Ideal set-top box would combine DVR, wireless and remote access

Dec 31, 2008 By Etan Horowitz

Each week in the space I review gadgets and electronics and tell you which ones are worth buying. Frankly, it's a selfless job where I try to put your interests above my own. But now it's my turn.

This year, I spent a lot of time testing set-top boxes, devices that connect to your television and let you watch content from another source, such as videos from YouTube, family photos saved on a computer, movies streamed instantly from Netflix, or programming from the cable company. The thinking is that entertainment options are everywhere and consumers love their flat-screen, high-definition TVs so much that they want to watch everything on them, and they don't want to have a bunch of clunky boxes spoiling the view.

I checked out the Neuros OSD, the revamped Apple TV, the Vudu box, the Netflix Player by Roku, the LG Network Blu-ray Disc Player and the SlingCatcher. And although I didn't test them, TiVo's HD boxes are always a strong contender in the set-top box competition. I'm sure I'll see more in a few weeks at the 2009 International Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas.

But so far none of these boxes does it all. So if any consumer electronics manufacturers are listening, here is what I would like to see in my ideal set-top box.

I realize some of these things may not be possible right now because of technical limitations, digital-rights rules, existing agreements, blah blah blah. I don't care. That's why it's my ideal set-top box.

Like a TiVo, it needs to accept CableCards so that I can get programming from my local cable company. Like a cable-company digital video recorder or TiVo, it must have a recording function, so I can watch my favorite TV shows whenever I want. And like a Slingbox, it should let me watch my home TV from a cell phone or computer connected to the Internet.

But because I'm not always connected to the Internet when I want to watch my shows (for example, when I'm on a plane), I need to be able to take the shows I have recorded and convert them a format that I can watch on my computer or iPhone. This is a feature offered by TiVo and the Neuros OSD.

Increasingly, many of the things I want to watch are not broadcast on TV, but are found on Internet sites such as Hulu.com or YouTube, so the box has to be able to access these sites and more. Another option is to create software such as the SlingCatcher's SlingProjector that lets you wirelessly project whatever is on your computer screen to your TV.

Beyond that, sometimes I just want to watch videos or photos I've taken or video podcasts I've downloaded to my computer, so it has to let me wirelessly access media stored on the computers in my house as you can do with Apple TV and other products.

Finally, the box would let me rent or buy movies. Ideally, this would come in the form of streaming through Netflix, something that is included in most monthly plans and is now available on boxes such as TiVo, the Xbox 360, the Netflix Player by Roku and the LG Network Blu-ray Disc Player.

I purposely left out the ability to play DVDs or Blu-ray discs because I didn't want to make this box too huge, and as all types of entertainment continue moving to a digital format, physical discs will likely become less popular.

Plus, DVD players are included on many video-game consoles, though that does mean bringing another dreaded box into the mix.

There you have it. Set-top box makers, are you listening?

___

© 2008, The Orlando Sentinel (Fla.).
Visit the Sentinel on the World Wide Web at www.orlandosentinel.com/.
Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.

Explore further: Form Devices team designs Point as a house sitter

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Bats may be mistaking wind turbines for trees

Sep 30, 2014

Certain bats may be approaching wind turbines after mistaking them for trees, according to a study to be published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Scientific instruments of Rosetta's Philae lander

Sep 23, 2014

When traveling to far off lands, one packs carefully. What you carry must be comprehensive but not so much that it is a burden. And once you arrive, you must be prepared to do something extraordinary to make ...

Recommended for you

Form Devices team designs Point as a house sitter

20 hours ago

A Scandinavian team "with an international outlook" and good eye for electronics, software and design aims to reach success with what they characterize as "a softer take" on home security. Their device is ...

Amazon offers Washington Post app on Kindle

Nov 20, 2014

Amazon said Thursday it will offer a free Washington Post app to Kindle users for six months, a move highlighting the digital strategy for the newspaper owned by Jeff Bezos.

Gift Guide: Help your selfie with some add-on gear

Nov 20, 2014

Not all selfies are created equal. Some are blurry, are poorly framed or miss the action entirely because you might be scrubbing your thumb fishing for a virtual shutter button as the moment passes you by.

User comments : 2

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

humanist
not rated yet Dec 31, 2008
Etan,

If you don't already know how to format your "saved" video for your "mobile" device don't expect an appliance to do it.

Lots of software enable this. McClatchy-Tribune fails again.
LuckyBrandon
not rated yet Jan 04, 2009
Ok first, tivo simply bites. Its not a strong runner of anything unless you are a fan of freezing, missed recordings, and overall extremely slow and poor performance.

It appears a couple glitches and omissions in here, although for the most part I agree:

WAP on STB (Wireless) - this is just a bad idea unless you are willing to also pay for the telivision viewing experience of half your neighbors when they sniff and link to you.

Remote access from the STB - this would be pointless unless you had your STB serving as the router itself. It would be cheaper and easier to implement a remote access point from the router that's likely between this STB and your ISP. It would also provide a more direct route into your home network.

Add ons:

Integrated webcams - video phone/conferencing; online chat rooms; straight to net videos

Peer to peer interaction - STBs functioning as another PC on your network so access is not limited to the STB (and also giving availability for external storage capacity in cloud form across home PCs in bulk)

USB expansion ports..


You know, come to think of it...my setup is still better than this, as I have all of this we're talking about.
Get a good video tuner card for your PC and a good video card for HDMI output and a good size hard drive on a decent computer.....

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.