Will antitrust probe keep Microsoft, Yahoo apart?

Aug 23, 2009 By JOELLE TESSLER and MICHAEL LIEDTKE , AP Technology Writers
ADVANCE FOR AUG. 24; graphic shows the share of core Internet searches of Google, Yahoo, Microsoft, AOL and Ask Networks

(AP) -- Yahoo Inc. and Microsoft Corp. hope that by joining forces, they can tilt the balance of power in Internet search away from Google Inc. First, however, Yahoo and Microsoft have to convince regulators that their plan won't hurt online advertisers and consumers.

As the U.S. Justice Department reviews the proposed partnership, approval figures to hinge on this question: Will the online ad market be healthier if Google's dominance is challenged by a single, more muscular rival instead of two scrawnier foes?

The first step toward getting an answer came this month when Microsoft and Yahoo filed paperwork with federal regulators to comply with the Hart-Scott-Rodino Act, an antitrust law governing mergers and alliances between competitors. The Justice Department has until early September to approve the agreement or - as is likely in this case - request additional information.

European regulators are also expected to review the deal. Microsoft and Yahoo are bracing for the probes to extend into early next year, and the outcome is far from certain.

Just nine months ago, Google abandoned its own proposed partnership with Yahoo to avoid a showdown with the government, which had concluded that Google was already too powerful in the lucrative market for selling ads alongside search results.

Google had hoped to extend its reach even further by selling ads next to some of Yahoo's search results, and in the process, keep Yahoo out of Microsoft's clutches. Microsoft aggressively lobbied against the partnership.

With the Google-Yahoo inquiry behind them, U.S. antitrust regulators are likely to enter this examination with a clearer definition of the landscape and a better understanding of how it affects the steadily growing online advertising market.

Justice Department spokeswoman Gina Talamona would not comment on the antitrust review, whose existence was confirmed by Microsoft and Yahoo.

Microsoft is counting on the Yahoo partnership to close the wide gap separating the software maker from Google in search. Under the 10-year agreement announced last month, Microsoft's Bing search engine would process all search requests and steer search-related ads on Yahoo.

Analysts believe the move will free Yahoo to phase out of the search business so it can focus on other products. Yahoo would keep 88 percent of advertising revenue generated by searches on its site for the first five years of the deal, and as much as 93 percent in the final five years.

The Microsoft-Yahoo alliance may stand a better chance of winning antitrust approval than the Google-Yahoo pact because it would combine the second and third players in the search market instead of the top two, said Melissa Maxman, head of the antitrust practice group at Baker & Hostetler LLP. In fact, a combination of Microsoft and Yahoo would still lag far behind Google.

Google handled 64.7 percent of all U.S. Web searches in July, while Yahoo processed 19.3 percent and Microsoft 8.9 percent, according to comScore Inc.

The lopsided competition means neither Yahoo nor Microsoft has a large enough audience on its own to lure a significant amount of search advertising dollars away from Google, argues Microsoft General Counsel Brad Smith.

"Advertisers want scale," Smith said in an interview, "so we need to increase our scale to offer something compelling to advertisers."

Already, one large group of advertisers that opposed the Google deal is supporting the Microsoft marriage.

Last year, the Association of National Advertisers feared Google would gain too much pricing leverage over advertisers through a Yahoo alliance. But Microsoft still won't be in the driver's seat if it teams with Yahoo, said Bob Liodice, president of the trade group. Its members include such big marketers as Procter & Gamble Co., Johnson & Johnson and General Motors Corp.

"This is a whole different ball game," Liodice said. "We are not concerned about monopolization of the market as a result of two weaker competitors coming together. We would still have a very competitive marketplace."

Maxman said regulators will have to consider another factor as well: Yahoo may need Microsoft to survive. Although it remains profitable, Yahoo might not be able to afford to keep spending so much money on search - where it has been losing ground to Google for years - while its hold on its audience is threatened by rapidly growing Internet hubs such as Facebook and Twitter.

Nevertheless, Maxman said, antitrust regulators could still conclude that Microsoft and Yahoo don't absolutely need each other to compete effectively with Google. Microsoft has deep pockets and plenty of brainpower. And while Yahoo's profits have been slipping for the past three years, the company is now run by a chief executive, Carol Bartz, who has been trying to instill more discipline and focus during the first seven months of her tenure.

"There is no reason that with the right management and right strategy that it can't remain a viable third alternative in the search market," said Matthew Cantor, a New York attorney specializing in .

Antitrust regulators generally frown on deals that create duopolies, unless one of the players can show it needs to bow out of a cutthroat competition to stay alive, Cantor said.

"The Justice Department's goal is to prevent the market from becoming too concentrated," Maxman said.

The real challenge for antitrust regulators, she said, is that it can be difficult to predict how a rapidly changing technology market will evolve.

