Judge rejects Silicon Valley anti-poaching settlement

Aug 09, 2014
Attendees gather at the Apple Worldwide Developers Conference on June 2, 2014 in San Francisco, California

A federal judge Friday rejected a plan to compensate employees affected by an "anti-poaching" agreement involving Silicon Valley tech giants Apple, Google, Intel and Adobe.

Judge Lucy Koh said in a ruling that the $324 million class-action was too low, compared with a deal with other companies sealed a year ago.

"The court finds the total settlement amount falls below the range of reasonableness," the judge said in her ruling.

"The court is concerned that class members recover less on a proportional basis from the instant settlement with (the four companies) than from the settlement with the settled defendants a year ago, despite the fact that the case has progressed consistently in the class's favor since then."

The long-running case alleged that major tech companies in Silicon Valley had secret agreements not to hire each other's employees, in a move to keep salaries under control.

The lawsuit alleged that the late Apple chief Steve Jobs, Google chairman Eric Schmidt and other tech executives were part of the conspiracy.

Other companies in the lawsuit which reached earlier settlements included eBay, Lucasfilm, Pixar and Intuit.

An Intel employee demonstrates the Intel touchscreen display on January 7, 2010 in Las Vegas, Nevada

Koh said the latest settlement would end up giving each plaintiff an average of $3,750—after deducting attorney's costs and other expenses—with the money divided up among the 64,000 class members.

She said the plaintiffs had been seeking $3 billion in total damages, and that the amount could be tripled under antitrust law under certain conditions.

Had the case gone to trial, the said, there would have been "compelling" evidence against the companies, including statements and admission from key executives about the collusion.

"This is particularly true for Google and Apple, the executives of which extensively discussed and enforced the anti-solicitation agreements," she wrote.

Explore further: Silicon Valley no-poaching settlement in doubt

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Silicon Valley no-poaching settlement in doubt

May 16, 2014

Casting some doubt on a proposed $324 million settlement with four Silicon Valley powers, a lead plaintiff in a lawsuit alleging illegal hiring practices in the tech industry has urged a federal judge to reject the pact, ...

Workers in tech case likely to get average of $4K

May 23, 2014

Nearly 60,000 high-tech workers are likely to receive an average of $4,000 apiece in a settlement of a class-action lawsuit alleging Apple and Google conspired in an illegal cartel of Silicon Valley employers that secretly ...

Judge deals blow to high-tech workers' lawsuit (Update)

Apr 05, 2013

A federal judge on Friday struck down an effort to form a class action lawsuit to go after Apple, Google and five other technology companies for allegedly forming an illegal cartel to tamp down workers' wages ...

US judge allows tech 'poaching' suit to proceed

Apr 19, 2012

A US judge has given a green light to a lawsuit charging Apple, Google, Pixar and other technology-driven firms with colluding to keep salaries in check by agreeing not to poach one another's software engineers.

Recommended for you

Sony film mess reflects gadgets-entertainment gap

2 hours ago

Sony's iconic gadgetry and the star appeal of Hollywood may have appeared to be a perfect match when the electronics giant bought Columbia Pictures in 1989. A quarter century later, it's apparent that Sony ...

LivingSocial's new CEO eyes an experience-oriented future

Dec 24, 2014

Some big challenges lie ahead for LivingSocial, the online marketplace known for its daily deals and discounted prices on restaurants, spas and local activities. But that's where the company's new chief executive, Gautam ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

alfie_null
not rated yet Aug 10, 2014
Leaving $84 million. Regarding vocation, a hint for all those underpaid engineers in Silicon Valley.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.