Neurobiologist proposes 'The end of sex as we once knew it'

Feb 02, 2009

(PhysOrg.com) -- Women are not from Venus any more than men are from Mars. But even though both sexes are perfectly terrestrial beings, they are not lacking in other differences. And not only in their reproductive organs and behavior, either, but in such unsexy characteristics as the propensity for drug abuse, fine motor control, reaction to stress, moods and many brain structures.

According to Rockefeller University’s Bruce S. McEwen, who has spent over four decades studying how hormones regulate the brain and nervous system, deciphering the substantial but often ignored differences between the sexes is crucial to developing more effective personalized medicine. In an upcoming issue of Physiology and Behavior, he emphasizes that none of the findings suggest one sex is stronger or more intelligent, and in many cases, the differences discovered raise more questions than they answer.

In spite of the subject’s political sensitivities, McEwen says, it is ignored at our collective peril. “It’s amazing how ignorant people are about this,” says McEwen, the head of the Harold and Margaret Milliken Hatch Laboratory of Neuroendocrinology. “Medicine is clueless as to how males and females really differ from one another. They have a very mechanistic view of disease and they tend to think it always works the same way in both sexes. That can be dangerous.”

His article, “The end of sex as we once knew it,” is the introduction to a special Physiology and Behavior issue devoted to sex differences and outlines increasing research into the pervasive role of hormones in the brain. Men and women differ in crucial brain structures such as the hippocampus, which is known to be critical to learning and memory, and the corpus callosum, which permits the brain’s two hemispheres to talk to one another and integrate. Work by McEwen’s lab and colleagues elsewhere has identified receptors for estrogen and other hormones in many parts of the rat brain and has shown that they do not reside in the neurons’ nuclei, but rather in the dendrites, synapses and other processes. So the hormones don’t act directly on the genes inside the nuclei, but only indirectly through other signaling pathways, recent experiments suggest. In most cases, scientists do not yet know what the behavioral repercussions of this extensive hormone activity in the brain are, but they are likely to be the source of real differences.

Scientists doubted that hormones could even enter the brain until the 1960s, and since then, most have maintained a dogma that they are only involved in reproductive aspects of brain function, McEwen says. On this question, McEwen is a proud heretic. “We know that sex hormones are active in the entire nervous system, both in sexual differentiation and in terms of the activation of neurological, cognitive and emotional processes,” McEwen says.

The debate is not just academic, either. Given the manifold roles hormones seem to play in the brain, and the differences in the hormones of men and women, it is likely that drugs and other treatments for some disorders should be tailored differently for the two sexes, says Elizabeth Waters, a postdoctoral associate in McEwen’s lab.

“Females aren’t males and it’s really important to understand the differences,” Waters says. “It is important to recognize that the female brain acts differently. It may be abstract now, because it’s a basic science question, but once we understand hormones in a healthy brain we can go on to understand what changes when the brain is diseased or needs to be treated with drugs.”

“I feel like this critical gap in knowledge is hindering our moving forward and developing better drugs for the clinic,” she says. “We do a disservice to everyone by not being able to treat women, as well as men, as effectively as possible.”

More information: Physiology and Behavior online: December 13, 2008 - dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.physbeh.2008.12.002

Provided by Rockefeller University

Explore further: Biologists reprogram skin cells to mimic rare disease

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Anti-depressants disrupt fish's brains

Jul 04, 2014

Drugs designed to ease the symptoms of mental health problems such as depression, obsessive compulsive disorder and post-traumatic stress can have major disruptive effects on aquatic animals' brains, say ...

Recommended for you

Biologists reprogram skin cells to mimic rare disease

10 hours ago

Johns Hopkins stem cell biologists have found a way to reprogram a patient's skin cells into cells that mimic and display many biological features of a rare genetic disorder called familial dysautonomia. ...

Student seeks to improve pneumonia vaccines

Aug 20, 2014

Almost a million Americans fall ill with pneumonia each year. Nearly half of these cases require hospitalization, and 5-7 percent are fatal. Current vaccines provide protection against some strains of the ...

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

LuckyBrandon
not rated yet Feb 02, 2009
i like how they dont mention which sex does actually have the higher brain activity.
actually, an article was posted a couple/few days back showing that males have a higher capacity for thinking and learning, basically. but it is highly known that the female has a much higher capacity for communication/all adds up like 1 1 doesnt it :D
Ashibayai
not rated yet Feb 03, 2009
Brain activity doesn't equal intelligence. I think some of the extra activity in females could be for emotion. Sounds like that might be pretty favored since traditionally they were the one's taking the most care of the children and emotional attachment is important in that aspect.
LuckyBrandon
not rated yet Feb 09, 2009
ashibayai-depending on the region of the brain that is activated, it can indicate greater or lesser intelligence on some scale.i can totally see your point on emotions, as is is the exact same reason they are better at communication. females wanted to interact with their offspring and each other better, in order to better take care of their offspring from learned behavior, with vocal communication being a very efficient method of learning.
Gnostica
not rated yet Mar 30, 2009
First of all, men have estrogen too, just not at the same level as women. Second, testosterone affects the brain and I don't see that in this study as all research is primarily done on men so that is a given. Third, mother child bonding is not as a result of estrogen, it's from Oyxtocin. Men also have oxytocin and a slight elevation of it after sex which promotes bonding with your lover. Fancy that. Fourth, men and women have different brain structures and it is true that men are better at rote memory and brute logic. That is why science has been taught for hundreds of years from the male dominated perspective. Women are also very good at science. Some women are able to assimilate into male oriented scientific inquiry but many more women approach science from a holistic view that considers the whole person and their environment, not just a sack of parts to be studies or manipulated. Reductionists.