A decade ago, Microsoft's stranglehold on PC software triggered an antitrust case that led regulators to conclude the company had abused its control over PC operating systems. Now, Google has emerged as the industry's fearsome giant - a transformation underscored by the Justice Department's decision to block Google's proposed deal with Yahoo last year. are also reviewing the potential effects of a legal settlement that would give Google the digital rights over millions of copyright-protected books.

With the antitrust microscope zoomed in, Google may not be nearly as active in trying to scuttle the Microsoft-Yahoo partnership as Microsoft was in trying to derail the Google-Yahoo pact last year. Google has said little publicly since the deal was announced other than to reiterate that more competition is good for Web surfers and advertisers.

Even if Google doesn't object, the Microsoft-Yahoo agreement merits an examination of how the two companies intend to share the data they gather about Web surfers, said Jeff Chester, executive director of the Center for Digital Democracy, a privacy watchdog group.

"This will be a litmus test for the Obama administration on whether they incorporate privacy into antitrust review," Chester said.

Besides eliminating one of Google's search rivals, the deal would cede Yahoo's market share to a company that still dominates the markets for operating systems and Internet browsers. The antitrust review needs to consider whether Microsoft's clout in those areas would be strengthened by the Yahoo partnership, Chester said.

Yahoo and Microsoft also are among the largest providers of free e-mail and instant messaging services. As a result, even if regulators approve the search alliance, they may impose controls to ensure the two companies keep those other parts of their business separate.

Perhaps the best way to placate regulators may be for to sell its search technology to another company besides or , to spice up the competition, Cantor said.

"If the traditional antitrust doctrines are followed, it is going to be hard for the authorities not to challenge this deal, unless some conditions are placed on the parties," Cantor said.

---

Michael Liedtke reported from San Francisco.
©2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Explore further: New social network for teenagers experiences a growth spurt

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Microsoft-Yahoo deal to face tough antitrust probe

Jul 29, 2009

(AP) -- The Internet search partnership between Microsoft and Yahoo faces a tough antitrust review in the U.S. and overseas, with approval likely hinging on whether the marriage would foster more competition ...

Microsoft to hire at least 400 Yahoo workers

Aug 05, 2009

(AP) -- Microsoft Corp. will hire at least 400 workers from Yahoo Inc. if government regulators approve the companies' proposed Internet search partnership, and Yahoo will receive $150 million to cover any unexpected costs ...

Google users loyal: comScore

Aug 15, 2009

The planned Microsoft-Yahoo! online search tie-up has promise but must overcome people's fierce loyalty to market king Google, industry tracker comScore said Friday.

Yahoo CEO: Shake-up needs more time, not Microsoft

Jun 03, 2009

(AP) -- Yahoo Inc. Chief Executive Carol Bartz has a message for investors hoping for a quick fix at the slumping Internet company or for an online search partnership with Microsoft Corp. - don't expect either to happen ...

Microsoft, Yahoo! in search, ad talks

Apr 10, 2009

Microsoft and Yahoo! have held "early discussions" about possible Internet search and advertising partnerships, a leading Silicon Valley technology website reported on Friday.

Recommended for you

Facebook goes retro with 'Rooms' chat app

Oct 23, 2014

Facebook on Thursday released an application that lets people create virtual "rooms" to chat about whatever they wish using any name they would like.

Some online shoppers pay more than others, study shows

Oct 23, 2014

Internet users regularly receive all kinds of personalized content, from Google search results to product recommendations on Amazon. This is thanks to the complex algorithms that produce results based on users' profiles and ...

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

superhuman
5 / 5 (2) Aug 23, 2009
This deal will reduce competition and choice of consumers and therefore should certainly be opposed.
Three players is already far too few, regulators should never allow the number to drop down to two.

Not to mention that this deal will force people to use worse search engine and one which they don't like and don't want to use.

As always micro$oft can't compete on a level playing field so they use their money to eliminate better players. The deal may be good for yahoo in short term but after those 10 years yahoo will be left with nothing - eliminated from search market.
MorituriMax
not rated yet Aug 23, 2009
While I like Bing, I have only actually used it less than a dozen times, I always go back to Google. And strangely or not, I find Google's home page totally unappealing and never actually go there on purpose. As for yahoo, it WAS my homepage for a few years a while back but I have since set msnbc as my home page. Something about yahoos ads was very irritating.
Velanarris
not rated yet Aug 24, 2009
This deal will reduce competition and choice of consumers and therefore should certainly be opposed.

Three players is already far too few, regulators should never allow the number to drop down to two.



Not to mention that this deal will force people to use worse search engine and one which they don't like and don't want to use.



As always micro$oft can't compete on a level playing field so they use their money to eliminate better players. The deal may be good for yahoo in short term but after those 10 years yahoo will be left with nothing - eliminated from search market.

Problem here is, there are far more competition in the two methods of revenue generation that Google, MS, and Yahoo engage in. I'm not so sure you could consider it anti-trust.