Surviving the attack of killer microbes

August 19, 2014 by Poncie Rutsch
Spear-shaped viruses attack a spherical microbe. The microbe is a dead ARMAN, and the viruses represent at least two different types of virus. This image is a slice from a 3D cryo-ET reconstruction of an acid mine drainage biofilm region produced by Dr. Luis R. Comolli, guest editor of Frontiers in Microbiology.

The ability to find food and avoid predation dictates whether most organisms live to spread their genes to the next generation or die trying. But for some species of microbe, a unique virus changes the rules of the game. This unusual virus turns some individual microbes into killers. That is, when these killer microbes encounter any other microbe that is competing with them for resources, they kill that microbe on the spot.

One would imagine that eventually, only killer microbes would remain, because all non-killer, or sensitive microbes, would die. But this is not the case. In both wild and in-vitro experiments, the sensitive microbes persist. This question piqued the interest of mathematician Robert Sinclair, a professor at Okinawa Institute of Science and Technology Graduate University who heads the Mathematical Biology unit.

Sinclair first heard about killer microbes from Prof. Alexander Mikheyev in the OIST Ecology and Evolution unit.  He credits the design of the university for fostering interactions between researchers. "I would never have known about killer microbes if I had been at a normal university," explained Sinclair.

Mikheyev, who frequently uses baker's yeast as his microbial study subject, had been following emerging research on how specific viruses were turning individual yeast cells into killers. "You can look at the question more broadly," explained Mikheyev, "as 'What happens when you have different strategies for surviving?' We cannot see most of the microbial world, and it is run by different laws than our own."

Surviving the Attack of Killer Microbes
Professor Robert Sinclair sits in Café Kaito+ at OIST, where researchers often come to have a bite to eat and talk to other researchers.

In the past, researchers have shown that producing more offspring was the sensitive microbes' key to survival. If the sensitive microbes had a higher reproduction rate, or reproduced far more offspring than the killer microbes, there was no way the killer microbes could kill them all. But no one could assign a number, to show exactly how much more prolific the sensitive microbes would need to be.

As a mathematician, Sinclair saw the question differently: in terms of infinity. "There are many infinities," said Sinclair, "and they're all quite different."  In this case, he wondered if only an infinitesimally small change in reproduction rate would make the difference between sensitive microbes' persistence and death. Instead of modeling hundreds of scenarios, each with a slightly smaller difference in reproduction rate, he would set up a proof and find out.

Sinclair wrote equations somewhat like the logistic growth model, a standard theory that represents population growth. Then he analyzed the equation to determine just how many more offspring the sensitive strain needed to reproduce in order to survive. He found that one doesn't need to measure the reproduction rate between sensitives and killers. As long as the sensitive strain has the higher , it can coexist with killer . His result was published July 14, 2014 in Frontiers in Microbiology.

A virus, pictured at upper center, attacks one species of microbe, called an ARMAN cell. The ARMAN cell is connected to another species of microbe, called a Thermoplasmatal cell, through a remarkable tubular appendage. This image is a slice from a 3D cryo-ET reconstruction of an acid mine drainage biofilm region produced by Dr. Luis R. Comolli, guest editor of Frontiers in Microbiology.

In addition to solving the killer microbe conundrum, Sinclair's analysis is unusual because it discusses the infinitesimally small. This idea is typically restricted to pure mathematics, because it is hard to model infinity. "Going to infinity presents trouble," Sinclair explained. "There are things that can happen that you do not expect." Applying the infinitesimally small to a real world situation bridges the gap between pure mathematics and applied mathematics. "It's not that these topics are so monstrously different," said Sinclair.  "I would like to break this artificial boundary pure mathematics and applied mathematics."

Explore further: A microbe's trick for staying young

More information: The complete paper is available online:

Related Stories

A microbe's trick for staying young

September 12, 2013

Researchers have discovered a microbe that stays forever young by rejuvenating every time it reproduces. The findings, published in Current Biology, provide fundamental insights into the mechanisms of aging.

Are tiny microbes outwitting us to steal our food?

March 31, 2014

It's long been know that microbes are to blame for food going off and becoming rotten but in the late 1970's, Dan Janzen of the University of Pennsylvania, and a winner of ecology's version of the Nobel Prize, suggested that ...

Of dinosaurs and mathematics

June 5, 2014

Dinosaurs and mathematics do not seem like an obvious pair, but for Professor Robert Sinclair and his Mathematical Biology Unit, they are a logical match.  Sinclair was part of a team that recently published a paper in Alcheringa: ...

New discovery: Microbes create dripstones

August 18, 2014

According to new research humble, microscopic organisms can create dripstones in caves. This illustrates how biological life can influence the formation of Earth's geology - and the same may be happening right now on other ...

Recommended for you

New gene map reveals cancer's Achilles heel

November 25, 2015

Scientists have mapped out the genes that keep our cells alive, creating a long-awaited foothold for understanding how our genome works and which genes are crucial in disease like cancer.

Study suggests fish can experience 'emotional fever'

November 25, 2015

(—A small team of researchers from the U.K. and Spain has found via lab study that at least one type of fish is capable of experiencing 'emotional fever,' which suggests it may qualify as a sentient being. In their ...

How cells in the developing ear 'practice' hearing

November 25, 2015

Before the fluid of the middle ear drains and sound waves penetrate for the first time, the inner ear cells of newborn rodents practice for their big debut. Researchers at Johns Hopkins report they have figured out the molecular ...

How cells 'climb' to build fruit fly tracheas

November 25, 2015

Fruit fly windpipes are much more like human blood vessels than the entryway to human lungs. To create that intricate network, fly embryonic cells must sprout "fingers" and crawl into place. Now researchers at The Johns Hopkins ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.