Monkeys take 'selfies,' sparking copyright dispute

Aug 07, 2014 by Sylvia Hui

Monkey see, monkey do. But when a monkey takes a selfie, who owns the copyright?

A series of self-portraits taken by Indonesian monkeys has sparked a copyright dispute between Wikipedia and a British wildlife photographer, who wasn't amused that the popular images are being used for free.

Photographer David Slater complained Thursday that Wikipedia rejected his requests for the images to be removed from the website. He said he owns the copyright to the images of crested black macaque monkeys, which were taken in the Indonesian jungle in 2011.

Slater told the BBC that although the monkeys pressed the button, he had set the self-portraits up by framing them and setting the camera on a tripod.

"It wasn't that the monkey stole the camera, went behind the bush and photographed it all by itself. It required a large input from myself," he said.

But Wikimedia Foundation, the group behind the free information-sharing site, argued that Slater didn't own the copyright to the photos because he didn't take the images.

It said no one owned the copyright to the images, because under U.S. law, "copyright cannot vest in non-human authors"—the in this case.

"We take these requests very seriously, and we thoroughly researched both sides of the claim," the group said in a statement. "When a work's copyright cannot vest in a human, it falls into the public domain. We believe that to be the case here."

Wikimedia's spokeswoman Katherine Maher said Slater requested the photos' removal in January, but the case captured public attention after the group included it in its first transparency report, published Wednesday.

The images are currently free for use and downloading at Wikimedia Commons, the group's database of and video clips. Slater said laws should be updated to address cases like his.

Explore further: Wikipedia says EU court ruling is Web 'censorship'

4.2 /5 (5 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Brits rescue 88 research monkeys

Jan 30, 2008

Dozens of research monkeys used by a Chilean medical laboratory were sent to England following threats by an animal rights group.

First images of newly discovered primate

Jan 10, 2012

(PhysOrg.com) -- Researchers working in Northern Myanmar have captured the first photographs of the recently discovered Myanmar snub-nosed monkey.

Recommended for you

N. Korea suffers another Internet shutdown

Dec 27, 2014

North Korea suffered an Internet shutdown for at least two hours on Saturday, Chinese state-media and cyber experts said, after Pyongyang blamed Washington for an online blackout earlier this week.

Streaming release of 'Interview' test for industry

Dec 25, 2014

Sony's "The Interview" has been a hacking target, a punchline and a political lightning rod. Now, with its release online at the same time it debuts in theaters, it has a new role: a test for a new kind of ...

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Nik_2213
not rated yet Aug 07, 2014
So who owns the images from a 'trail cam' that trips for animal movement ?? Or our motion-sensitive CCTV guarding the door ?? Or the neighbours' dog, now sometimes fitted with a 'collar dvr' ??
Captain Stumpy
not rated yet Aug 07, 2014
So who owns the images from a 'trail cam' that trips for animal movement ?? Or our motion-sensitive CCTV guarding the door ?? Or the neighbours' dog, now sometimes fitted with a 'collar dvr' ??
@Nik_2213
from what I remember and have read thus far... the owner of the media is the owner of the picture/image/video/etc, however, there are laws regarding the use of the picture/image/video/etc and the likeness therein, be it personal (like your neighbor) or under copy-write/trademark.

you can take all the pics you want, but using another persons image or likeness is protected under law (in the US and within limits internationally IIRC)

del2
not rated yet Aug 07, 2014
If the Wikimedia Foundation's claim is upheld, it will affect the copyright of all wildlife photos triggered by animals via tripwires, infra-red beams and so on. A lot of wildlife photographers will be very upset.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.