer, a leading expert on national health care reform, published this week in Neurology, ...

Recommended for you

Ozone air pollution could harm women's fertility

1 hour ago

Many urban and suburban areas have high levels of ground-level ozone, an air pollutant that can adversely affect lung and heart health. New research in mice suggests breathing high levels of ozone could also affect women's ...

Exercise can outweigh harmful effects of air pollution

3 hours ago

New research from the University of Copenhagen has found that the beneficial effects of exercise are more important for our health than the negative effects of air pollution, in relation to the risk of premature ...

Morocco confronts abortion taboo with proposed reform

6 hours ago

It was just 7 a.m. and Hoda was walking alone to a clinic in the Moroccan coastal city of Agadir. She skipped breakfast: the Senegalese doctor had told her that the abortion would be better done on an empty ...

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.