New experimental test detects signs of Lyme disease near time of infection

February 12, 2016 by Mark Bello
Deer, or black-legged, ticks can transmit Lyme disease to humans during feeding, when they insert their mouth parts into the skin. A new experimental test developed at NIST has been shown to detect the disease near the time of infection, earlier than the standard blood test now used. Credit: James Gathany/CDC

When it comes to early diagnosis of Lyme disease, the insidious tick-borne illness that afflicts about 300,000 Americans annually, finding the proverbial needle in the haystack might be a far easier challenge—until now, perhaps. An experimental method developed by federal and university researchers appears capable of detecting the stealthy culprit Lyme bacteria at the earliest time of infection, when currently available tests are often still negative.

The team suggests the approach might also be useful for early detection of other elusive bacterial infections. The collaborators—from the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), Institute for Bioscience and Biotechnology Research, and Johns Hopkins School of Medicine—recently reported the successful first trial of their new method.

"Our hypothesis was that Lyme bacteria shed vesicle-like particles—or fragments—derived from the cell wall of the bacteria circulating in the serum of individuals. These particles would contain membrane proteins that can be detected to provide a unique indicator of infection," explains NIST research chemist Larik Turko.

The challenge was to detect these bacterial membrane proteins among the far, far more plentiful proteins normally present in serum, the watery, cell-free component of blood. The researchers speculated that running serum samples through a high-speed centrifuge—a standard step in chemistry labs—might selectively concentrate the larger, heavier fragments containing the bacterial membrane proteins into pellets. In effect, they predicted, this step would separate the wheat—the sparse target proteins—from the chaff—the much more abundant human serum proteins.

The new method's promise was demonstrated in tests on serum samples drawn from three patients with undetected Lyme disease at the time of their initial doctor visit. By customizing standard analytical techniques for determining the types and amounts of chemicals in a sample, the team detected extremely small amounts of the target protein in all three samples. For chemistry buffs, the protein in enriched samples was present at a level of about four billionths of a millionth of a mole, the standard unit for amount of substance.

In one patient, the experimental method detected the bacteria three weeks before infection was confirmed with the standard blood tests now used. For the other two, infection was detected simultaneously by the two methods.

"The complexity of Lyme disease, combined with lack of biomarkers to measure infection, has slowed progress," study collaborator John Aucott, head of the Johns Hopkins Lyme Disease Clinical Research Center.. "Now, thanks to recent advances in technology, the tiniest concentration of blood molecules can now be detected, molecules that were previously 'invisible' to scientists."

Aucott will feature the joint study as an example in his 2016 AAAS Annual Meeting presentation, Big Data Clinical Realities and the Human Dimensions of Interoperable Data.

The current standard blood test for Lyme disease exposes the infection only after antibodies have accumulated to detectable levels, which can take up to 4 to 6 weeks. If patients exhibit a telltale bull's-eye rash, diagnosis and treatment can begin earlier. But the rash does not occur in 20 to 30 percent of Lyme disease patients, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Rather than waiting for an infected person's immune system to produce noticeable amounts of antibodies, the team chose to home in on the bacteria itself—specifically, proteins the bug sheds when attacked by the body's defenses.

"From many candidates, we chose one that is both easily distinguished from human serum proteins and an unambiguous indicator of the bacteria," Turko says. "This protein, which resides on the outer surface of membranes, became the target of our search in serum samples."

But finding that target required an important preliminary step to ensure the accuracy of their measurements: making a reference sample that contained ample amounts of the target protein. With the reference sample, the team established the unmistakable signature the bug's outer-surface membrane protein would yield when they examined samples drawn from patients. As a result of these steps, the team could detect the copies of the , even though human proteins were 10 million times more plentiful.

"We believe that this approach may be universally applicable to detection of other bacterial infections in humans," the researchers write.

Explore further: Researchers identify new Borrelia species that causes Lyme disease

More information: C.S.F. Cheung, K.W. Anderson, K.Y. Villatoro Benitez, M.J. Soloski, J.N. Aucott, K.W. Phinney, and I.V. Turko, "Quantification of Borrelia burgdorferi Membrane Proteins in Human Serum: A New Concept for Detection of Bacterial Infection." Analytical Chemistry (2015) 87, 11383-11388.

Related Stories

Gene signature could lead to a new way of diagnosing Lyme

February 12, 2016

Researchers at UC San Francisco and Johns Hopkins may have found a new way to diagnose Lyme disease, based on a distinctive gene "signature" they discovered in white blood cells of patients infected with the tick-borne bacteria.

'Water on the knee' could be early sign of Lyme disease

November 1, 2015

Spontaneous knee effusion, also known as "water on the knee," can be a primary symptom of Lyme disease, even when patients do not exhibit a "bull's eye" rash, another common Lyme disease symptom. According to a literature ...

Imperfect test fuels alternative treatments for Lyme disease

August 17, 2015

Lyme disease conjures memories of checking for ticks at camp and fretting over bug bites after hikes in the woods. But far from a summertime nuisance, Lyme is a potentially debilitating disease - and the subject of a vigorous ...

Recommended for you

Turning CO2 to stone

October 25, 2016

Earth has limits to the amount of carbon dioxide in its atmosphere before the environment as we know it starts to change. Too much CO2 absorbed by the oceans makes the water more acidic. Too much in the atmosphere warms the ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.