Slow Down -- Those Lines On The Road Are Longer Than You Think

Feb 02, 2009
We perceive the lane lines on roadways to be much shorter than they are, allowing us to go faster than we should. Credit: Ohio State University

Take a guess -- how long are the dashed lines that are painted down the middle of a road? If you're like most people, you answered, "Two feet."

The real answer is 10 feet. That's the federal guideline for every street, highway, and rural road in the United States, where dashed lines separate traffic lanes or indicate where passing is allowed.

A new study has found that people grossly underestimate the length of these lines -- a finding which implies that we're all misjudging distances as we drive, and are driving too fast as a result.

Dennis Shaffer, assistant professor of psychology at Ohio State University's Mansfield campus, led the study, which appeared in the journal Perception & Psychophysics.

Shaffer and his colleagues tested more than 400 college students in three experiments. When asked to guess the length of the lines from memory, most answered two feet. Even when the students were standing some distance away from actual 10-foot lines or riding by them in a car, they judged the size to be the same: two feet.

"We were surprised, first, that people's estimates were so far off, and second, that there was so little variability," Shaffer said.

The finding holds implications for traffic safety. Each dashed line measures 10 feet, and the empty spaces in-between measure 30 feet. So every time a car passes a new dashed line, the car has traveled 40 feet. But in this study, people consistently judged the lines and the empty spaces to be the same size, claiming that both were two feet.

"This means that to most people, 40 feet looks like a lot less than 40 feet when they're on the road," Shaffer said. "People cover more ground than they think in a given period of time, so they are probably underestimating their speed."

He acknowledges that the study will come as no surprise to transportation engineers, some of whom his team consulted with during the study. But this is the first study to quantify Americans' misperceptions of the lines.

Shaffer began this research when he was a graduate student at Kent State University in 1995, and continued it while he was on the faculty of Arizona State University's West Campus, and now at Ohio State. At each university, he and his colleagues measured lines on a variety of roads in the area.

Over those years, the federal guideline for line size has shrunk from 15 feet to 10 feet. Wherever the researchers went, they found all lines to be close to the federal guidelines of the time. In Arizona in 2000, for instance, some lines were 16 feet long instead of the expected 15.

But even back then -- when the federal guideline was 15 feet -- people still thought of lines as measuring only two feet.

"It was ridiculous," Shaffer said. "We talked to different people in different states, over different years, and whether the lines were 15 feet or 10 feet, people still estimated them to be two feet."

One possible explanation: as we drive, we look out far ahead the car for safety reasons, so the only lines we really see are faraway lines that look small.

Even though lines appear to expand as a car passes by, drivers can't safely notice that effect. Rather, the first line we can comfortably look at while driving safely is some 120 feet ahead -- the fourth line ahead on the road. So perhaps we think that all lines are as small in reality as that one faraway line appears to be.

Some researchers have proposed the idea of "size constancy" to explain our perceptions -- meaning that we see an object as being the same size, no matter how close or far away it is, Shaffer said.

"That seems to be the case for lines on the road, because even if you know how long they are, they still look two feet," he added. "To have a correct perception of the size of an object, you have to be familiar with the object in advance. And that's the clincher. Very few people are familiar with the size of a line on the road in advance."

In the first experiment, researchers gave participants a written test in which they were asked how long they believed the lines and the spaces in-between to be. In the second experiment, the researchers took a piece of paper that was the exact size and shape of a dashed line and taped it to the ground. Participants stood either 60 or 120 feet from the line, and looked at it at an angle close to their line of sight, as they would see it if they were driving down a road. In the third experiment, participants sat in the front or rear passenger seat of a car, and were asked to study the lines and spaces while a researcher drove down an actual road at either 25 or 60 miles per hour.

As to why everyone's estimates were consistent in every experiment, Shaffer suspects that the answer has something to do with how our brains perceive geometry. Engineers design roads, buildings, and public spaces using Euclidian geometry -- the system of lines and angles first described by the ancient Greek mathematician Euclid. But this study and previous ones suggest that our brains perceive objects in a non-Euclidian way.

In the future, Shaffer will examine how people perceive the size of lines that are oriented at different angles -- as if seen by a driver approaching a bend in a road -- and how our perceptions affect our ability to judge the steepness of hills.

Source: Ohio State University

Explore further: New insights into eyewitness memory from groundbreaking replication initiative

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Commercial use of drones has already taken flight

Dec 11, 2013

The camera swoops over the green expanse of the Everglades hundreds of feet below, like many helicopter shots you've seen on television. But suddenly it dips and flies through a narrow, shaded canal where kayakers are paddling, ...

Germany's top court upholds restrictive GM crops law

Nov 24, 2010

Germany's top court on Wednesday upheld a two-year-old law placing sharp restrictions on the use of genetically modified crops, saying it protected the public from the risks of the technology.

U-M announces its first human embryonic stem cell line

Oct 04, 2010

University of Michigan researchers have created the state's first human embryonic stem cell line, achieving a long-sought goal that provides the foundation for future efforts to develop innovative disease treatments.

Gulf crews prepare to start plugging well for good

Aug 02, 2010

(AP) -- The only thing keeping millions more gallons of oil out of the Gulf of Mexico right now is a rush job: an experimental cap that has held for more than two weeks but was never meant to be permanent. ...

Ohio lake's algae dangerous to swimmers, economy

Jul 02, 2010

(AP) -- Patches of green and turquoise slime floated like thick paint in the channel behind Kyle Biesel's home. His pontoon boat sat covered up, unused for weeks, on a wooden lift stained by the algae.

Recommended for you

Mother-daughter research team studies severe-weather phobia

Sep 19, 2014

No one likes severe weather, but for some just the thought of a thunderstorm, tornado, hurricane or blizzard can severely affect their lives. When blood pressures spike, individuals obsessively monitor weather forecasts and ...

Study: Pupil size shows reliability of decisions

Sep 18, 2014

Te precision with which people make decisions can be predicted by measuring pupil size before they are presented with any information about the decision, according to a new study published in PLOS Computational Bi ...

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

TheTim
not rated yet Feb 02, 2009
Possibly, the people involved were legally retarded, explaining why there are so many worthless drivers on the road.
ctrl_alt_del
5 / 5 (1) Feb 02, 2009
It's a bit of a leap (reporter's fault?), to conclude we drive faster because the dashes appear short. The rest of us also go by stationary objects (poles, signs, fences) and other vehicles. Oh yeah, and the SPEEDOMETER. The high-paid researcher that set up this experiment was 'surprised' by the result. The appearance of the dashed lines is 'anamorphic projection'. Check it out:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anamorphosis
www.3d-street-art.com/
bridge.skyline.net/features/angel.html
www.anamorphosis....and.html
www.anamorphosis....all.html
www.tringalis.com...ico.html
I am an unemployed machinist with Comm. College degree and a butt-load of student loans.
ctrl_alt_del
not rated yet Feb 02, 2009
Also, sometime, check out the white turn-lane arrows and any letters painted on the road. They are actually really long and stretched too.