Australia: Call for choice between Medicare or private health cover

Oct 16, 2008

Australians should be able to choose either private health cover or Medicare to ensure a more efficient and fair system and help reduce public waiting lists, a health care economist from The Australian National University has proposed.

Dr Francesco Paolucci – a Research Fellow at the Australian Centre for Economic Research on Health (ACERH) at ANU – says the current public/private mix in health care financing leads to duplication, high-transaction costs, and long waiting times in the public health sector.

"Although the policy goals of subsidising private health insurance in Australia are, among others, to decrease the pressure on the public system, increase choice and affordability of health coverage to Australians – the current arrangements have led to some perverse incentives and undesirable effects" Dr Paolucci said.

"Giving consumers a choice between Medicare and private health insurance (PHI), combined with a system of risk-adjusted subsidies, would improve incentives for efficiency and increase stability in the PHI market."

Dr Paolucci says Australia should explore introducing consumers' choice of health plan and leave Medicare and the private insurers to compete with each other to be a 'prudent buyer of care'.

"The crucial element of this approach is that it removes duplication of coverage by allowing individuals to choose to be enrolled in one plan or the other. Private health insurers would have to cover all types of services and pay all health care expenses, which is not the case now.

"An essential component of the 'Medicare/PHI choice' would be that as compensation for covering all health care costs, PHI holders or funds receive a risk-adjusted subsidy. In the long run, both PHI and Medicare might receive the same risk-adjusted subsidy from the Government who collects the funds, and manages the risk equalisation fund."

Source: Research Australia

Explore further: Targeting parents along with overweight kids benefits both

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Business CEOs call for raising retirement age

Jan 16, 2013

An influential group of business executives is pushing a plan to increase the full retirement age to 70 for both Social Security and Medicare and to partially privatize the health insurance program for older Americans.

Tech bugs plague federal projects

Dec 05, 2013

t was an ambitious federal technology project, tying together a string of government databases in one Web portal. But the launch was a giant mess: contract missteps, broken deadlines, cost overruns. Users complained the site ...

Wearable robots getting lighter, more portable

May 09, 2013

When Michael Gore stands, it's a triumph of science and engineering. Eleven years ago, Gore was paralyzed from the waist down in a workplace accident, yet he rises from his wheelchair and walks across the ...

Social security: Fixing the glaring gap for women

May 14, 2012

(Phys.org) -- After a lifetime of lower wages and time out of the labor market for caregiving, women typically receive less from Social Security than men, with millions of widows and women of color falling into poverty in ...

Recommended for you

Keep your teens safe on the road this summer

5 hours ago

(HealthDay)—Car crashes are the leading cause of accidental death among American teens, and parents need to take steps to keep their teens safe when they're on the road this summer, an expert says.

User comments : 0