Study traces evolutionary origins of migration in New World birds

Aug 04, 2014
The Baltimore Oriole is one of many songbirds featured in The Field Museum's latest study. Credit: Arlene Koziol (c)2014 The Field Museum

Every year, millions of birds make the journey from North America to Central and South America for the winter. But the evolutionary origins of this long-distance migration have remained opaque due to the complex geographic distributions of modern and ancient bird ranges.

Now, a team of scientists from the University of Chicago have developed a new method to reveal the ancestral ranges of New World birds, and discovered that in the Americas evolved in that resided in North America. Their work also offers evidence that many tropical bird species descended from migratory ancestors that lost migration. The study was published Aug 4 in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Seasonal migration – which occurs when species breed in one geographical area and winter in another – is commonly hypothesized to have evolved as ancestral species native to the tropics began to shift their breeding ranges northward. However, this has been difficult to prove as hundreds of species with large and dynamic geographic ranges have to be studied.

To better understand the of this phenomenon, Benjamin Winger, a graduate student of the Committee on Evolutionary Biology at the University of Chicago, and his colleagues Keith Barker, PhD, a University of Chicago alumnus now at the University of Minnesota in St. Paul, and Richard Ree, PhD, of the Field Museum of Natural History in Chicago, developed a new model to infer the historical geographic distributions of migratory birds.

Using emberizoid passerines – the largest lineage of New World migratory birds, which includes warblers, sparrows, orioles, blackbirds and cardinals – Winger and his colleagues described over 750 passerine species' breeding and wintering patterns by geographical location. They mapped these ranges to a phylogenetic tree – a diagram which shows the evolutionary relationships of each passerine species and their common ancestors – to reconstruct where ancestral passerines lived. The team then computationally inferred the trends in range evolution among ancestral and descendant birds.

Contrary to common hypotheses, they found that the most likely origin of migration in this group lay in ancestral species that resided in North America and gradually moved further and further south for the winter. Shifts in range from North America to tropical areas were the dominant pathway for geographical change, and evolved much more frequently than shifts northward from tropical areas. They also found evidence that ancestral migratory bird species colonized the tropics, eventually losing migration and diversifying into the species that today stay in the tropics year-round.

"We find that a North American species is ancestral to migratory birds in the New World," said Winger, who is the corresponding author on the study. "It's been assumed that because species density is so high in the tropics, that must come out of the tropics. But our study suggests the opposite happened more frequently in this group. The evolution of is a complex system. Our study highlights the importance of using phylogenies to study this phenomenon."

Explore further: Study provides insights into birds' migration routes

More information: Temperate origins of long-distance seasonal migration in New World songbirds, PNAS,

Related Stories

Environmental conditions may impact bird migration

May 14, 2014

Wind conditions during spring migration may be a predictor of apparent annual survival and the timing of breeding in yellow warblers, according to results published May 14, 2014, in the open access journal PLOS ONE by Ann ...

Study provides insights into birds' migration routes

Jul 21, 2014

By tracking hybrids between songbird species, investigators have found that migration routes are under genetic control and could be preventing interbreeding. The research, which is published in Ecology Le ...

Ancient birds from North America colonized the South

Jul 13, 2010

Scientists studying ancient species migration believe northern birds had the ability to colonise continents that southern species lacked. The research, published in Ecography, reveals how the ancient 'land ...

Tiny plants ride on the coattails of migratory birds

Jun 12, 2014

Since the days of Darwin, biologists have questioned why certain plants occur in widely separated places, the farthest reaches of North American and the Southern tip of South America but nowhere in between. ...

Recommended for you

Researchers discover new mechanism of DNA repair

Jul 03, 2015

The DNA molecule is chemically unstable giving rise to DNA lesions of different nature. That is why DNA damage detection, signaling and repair, collectively known as the DNA damage response, are needed.

The math of shark skin

Jul 03, 2015

"Sharks are almost perfectly evolved animals. We can learn a lot from studying them," says Emory mathematician Alessandro Veneziani.

Cuban, US scientists bond over big sharks

Jul 03, 2015

Somewhere in the North Atlantic right now, a longfin mako shark—a cousin of the storied great white—is cruising around, oblivious to the yellow satellite tag on its dorsal fin.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Aug 06, 2014
Common sense... if you are in the tropics... migrate??

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.