Brain represents tools as temporary body parts, study confirms

Jun 22, 2009
Brain
Credit: University of Wisconsin and Michigan State Comparative Mammalian Brain Collections and the National Museum of Health and Medicine

Researchers have what they say is the first direct proof of a very old idea: that when we use a tool—even for just a few minutes—it changes the way our brain represents the size of our body. In other words, the tool becomes a part of what is known in psychology as our body schema, according to a report published in the June 23rd issue of Current Biology.

"Since the origin of the concept of body schema, the idea of its functional plasticity has always been taken for granted, even if no direct evidence has been provided until now," said Alessandro Farnč of INSERM and the Université Claude Bernard Lyon. "Our series of experiments provides the first, definitive demonstration that this century-old intuition is true."

In the new study, Farnč, Lucilla Cardinali, and their colleagues reasoned that if one incorporates a used tool into the body schema, his or her subsequent bodily movements should differ when compared to those performed before the tool was used.

Indeed, that is exactly what they saw. After using a mechanical grabber that extended their reach, people behaved as though their arm really was longer, they found. What's more, study participants perceived touches delivered on the elbow and middle fingertip of their arm as if they were farther apart after their use of the grabbing tool.

People still went on using their arm successfully following after tool use, but they managed tasks differently. That is, they grasped or pointed to object correctly, but they did not move their hand as quickly and overall took longer to complete the tasks.

It's a phenomenon each of us unconsciously experiences every day, the researchers said. The reason you were able to brush your teeth this morning without necessarily looking at your mouth or arm is because your toothbrush was integrated into your brain's representation of your arm.

The findings help to explain how it is that humans use tools so well.

"We believe this ability of our body representation to functionally adapt to incorporate tools is the fundamental basis of skillful tool use," Cardinali said. "Once the tool is incorporated in the body schema, it can be maneuvered and controlled as if it were a body part itself."


Join PhysOrg.com on Facebook!
Follow PhysOrg.com on Twitter!
Source: Cell Press (news : web)

Explore further: Blood test predicts tissue injury in kidney transplant recipients

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Pain is in the eyes of the beholder

Nov 25, 2008

By manipulating the appearance of a chronically achy hand, researchers have found they could increase or decrease the pain and swelling in patients moving their symptomatic limbs. The findings—reported in the November 25th ...

How The Octopus Forms An Elbow

Apr 21, 2006

The octopus arm is extremely flexible. Thanks to this flexibility--the arm is said to possess a virtually infinite number of "degrees of freedom"--the octopus is able to generate a vast repertoire of movements that is unmatched ...

Monkeys Adapt Robot Arm as Their Own

May 11, 2005

Monkeys that learn to use their brain signals to control a robotic arm are not just learning to manipulate an external device, Duke University Medical Center neurobiologists have found. Rather, their brain ...

Left and Right Hands Rely on Different Senses

Oct 20, 2006

Sometimes, the right hand really may not know what the left hand is doing. It turns out that each of them relies on a different set of sensory inputs to control its movement.

The Wiimote as an interface bridging mind and body

Mar 05, 2008

The Nintendo Wii is an immensely popular source of videogame entertainment, but more recently, it has been adapted for a number of different uses, such as a tool for physical therapy and as a form of exercise for geriatri ...

Recommended for you

Scientists aim to give botox a safer facelift

16 hours ago

New insights into botulinum neurotoxins and their interactions with cells are moving scientists ever closer to safer forms of Botox and a better understanding of the dangerous disease known as botulism. By comparing all known ...

User comments : 8

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

NeilFarbstein
1 / 5 (2) Jun 22, 2009
They should investigate effects of computers as tools that affect the body schema and video games and steering wheels.
hypnosis
5 / 5 (2) Jun 23, 2009
Yeah,people and machines become one is the feeling.Drive a car,train and a giant dump truck e.t.c seems to incorporate a sense of being the transport as one's self,same if you ask any musician,they get a notion their instrument is part of them.Classic example are ventriloquists,the doll thinks and senses the human is a part of them,quite profoundly.Makes a change that age old intuition turns out to be correct against sciences numerous counter-intuition reports...
russcelt
5 / 5 (2) Jun 23, 2009
Exactly! When I climbed into the cab of the eight axle, sixty ton semi-trailer truck toward the end of my driving career I had to think as if I were 13' 6" tall, 10' wide and 60' long to manoeuvre safely on the public roads. To not have done so for twenty five years would have endangered not only myself but the millions of other highway users I shared the roads with. For well over 1.5 million miles I was a safe iron giant.
designmemetic
5 / 5 (1) Jun 23, 2009
I would like to hear more about what specific parts of our brain our active during the alteration of our body schema. can they run this test under mri imaging? How does this compare to other animals such as monkeys and dolphins?
docknowledge
4 / 5 (1) Jun 23, 2009
Yes, good study. One of those that makes you think: "Come on, I knew that already." Or did I?
blubbber
not rated yet Jun 23, 2009
Of course you knew it already. And you typed, that proves it.

Anybody who is really interested in this should check out the work of Vilayanur Ramachandran at Cal. San Diego.
farmjunk
not rated yet Jun 23, 2009
WOW! After I read this, I noticed that when I try to sort though ideas and concepts in my head I often make my mind into a "computer desktop" (best way of describing it) and will move ideas around, delete and edit them. since the better part of my free time is spent on a computer it seems the action of a mouse has been incorporated into my body.
SMMAssociates
not rated yet Jun 27, 2009
I won't say that I already knew it, but I did sort of think about it, and seeing this article "fixes" the impression....

When helping my daughter learn how to drive a few years ago, I had the opportunity to try to figure out how I would do the maneuvering test if I had to do it. That led me back to the whole "be one with the car" thing....

Then, more recently, I had to do some cleaning in the office here, and I don't move or sit on the floor as well as I used to, so I used one of those "grabber" tools for a couple days. I was tempted to holster it....

What the brain is actually doing, I'm not sure, but the effect seems similar!