Worsening US droughts demand alternative water protection approaches, study suggests

December 4, 2015
Worsening U.S. droughts demand alternative water protection approaches, study suggests
Fall in the Wasatch Mountains. Credit: Utah Wildflowers

Alternative models of watershed protection that balance recreational use and land conservation must no longer be ignored to preserve water supplies against the effects of climate change, argues a new study. Researchers claim that the management of Salt Lake City's Wasatch watershed in Utah provides a valuable example contradicting the dominant view presented in academic literature that informs many current conservation strategies.

Salt Lake City's preservation of the Wasatch is an important model for protecting urban water sources through land use regulation and conservation, which could have important implications for preserving future against the effects of in the American West, according to a new study. This example is currently absent from academic literature on , meaning that conservation discussions are instead dominated by models that focus on financial, 'market-based' incentives to protect watershed areas, which the researchers argue could be inappropriate in many circumstances.

The most prevalent model for water resource preservation is that of New York City's Catskills/Delaware watershed, which is based on upstream resource users being paid to avoid harmful practices that might affect water flows and water quality, typically by beneficiaries who are downstream. These 'market-based' approaches (also known as Payments for Watershed or Ecosystem Services) have been widely promoted, but risk neglecting alternative approaches that do not always require monetary transactions to improve environmental outcomes.

In contrast, Salt Lake City's management strategy allows regulated use of the watershed area for public recreation (unlike other forested catchments in the US where public access is prohibited to preserve ). In the Wasatch case, this means that the upstream catchment remains accessible, including for high impact uses such as skiing and mountain biking. Researchers argue that it is vital to consider these alternative strategies for solving the increasing in the American West.

"While regulatory exclusion is often thought of as the only viable alternative to market-based incentives in managing ecosystem services, the management of the Wasatch watershed provides a third, yet under-recognised, successful conservation strategy for water resources," says Libby Blanchard, lead author of the study from the University of Cambridge's Department of Geography.

Recreation in the Wasatch watershed. Credit: Libby Blanchard

"The dominance of the Catskills example in discussions of watershed protection provides an unduly limited, and historically incomplete, perspective on interventions to secure water resources, and limits policy discussions about alternative conservation approaches," she adds.

In the American West, unprecedented droughts have caused extreme water shortages. The current drought in California and across the West is entering its fourth year, with precipitation and water storage reaching record low levels. Droughts are ranked second in the US in terms of national weather-related economic impacts, with annual losses just shy of $9 billion. With water scarcity likely to increase due to advancing climate change, the economic and environmental impacts of drought are also likely to get worse.

"The chances of a 'megadrought' – one that lasts for 35 years or longer – affecting the Southwest and central Great Plains by 2100 are above 80% if climate change projections are not mitigated," says Blanchard. "As the West faces more frequent and severe droughts, the successful protection of watersheds for the ecosystem services of water capture, storage, and delivery they provide will be increasingly important."

"The sufficient and effective protection of watersheds will become more challenging, so awareness of alternative, successful strategies is critically important," adds Bhaskar Vira, co-author of the study also from Cambridge's Department of Geography. "The management of the Wasatch is one such strategy that should be more widely recognised amongst policymakers and researchers alike seeking effective solutions to water scarcity."

The economic and instrumental value of the Wasatch watershed was noticed by Salt Lake City's government as early as the 1850s, when the first legislation to protect the city's natural resources was passed. Salt Lake City uses two tools to protect its watershed: purchasing land for conservation, and regulating land use by restricting a variety of activities within the watershed such as cattle grazing. Recreation is not altogether restricted, but is negotiated with the local community to allow public use. The Uinta-Wasatch-Cache National Forest is one of the most heavily visited national forests in the US, with 7 million annual visitors.

"Salt Lake City has been able to preserve the natural capital that protects its watershed while allowing recreational use. The preservation of the watershed actually boosts recreation, providing visitors with natural landscapes and unadulterated settings for mountain biking, hiking, skiing, and fly-fishing," says Blanchard.

The city raises funds to buy land within the watershed through a surcharge on water customers' monthly bills, which provides around $1.5 million each year to protect watershed lands from development. Since 1907, the city has managed to purchase over 23,000 acres of the watershed.

"Despite the popularity and power of the Catskills narrative to promote the preservation of ecosystems via market-based incentives, we found that this narrative is at best partial, and quite possibly flawed," says Blanchard.

"The Wasatch's absence in the ecosystem literature results in an incomplete perspective on interventions to secure watershed ecosystem services and limits policy discussions in relation to alternative conservation approaches. It is vital that such alternatives are given more recognition in order to find effective solutions for the protection of natural capital in the future."

Explore further: Dry lake city: Great Salt Lake is shrinking

More information: Libby Blanchard et al. The lost narrative: Ecosystem service narratives and the missing Wasatch watershed conservation story, Ecosystem Services (2015). DOI: 10.1016/j.ecoser.2015.10.019

Related Stories

Dry lake city: Great Salt Lake is shrinking

February 26, 2016

Utah's Great Salt Lake is the defining physical feature of its arid Western state. Seventy-five miles long and nearly 35 miles wide, the salt water remnant of ancient Lake Bonneville teems with aquatic life, serves as a critical ...

A new analysis and approach to watershed management

September 18, 2015

The first continent-wide, multi-factor analysis of climate and land cover effects on watersheds in the United States, published today, provides a broad new assessment of runoff, flooding and storm water management options ...

Recommended for you

Scientists examine bacterium found 1,000 feet underground

December 8, 2016

Pioneering work being carried out in a cave in New Mexico by researchers at McMaster University and The University of Akron, Ohio, is changing the understanding of how antibiotic resistance may have emerged and how doctors ...

3 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

OdinsAcolyte
1 / 5 (2) Dec 04, 2015
More governmwent is always the wrong solution.
thermodynamics
5 / 5 (3) Dec 04, 2015
More governmwent is always the wrong solution.


How about when we go to war? Do you want a small government then?
antigoracle
1 / 5 (4) Dec 04, 2015
More governmwent is always the wrong solution.


How about when we go to war? Do you want a small government then?

Strong be the stupid in this one, Padawan. Thermoidiot for president!! Bigger government and more wars.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.