'Doing nothing' to maintain the dunes on Ameland does not affect coastal safety

Jul 28, 2014
‘Doing nothing’ to maintain the dunes on Ameland does not affect coastal safety

'Dynamic coastal management' has been used to maintain the dunes in several areas on Ameland since 1990. In other words, nature has been allowed to take its course and few interventions have been made. Research carried out by Alterra, Wageningen University and the Nature Center Ameland has shown that this strategy does not compromise safety.

Very little known about types of dune management

Nearly half the population of Europe lives within 50 kilometres of the coastline. Coasts are often the nub of vital economic activity. The total length of our coastlines is almost 90,000 kilometres. Securing the land behind them can be an enormous job, particularly in view of rising sea levels. Much of the coast is protected by dunes, which provide a natural line of defence. However, very little is known about their natural development under different types of management, despite their immense importance to a country like the Netherlands. The Dutch dunes not only protect the coast, they are also an important part of various ecosystem services, such as drinking water supplies, recreation and conservation.

Customary approach and dynamic dune management

Alterra, Wageningen University and Nature Center Ameland carried out research into two types of dune management: 'soft engineering' and 'dynamic '. Their results were recently published in the Journal of Coastal Research. Soft engineering refers to the customary type of coastal management, whereby sand is replaced on the seaward side of the dunes in order to strengthen or maintain them. Sand fences are then erected and marram grass planted. Since 1990, dynamic coastal management has become increasingly popular in the Netherlands. This approach involves allowing natural processes to take place undisturbed, as long as safety is not compromised. These processes are sometimes actively stimulated in a strategy known as 'building with nature'.

Research on Ameland

The study was carried out in East-Ameland, where Alterra has already spent many years researching the impact of soil subsidence caused by gas extraction by the NAM. "We studied the effects of dynamic coastal management introduced in two areas in 1995 and in 1999," says Alterra researcher Pieter Slim. "We looked at the way the beach and the dunes developed before and after the introduction of dynamic coastal management. Using data from 1980 to 2010, we analysed all the relevant information, including the development of the position of the toe, the top and the slope of the dune, the sand volume, the shape and width of the beach, the water level, wave height and the like."

Just as safe to 'do nothing'

The study showed that the introduction of dynamic coastal management, with a minimum of dune maintenance, had no negative effects on the way the dunes developed. Dune growth rates were the same, while the toe of the evolved more naturally. Heavy storms sometimes had a negative impact on vegetation development in the foredunes, but subsequent recovery was the same whether dynamic coastal management or the customary approach was used. The coastal strips of dunes grew autonomously. Dynamic coastal management does not therefore reduce coastal safety.

Explore further: Should we all escape to the country during a heatwave?

More information: Bart De Jong, Joep G.S. Keijsers, Michel J.P.M. Riksen, Johan Krol, and Pieter A. Slim (2014) "Soft Engineering vs. a Dynamic Approach in Coastal Dune Management: A Case Study on the North Sea Barrier Island of Ameland, The Netherlands." Journal of Coastal Research: Volume 30, Issue 4: pp. 670 – 684. www.jcronline.org/doi/full/10.2112/JCOASTRES-D-13-00125.1

Related Stories

Climate change to put dunes on the move

Jun 20, 2014

(Phys.org) —The instability of coastal sand dunes – already an issue for Adelaide's suburban beaches – is likely to worsen as sea levels rise with global warming, according to Flinders University Professor ...

Image: Martian sand dunes in spring

Mar 07, 2014

(Phys.org) —Mars' northern-most sand dunes are beginning to emerge from their winter cover of seasonal carbon dioxide (dry) ice. Dark, bare south-facing slopes are soaking up the warmth of the sun.

Image: Great Sandy Desert, Australia

Apr 09, 2013

(Phys.org) —In northwest Australia, the Great Sandy Desert holds great geological interest as a zone of active sand dune movement. While a variety of dune forms appear across the region, this astronaut ...

Recommended for you

Gimmicks and technology: California learns to save water

5 hours ago

Billboards and TV commercials, living room visits, guess-your-water-use booths, and awards for water stinginess—a wealthy swath of Orange County that once had one of the worst records for water conservation ...

Cities, regions call for 'robust' world climate pact

5 hours ago

Thousands of cities, provinces and states from around the world urged national governments on Thursday to deliver a "robust, binding, equitable and universal" planet-saving climate pact in December.

Will climate change put mussels off the menu?

5 hours ago

Climate change models predict that sea temperatures will rise significantly, including in the tropics. In these areas, rainfall is also predicted to increase, reducing the salt concentration of the surface ...

As nations dither, cities pick up climate slack

17 hours ago

Their national governments hamstrung by domestic politics, stretched budgets and diplomatic inertia, many cities and provinces have taken a leading role—driven by necessity—in efforts to arrest galloping ...

User comments : 2

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (3) Jul 28, 2014
Humans effect the climate which affects the coasts. And here we see the effective thing is to do nothing, rather than take action to protect the earth. We might also first assume that doing nothing about global warming, is also the right approach, until proven otherwise.
5 / 5 (1) Jul 28, 2014
{Cough} To a first approximation, in the short term, *some* coastal areas are self-healing. This seems to be one of them. Although there is storm erosion, subsequent deposition replaces those losses, provides the material to rebuild the dunes.

Few areas are so fortunate. An apparently trivial shift of off-shore currents may build or strip a sand-bank or spit that protects the shore. With such gone, even temporarily, the next storm's waves may 'blow' a gap through the dunes, flooding the low land behind, destroying the fresh-water lens that supplies the fragile ecosystem, comprimising 'natural' recovery...

Don't forget that, further up the Dutch coast, they have built vast storm barriers to protect vulnerable coasts and estuaries from rising sea levels. Such mega-engineering works surely falsify your hypothesis.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.