How true is conventional wisdom about price volatility of tech metals?

February 12, 2016 by Laura Millsaps

It's often assumed that exotic metals and minerals critical to clean energy technologies are more price volatile than more common commodity metals. They're mined in much smaller quantities and often as by-products of other high-volume production materials, and even slight changes in production, demand, and consumer end-uses can greatly affect markets.

But are they really more price-volatile? Preliminary research by the Colorado School of Mines (Mines) and funded by the Critical Materials Institute (CMI) suggests that conventional wisdom about the high price volatility of by-product metals and minerals is generally true, but with several caveats.

"There's actually been very little empirical evaluation of the , and this was an attempt to test that," said Rod Eggert, Deputy Director of CMI and professor at Mines. "This is a beginning. Further research could help us understand what's truly driving price volatility."

The research used regression analysis to compare the price volatility of by-product metals and minerals to commodity materials produced primarily or solely as main-products or individual products.

The data showed that over the past 50 years, using annual average pricing, metals and minerals with significant by-product production were 50 percent more volatile than those produced as main or individual products. But in contrast to annual data, monthly price data from the past ten years showed only mixed evidence that by-products have greater price volatility.

Eggert said the mixed evidence of price volatility using monthly price data may be explained by the smaller volume of transactions for by-product materials on a month-to-month basis, often leading to unchanged published prices for several months at a time.

The paper laid the groundwork for further study, which should investigate the underlying determinants of price volatility, which may include one or more of the following characteristics of metals produced as by-products: the dependence of by-product supply on developments in markets for the associated main product, the generally small number of producing mines or companies, few consumers and end-use applications and the general lack of transparency in these markets. All of these characteristics make by-product prices potentially more prone to volatility.

Understanding price volatility helps CMI make assessments of what materials may face supply risks in the future—risks that may come in the form of either price volatility or physical unavailability of material, said Eggert.

"This helps us begin to understand the markets for a number of elements that up until now have been used in relatively small quantities in limited applications," said Eggert. "But these elements could be used in much greater quantities if certain clean develop and grow."

"We read a lot of opinion about the prices of rare earths and other and where they're going. But CMI must focus on actual data. In order to direct our scientific research on the uses of these materials the most effectively, we must check these assumptions against what the numbers are really telling us," said CMI Director Alex King.

The results of the research were published in the paper "Volatility of by-product metal and mineral prices" in Resources Policy by Michael Redlinger and Roderick Eggert from the Division of Economics and Business, Colorado School of Mines, and funded by the Critical Materials Institute.

Explore further: Will growth in low-carbon technologies lead to metals scarcity?

More information: Michael Redlinger et al. Volatility of by-product metal and mineral prices, Resources Policy (2016). DOI: 10.1016/j.resourpol.2015.12.002

Related Stories

China sets up rare earths industry group

April 9, 2012

(AP) -- China has set up a rare earths industry association to fend off trade complaints and help regulate the sector that is critical to global high-tech manufacturing.

How to kick-start new energy technologies

December 22, 2011

The world desperately needs innovation in energy technologies — but those innovations are unlikely to happen by themselves. A three-year study by a team of researchers based at MIT has now identified a suite of policy ...

Wandering Jupiter accounts for our unusual solar system

March 23, 2015

Long before Mercury, Venus, Earth, and Mars formed, it seems that the inner solar system may have harbored a number of super-Earths—planets larger than Earth but smaller than Neptune. If so, those planets are long gone—broken ...

Rare earth metals: Another challenge for the green economy?

April 3, 2012

If you follow the clean energy dialogue, then you may have encountered discussions about the role of rare earth metals at some point in the last year or two. If not, read on, because rare earths should not be a rare topic ...

Facebook's stock sinks, so who should buy it?

July 27, 2012

(AP) — Investors are dumping Facebook's stock, spooked by slowing revenue growth, the lack of a financial outlook and plans to spend more money in the coming months.

Recommended for you

An inflexible diet led to the disappearance of the cave bear

August 23, 2016

Senckenberg scientists have studied the feeding habits of the extinct cave bear. Based on the isotope composition in the collagen of the bears' bones, they were able to show that the large mammals subsisted on a purely vegan ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.