'Dodgy dossier' partly to blame for failure of war against malaria in the tropics

Sep 10, 2008

The war against malaria in tropical countries was fought and lost in the 20th Century on the basis of faulty intelligence, a 'dodgy dossier' which argued that the same methods used to tackle the disease in temperate countries would also work in the tropics.

Eradication failed in almost every tropical and sub-tropical country, because tactics that had been proven to work in countries such as the USA, Greece and Italy were also deployed in tropical countries, despite the existence of evidence that they would they not work, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa.

Dr. Colin Sutherland, a Senior Lecturer at the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, who is contributing to a session entitled 'How science addresses developing world issues' at the BA Festival of Science in Liverpool today, explains: 'Previous efforts to eradicate malaria, if considered on a nation-by-nation basis, only succeeded in countries where the Plasmodium parasite was weak and its mosquito vector was vulnerable, particularly where populations were wealthy enough to afford the best tools available.

'The failure to eradicate malaria in tropical countries, where the parasite is now at its strongest, and the mosquitoes are doing very well, thank you very much is, in part, due to the miscalculation that a one-size-fits-all approach would be effective in every setting – a miscalculation that could have been avoided if we had heeded the evidence from Africa over half a century ago', he adds.

Dr. Sutherland cautions against the obsession among the western media with the 'scientific breakthrough', a concept which consequently dominates popular notions of science. Although breakthroughs do occur, and are undoubtedly newsworthy when they do, it is the careful synthesis of incremental advances in knowledge, and the dissemination of that knowledge to key decision-makers, health ministries and governments that will help us win the war against malaria. Today's session will look at ways of best achieving this, with a particular focus on open access publishing. It will also emphasise the importance of training and support for high calibre African scientists.

'In the war against malaria, knowledge is the most powerful weapon we have', concludes Dr. Sutherland.

Source: London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine

Explore further: ACG: Drug-induced liver injury mainly due to antimicrobials

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Climate change as a matter of public health

Apr 08, 2014

For a long time people perceived climate change as an environmental issue–the concern of environmentalists, the concern of a few. It was reframed as a justice issue at the turn of the 21st century, when ...

Recommended for you

Ebola: Five questions about the killer virus

27 minutes ago

The highly contagious Ebola virus, which has killed more than 4,500 people in west Africa since December and has fueled global alarm, is among the most dangerous ever identified.

Ebola fear, monitoring eases for some in Dallas

37 minutes ago

The people closest to Ebola victim Thomas Eric Duncan are trying to resume their lives now that they have come out of a 21-day incubation period without developing symptoms of the disease.

Third UN employee dies from Ebola

47 minutes ago

A UN staff member in Sierra Leone has died from Ebola, the third employee from the world organization to succumb to the deadly virus, the UN spokesman said Monday.

Canadian Ebola vaccine sent to WHO for testing

57 minutes ago

The first batch of an experimental Ebola vaccine developed by Canadian scientists was sent to Switzerland on Monday for testing by the World Health Organization, officials said.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

jscroft
not rated yet Sep 10, 2008
Blame? Look no farther than Rachel Carlson, the environmentalist wacko whose campaign of misinformation resulted in a worldwide ban on DDT. Judicious applications of DDT were almost universally effective in eradicating plasmodium-carrying mosquitos.

In the period from 1934-1955 there were 1.5 million cases of malaria in Sri Lanka, resulting in 80,000 deaths. After the country invested in an extensive anti-mosquito program with DDT, there were only 17 cases reported in 1963. Thereafter the program was halted, and malaria in Sri Lanka rebounded to 600,000 cases in 1968 and the first quarter of 1969. Although mosquitos CAN develop a resistance to DDT, research shows that this does NOT happen when the substance is used in an intelligent manner (as opposed to wholesale saturation of the countryside).

About a million people die of malaria every year in Africa alone, mostly kids under five. The hands of all those who support the anti-human, environmentalist agenda are stained with their blood.