Low Literacy Can Lead to Food 'Portion Distortion'

Feb 26, 2009 By Becky Ham

(PhysOrg.com) -- How big is a serving of spaghetti or a cup of cranberry juice? Correctly estimating the size of a food serving is important for maintaining a healthy weight, but a new study suggests people with lower literacy levels might have a more difficult time sizing up the foods they eat.

People with high literacy levels are twice as likely as those with low literacy test scores are to dole out a single-sized portion of pasta, pineapple, ground beef and other common foods, according to the study in the April issue of the American Journal of Preventive Medicine.

Yet, people with higher literacy levels have troubles estimating portion sizes, too, said Johns Hopkins researcher Mary Margaret Huizinga, M.D., who led the study while at Vanderbilt University. When combining serving data for all the foods in the study, only 62 percent of study participants could serve a specific amount of food accurately when asked, she and colleagues discovered.

For individual foods, “accuracy ranged from 30 percent for beef to 53 percent for juice,” Huizinga said.

“The current super-sizing of many foods may lead Americans to overestimate what a normal portion should be,” she said, “and the overestimation of portion size may lead to overeating and contribute to obesity.”

In their study of 164 patients at a primary care clinic, the researchers tested the participants’ verbal and written literacy as well as their understanding of numerical information. They then measured how well the patients were able to estimate a single serving or a specified amount of a variety of foods, using guidelines from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration and the U.S. Department of Agriculture as a standard.

The participants’ food preferences, or even how often they ate a particular food, did not seem to affect how well they estimated serving sizes, Huizinga and colleagues noted.

Ballooning portion sizes in restaurants is one factor that prompts people to see large portions as normal, but the same kind of “portion distortion” can happen at home, said Jennifer Fisher, Ph.D., an associate professor of public health at Temple University.

In her studies of how much children eat when faced with normal or super-sized entrees, Fisher found that a family’s social and cultural perceptions of “how much is enough” also influenced the portions dished out to children.

“Seeing a large amount of food in front of you can lead you to believe that someone decided this portion was the right amount to eat,” she said.

More information: Huizinga MM, et al. Literacy, numeracy, and portion-size estimation skills. Am J Prev Med 36(4), 2009.

Provided by Health Behavior News Service

Explore further: Recovery reversal seen in Oregon study of returning concussed athletes

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

One Codex in open beta for genomic data search

4 hours ago

Data, data everywhere and now as ever researchers need the best tools to make the data useful. In medicine, searching through genomic data can take some time. A startup called One Codex hopes to make difference ...

After breakups, newspapers seek path forward

5 hours ago

Following an unprecedented series of spinoffs by major US media companies, the print news industry now faces a rocky future without financial support from deep-pocketed parent firms.

Recommended for you

Pica in pregnant teens linked to low iron

1 hour ago

In a study of 158 pregnant teenagers in Rochester, NY, nearly half engaged in pica – the craving and intentional consumption of ice, cornstarch, vacuum dust, baby powder and soap, and other nonfood items, reports a new ...

User comments : 2

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Arkaleus
not rated yet Feb 27, 2009
I don't care what you eat. Stop bothing us about it. I don't need you to be my nanny. If you are vain enough to sense your body critically, then you will force yourself to not eat. If you don't care about your vanity, then eat. Please enjoy what you eat and laugh a lot.
casepeut
not rated yet May 22, 2009
If you really think that people other than dietitians base their nutritional intake on "portions," and thus that the ability to recognize them is a factor in obesity, you're much farther from stemming the tide of overweight than you think.


Do you think, during 9,950 of the past 10,000 years, our ancestors needed portion definitions to guide their consumption? I have a BMI of 24 and have never, ever been on a diet because -- and how "unscientific" this approach must seem to the author -- I LISTEN TO MY BODY WHEN I EAT.



So can anyone else without having the foggiest idea of how "portion" is defined.