More evidence prostate tests overdiagnose cancer

Mar 11, 2009 By LAURAN NEERGAARD , AP Medical Writer

(AP) -- As many as two of every five men whose prostate cancer was caught through a PSA screening test have tumors too slow-growing to ever be a threat, says a new study that raises more questions about the controversial tests.

The work "reinforces the message that we are overdiagnosing ," said Dr. Len Lichtenfeld of the American Society, who was not involved in the new study.

More than 186,000 U.S. will be diagnosed with prostate cancer this year, and nearly 29,000 will die, according to cancer society estimates. Most men over 50 have had a blood test that measures prostate specific antigen, or PSA, mostly for routine screening.

There begins the list of problems: Most men who undergo a biopsy for an abnormal PSA test don't turn out to have prostate cancer; high PSAs often signal a benign enlarged prostate. Of those who do have cancer, there's no proof yet that early detection saves lives - as most prostate tumors grow so slowly that had they not been screened, those men would have died of something else without the anxiety.

How many? Estimates vary widely. Enter the new study, which tracked prostate cancer diagnosed in U.S. men ages 54 to 80 between 1985 and 2000, and used three different models developed by cancer centers to more accurately estimate overdiagnosis.

Depending on how it's calculated, anywhere from 23 percent to 42 percent of PSA-detected cancers would otherwise never have been detected in the man's lifetime, concluded the team led by researchers at Erasmus University Medical Center in the Netherlands.

The study was published online Tuesday by the Journal of the National Cancer Institute.

Why is overdiagnosis such a concern? Because finding an early tumor forces men to choose among contested treatments - "watchful waiting," surgery, hormone therapy, radiation. And because some treatments can cause incontinence and impotence, men whose tumors wouldn't have been a threat can suffer serious side effects for no gain.

In fact, national health guidelines issued last year said men over age 75 shouldn't undergo PSA screening, while younger men should make an individual choice after hearing the pros and cons and weighing their own cancer risk.

The new study's estimate of U.S. overdiagnosis probably is too low - because since 2000, doctors have begun performing biopsies for lower PSA levels than once were the trigger, wrote Dr. Michael Barry of Massachusetts General Hospital in an accompanying editorial.

It's a confusing issue, acknowledged the cancer society's Lichtenfeld.

It boils down to: "If we diagnose this disease, are we making your life better? We know that for other cancers," such as breast, cervical and colorectal, which have strong evidence showing early detection hugely improves survival, he said.

Major studies are under way that in a few years should offer better guidance for prostate cancer screening, and scientists are furiously hunting new tests that might help pinpoint who has a worrisome tumor and who can relax.

"We're waiting for that evidence. Hopefully we'll have it in the not too distant future, but we really don't have the best answer right now," added Lichtenfeld, who stressed the importance of discussing potential benefits and risks with a doctor.

©2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Explore further: US Oks first-ever DNA alternative to pap smear

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

The changing roles of mothers and fathers

Mar 10, 2009

Elvire Vaucher is a professor at the Université de Montréal School of Optometry. Her husband is an artist who works from home. Upon the birth of their second child in 2003, she took only three months maternity ...

Small molecules block cancer gene

Mar 10, 2009

Finding molecules that block the activity of the oncogene Stat 3 (signal transducer and activator of transcription) required screening literally millions of compounds, using computers that compared the structure of the cancer-causing ...

US struggles to pinpoint cyber attacks: Top official

Mar 10, 2009

The United States often cannot quickly or reliably trace a cyber attack back to its source, even as rival nations and extremists may be looking to wage virtual war, a top official warned Tuesday.

Recommended for you

US Oks first-ever DNA alternative to pap smear

18 minutes ago

Federal health regulators have cleared a genetic test from Roche as the first U.S.-approved alternative to the pap smear, the decades-old mainstay of cervical cancer screening.

New breast cancer imaging method promising

5 hours ago

The new PAMmography method for imaging breast cancer developed by the University of Twente's MIRA research institute and the Medisch Spectrum Twente hospital appears to be a promising new method that could ...

Palliation is rarely a topic in studies on advanced cancer

6 hours ago

End-of-life aspects, the corresponding terminology, and the relevance of palliation in advanced cancer are often not considered in publications on randomized controlled trials (RCTs). This is the result of an analysis by ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Edward3
not rated yet Mar 11, 2009
There is nothing new in this - over-diagnosis has been a recognised problem for some time and it has therefore been recognised that better diagnostics are required - which is all that this study seems to be saying. There seems to be an implication here that everybody with a high PSA and positive biopsy is having radical treatment - this is not so.

More news stories

Autism Genome Project delivers genetic discovery

A new study from investigators with the Autism Genome Project, the world's largest research project on identifying genes associated with risk for autism, has found that the comprehensive use of copy number variant (CNV) genetic ...

Study suggests targeting B cells may help with MS

A new study suggests that targeting B cells, which are a type of white blood cell in the immune system, may be associated with reduced disease activity for people with multiple sclerosis (MS). The study is released today ...

Study links California drought to global warming

While researchers have sometimes connected weather extremes to man-made global warming, usually it is not done in real time. Now a study is asserting a link between climate change and both the intensifying California drought ...