Adaptive control techniques can help manage pests more effectively

February 9, 2016

As population growth, greater food consumption, competition for land use, and climate change pose challenges to world food production, managing loss of crop due to pests and weeds becomes increasingly important. While chemical pesticides offer effective means for control, potential loss of crop yield is still significant, as is cost. Global potential loss from pests has been estimated to be between 50% and 80% of yield based on crop type.

In a paper published last week in the SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics, authors Chris Guiver et al propose adaptive techniques to model pest dynamics and management as a control system.

Mathematics has been used to model pest control in other studies. Most of the prevailing approaches rely on deterministic or stochastic optimal control tools, where a management or intervention strategy is used to accomplish a desired behavior and minimize cost. There are pitfalls to these approaches, most notable of which is the capability to handle the uncertainty in pest dynamics due to the interaction of novel species and environments.

"Modeling for the purposes of pest management is inherently uncertain," says Stuart Townley, co-author and principle investigator on the project. "Vital rates of pests, such as birth and growth rate, and fertility, are highly sensitive to uncertain and stochastic environmental conditions, while data are often limited; so detailed models to guide decision making are unlikely to be available. Relying on tools from optimal control which require this level of detail could result in poor or fragile performance."

Adaptive control, on the other hand, works around the uncertainty because it does not need prior information about uncertain parameters.

"Our study's primary insight is that, given the uncertainty surrounding models for pests, design of pest management strategies faces two approaches: either develop better models so that optimal controls can be more effective, or adopt design approaches that tolerate the likely level of uncertainty to be faced," says author Brigitte Tenhumberg.

The authors adopt the latter approach by using adaptive control techniques. The input, state, and output in the control system are represented by pest control, the pest population, and some measure of the population respectively. The goal of the control system then, is to eradicate or lower the pest population by determining an input which stabilizes the model, driving state variables to zero.

The advantage of adaptive control is that it achieves state stability with minimal knowledge of the system to be controlled, and is simple to compute. The system does not seek to update the dynamic model over time by inferring or estimating parameters. The management strategy, in turn, changes over time in response to how the measured variable changes.

The downside of adaptive controllers is that the additional robustness needed to model uncertainty concedes a loss in optimality.

As author Markus Mueller explains, "The trade-off between robustness and optimality is pivotal in all areas where management or control decisions are made. Management actions can steer closer to optimal decisions when reliable models are available. However, when models are poor, as is the case with pests, actions need to be more cautious and robust. It is at this end of decision making where adaptive control is especially appealing and offers significant advantages compared to other optimal or robust control approaches."

The uncertainty in models necessitates approaches that must be both robust and capable of quantifying the level of uncertainty they can handle.

"In applications, the compromise between robustness and optimality also has economic considerations," adds Guiver. "Optimality may reduce implementation costs, but is susceptible to costly failure; while robustness would have higher implementation costs, it compensates for these potential failures and consequent losses."

Future work from the group includes adaptive deployment of biocontrol agents in order to reduce chemical pesticide usage. This would involve modeling the dynamics of the biocontrol agents in addition to that of pests. Modeling of the spatial distribution of pests will also be incorporated.

"So far, our work has focused on the temporal aspects of pests with abundance changing in time. Clearly, pest abundance has a spatial dimension and this needs to be addressed as well when designing pest management strategies," says author Richard Rebarber. "Here, pest management would seek to reduce, or contain, both the spread of a pest and its abundance. Since using pesticides can have unwelcome consequences, we are also exploring the use of adaptive feedback control in the design of strategies based around bio-control (also known as natural enemies, or -predators)."

"Pest management is one of the key factors in addressing the challenge of food security for a burgeoning world population with an increasing per-capita demand," says author Brigitte Tenhumberg. "Addressing food security undoubtedly requires a holistic approach, drawing upon input from policy makers and stakeholders, as well as theoretical insights from academia. Our contribution is to seek approaches to reducing crop losses to pests by applying less pesticide more effectively."

Explore further: The billion dollar game of strategy: The effect of farmers' decisions on pest control

More information: Chris Guiver et al. Simple Adaptive Control for Positive Linear Systems with Applications to Pest Management, SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics (2016). DOI: 10.1137/140996926

Related Stories

Integrated pest management for billbugs in orchardgrass

December 3, 2013

Two weevil species, the bluegrass billbug and the hunting billbug, have caused widespread economic damage to orchardgrass, a cool season grass that is cultivated throughout the United States as a high-value forage crop.

Recommended for you

Game theory research reveals fragility of common resources

September 29, 2016

New research in game theory shows that people are naturally predisposed to over-use "common-pool resources" such as transportation systems and fisheries even if it risks failure of the system, to the detriment of society ...

Giant dinosaur footprint discovered in Mongolia desert

September 30, 2016

One of the biggest dinosaur footprints ever recorded has been unearthed in the Gobi Desert, researchers said Friday, offering a fresh clue about the giant creatures that roamed the earth millions of years ago.

3-D printed fish fossil may reveal origin of human teeth

September 30, 2016

Three-dimensional prints of a 400 million year old fish fossil from around Lake Burrinjuck in southeast Australia reveal the possible evolutionary origins of human teeth, according to new research by The Australian National ...

Humans may have occupied Southern Cone 14,000 years ago

September 29, 2016

Humans may have occupied the Southern Cone 14,000 years ago, according to a study published September 28, 2016 in the open-access journal PLOS ONE by Gustavo Politis from CONICET and the Universidad Nacional del Centro de ...

Ancient reptile fossils claw for more attention

September 29, 2016

Newly recovered fossils confirm that Drepanosaurus, a prehistoric cross between a chameleon and an anteater, was a small reptile with a fearsome finger. The second digit of its forelimb sported a massive claw.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.