Competition between trees the main driver of forest change

March 20, 2015 by Michel Proulx
Fangliang He and his research team examined data collected from 1,680 permanent sample plots over 50 years across Western Canada. They found that competition, rather than climate change, is the primary factor causing long-term changes in tree mortality and growth.

Contrary to conventional wisdom, new research reveals that it is competition, not climate change, that has a greater impact on the changing composition of forests in Western Canada.

Forests are fundamental to sustaining the global environment, by storing carbon and maintaining biodiversity. But forests in many parts of the world have been undergoing rapid change in the last few decades and the environmental benefits they provide are at risk of declining, according to experts.

Fangliang He, a researcher in the Faculty of Agricultural, Life and Environmental Sciences who is an expert in biodiversity and landscape modelling, and his research team—PhD student Jian Zhang and Shongming Huang, a senior biometrician with Alberta Environment and Sustainable Resource Development—wanted to find out how climate change and competition affected those long-term changes.

He and his team looked at the combined effects of competition and climate change at the same time by studying data compiled over 50 years (1958 to 2009) on 1,680 permanent sample plots in undisturbed natural forests in Western Canada. They found that tree demographic rates have changed markedly over the last five decades.

"We observed a widespread, significant increase in , a significant decrease in tree growth and a similar but weaker trend of decreasing recruitment," said He, adding that these changes varied widely across tree size, forest age, ecological zones and species.

"Competition is the primary factor that is causing the long-term changes in tree mortality, growth and recruitment," added Zhang. "Regional climate had a weaker yet still significant effect on tree mortality, but little effect on and recruitment."

The finding has profound practical implications for , the authors said.

"Our results imply that, by controlling competition through better practices and regulations to manage the density of forest stands, forest practitioners can improve the growth of forests," said Huang.

The researchers also said that existing forest growth models developed from competition theory remain the most important and critical management tool for projecting future forests. To cope with climate change, however, future models should consider the dimension of climate, but not overemphasize it.

Climate change is often presumed to be responsible for changes in the forest, with surprisingly little attention being paid to the possible effects of internal factors despite the well-known fact that competition is an important force driving stand dynamics and succession.

The study sends a timely message to the scientific community that the current trend of climate-only studies potentially overlooks other processes important to dynamics, and thus could be biased.

"We believe we know why people are more willing to focus on than other processes," added Huang. "There is no question that climate is increasingly becoming important, and we don't intend to question the soundness of these works. However, we certainly see the importance of considering the combined effects of competition and climate to form a more complete, balanced understanding of what has happened—and what will likely happen—in the forests."

The research was published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Explore further: Amazon's carbon uptake declines as trees die faster

More information: Half-century evidence from western Canada shows forest dynamics are primarily driven by competition followed by climate, Jian Zhang, DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1420844112

Related Stories

Amazon's carbon uptake declines as trees die faster

March 18, 2015

The most extensive land-based study of the Amazon to date reveals it is losing its capacity to absorb carbon from the atmosphere. From a peak of two billion tonnes of carbon dioxide each year in the 1990s, the net uptake ...

Climate change is fueling forest disturbances

August 4, 2014

Climate change is already altering the environment. Long-lived ecosystems such as forests are particularly vulnerable to the comparatively rapid changes in the climate system. A new international study published this week ...

Forest tree seeds stored in the Svalbard seed vault

February 26, 2015

A new method for the conservation of the genetic diversity of forest trees will see its launch on 26 February 2015, as forest tree seeds are for the first time stored in the Svalbard Global Seed Vault on the Spitsbergen Island, ...

Recommended for you

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Mar 20, 2015
Of course competition for resources is continuous. As resources such as soil moisture decline, natural thinning occurs. As they increase, recruitment increases. If climate change alters the supply of resources, it will act through competition to alter the growth and survival of trees. Hard to picture a forester anywhere that doesn't know this.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.