Substituting water for sugar-sweetened beverages can reduce excess calorie consumption

Apr 06, 2009

Replacing consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs) with water could eliminate an average of 235 excess calories per day among children and adolescents, according to a study published in the April 2009 Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine. The study's authors conclude that such a replacement would be a simple and effective way to reduce excess intake of calories causing childhood overweight and obesity, as well as address dental cavities and other health problems associated with added sugar. And they predict no detrimental effects on nutrition.

"The evidence is now clear that replacing these 'liquid calories' with calorie-free beverage alternatives both at home and in schools represents a key strategy to eliminate excess and prevent childhood obesity," said Y. Claire Wang, MD, ScD, assistant professor of Health Policy and Management at Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health and the study's lead author.

Dr. Wang and colleagues analyzed what children and teens reported they ate and drank on two different days, using nationally representative data from the 2003-2004 National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey. They then estimated the impact of substituting water for SSBs on the total energy intake of youths ages two to 19.

No data suggest that youths increase their of other foods and to compensate for drinking fewer SSBs, and so every can of soda or fruit drink that is replaced by water means a net reduction of calories. Almost 90 percent of U.S. children and currently consume SSBs on any given day, including soda, fruit drinks, punches, sports drinks and sweetened tea, and the calories contained in these drinks can represent more than 10 percent of their total daily intake. There is growing evidence that sugar-sweetened beverage consumption is an important contributor to rising youth obesity rates in the United States.

"This study shows the substantial impact that replacing sugar-sweetened beverages with water could have," said C. Tracy Orleans, senior scientist and distinguished fellow at the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, which co-funded the study along with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. "Reversing the rise in childhood obesity requires finding approaches like this to close the gap between daily energy intake and daily energy expenditure. Changes such as this one can potentially add up to significant benefits for the population as a whole."

In contrast to the caloric reduction noted when replacing SSBs with water, the researchers found no difference when replacing SSBs with milk. But they emphasized the calcium, protein and other nutritional benefits that reduced-fat milk provides, in contrast to most SSBs. Though the findings suggest that reducing SSB consumption may prevent unhealthy weight gain, the researchers say that widespread recommendations to decrease SSB consumption are unlikely to lead to unnecessary or harmful weight loss in healthy-weight or underweight teens.

A 2008 study by the same team of researchers found that children consume SSBs in a variety of locations-homes, schools, fast-food establishments and other restaurants. Up to 70 percent of the consumption occurs in the home environment, whereas seven to 15 percent of consumption occurs in schools.

"Making children and teens more active is important," Dr. Wang noted, "However, simply eliminating the extra calories they don't need from these sugary drinks can tip the energy balance in a major way." A typical 15-year-old boy would need to jog for 30 minutes in order to burn off the calories contained in a 12-oz can of soda. The alternative drink best suited to reduce excess caloric consumption is water.

"These beverages are nothing more than different forms of sugar water, which kids don't need." said Steven Gortmaker, PhD, professor of the Practice of Health Sociology at the Harvard School of Public Health and the senior author on the study. "Unless they are running marathons, which we do not recommend for kids, water is the best choice for quenching their thirst. It is also low cost, especially when it comes from a clean tap source."

Source: Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health

Explore further: Cancer patients should not hesitate to speak with their doctors about dietary supplements

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Children's consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages

Jun 02, 2008

A recent study published in Pediatrics and led by researchers at Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health found that sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs) are an increasingly large part of children and teens' diets. ...

Sweetened beverage consumption increases in the US

Dec 11, 2008

Over the past two decades, the number of adults consuming sugar-sweetened beverages such as soft drinks, fruit drinks and punches has increased dramatically, according to a study led by researchers at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg ...

Sugary drinks, not fruit juice, may be linked to insulin

Sep 05, 2007

Steady increases in consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages over the last several decades, as well as rates of Type 2 diabetes mellitus, led nutritional epidemiologists at the Jean Mayer USDA Human Nutrition Research Center ...

Recommended for you

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

dirk_bruere
5 / 5 (2) Apr 06, 2009
Another result from the University of the Obvious brought to you at vast public expense.
physpuppy
5 / 5 (1) Apr 06, 2009
April 2009 Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine


Dang - there must be something else to this paper and this article left it out - either that or it must be incredibly damned easy to get a paper past reviewers in that journal. I mean - OK, as Dirk pointed out, sure it might be obvious to cut out sugary drinks and lose weight [and kids like to drink these things so substituting water is a way for them to lose weight], but how many other zillions of papers come to the same conclusion? In addition, this sounds like a middle school science project (or maybe that is what was published???)
Mauricio
not rated yet Apr 06, 2009
Hardly can get worst than this... and then some people wonder why the country is in crisis at multiple levels!!!

They just "solve an enigma" - how funny!!!

"professors" and "distinguished fellows" how hilarious

I bet these people are the ones deciding important matters in the country, like the bailouts and the legalization of marijuana
robbor
not rated yet Apr 06, 2009
Duh!