Bose sues Beats over headphone patents

Jul 25, 2014

Audio technology veteran Bose Corporation on Friday sued Beats Electronics over patented technology for canceling noise in earphones.

The suit filed in federal court in the US state of Delaware pits the 50-year-old firm against an Internet Age youngster being bought by Apple in a deal valued at $3 billion.

"Bose brings this action against Beats to protect its valuable patented technology for noise-canceling headphones," lawyers for the company said in a copy of the suit obtained by AFP.

Attorneys said they had also filed a complaint with the US International Trade Commission, which has the power to block imports of headsets found to infringe on patented technology.

Bose accused Beats of infringing on five of its patents for cutting out unwanted noise in headphones, particularly by cancelling it out with other sound waves.

The technology is referred to as active noise reduction.

"Beats has designed the infringing noise canceling functionality to be used automatically when a user is listening to music, and Beats instructs users on how to implement noise canceling functionality when a user only desires noise reduction," the lawsuit maintained.

Bose called on the court to order Beats to stop using the patented technology and to pay unspecified damages.

The suit comes at a time when Beats is being bought by a technology titan well experience in patent litigation.

Apple has been waging battles in courts around the world with Samsung over patented technology in iPhones and iPads.

Apple in May said it is buying Beats Music and Beats Electronics in a much-hyped deal worth $3 billion. The acquisition has yet to close.

Buying Beats was expected to help Cupertino, California-based Apple, a pioneer in digital music with its wildly popular iTunes platform, ramp up its efforts to counter successful models of streaming services like Pandora, Spotify and others.

The deal for the maker of high-end audio equipment and operator of a subscription streaming music service is Apple's largest acquisition ever.

It calls for Beats co-founders Dr. Dre, a Grammy-winning hip-hop pioneer, and Jimmy Iovine, a veteran music executive, to join the California company.

Since launching five years ago, Beats has become a popular brand for audio equipment and has attracted the likes of Lady Gaga, Lil Wayne and Nicki Minaj, who have designed their own customized Beats headphones and speakers.

Fashion designers and street artists such as Alexander Wang, Futura and Snarkitecture have collaborated on some products.

The deal, which has been rumored for weeks, is subject to regulatory approvals and is expected to be completed later this year.

Beats was reported to have claimed 60 percent of the billion dollars spent on top-end earphones in the US last year.

Explore further: Google made failed bid for Spotify

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Google made failed bid for Spotify

Jul 23, 2014

Internet titan Google tried last year to buy streaming music service Spotify but backed off for reasons including a whopping price tag, the Wall Street Journal reported on Tuesday.

Beats buy could broaden Apple's reach

May 09, 2014

An Apple buy-out of hip headphone maker Beats Electronics could expand the iPhone maker's lucrative domain and play into plans for its next big thing, analysts said Friday.

Report: Apple on verge of buying Beats for $3.2B

May 09, 2014

Apple is orchestrating a $3.2 billion acquisition of Beats Electronics, the headphone maker and music streaming distributor founded by hip-hop star Dr. Dre and music industry impresario Jimmy Iovine, according ...

Google buys Songza streaming music service

Jul 01, 2014

Google on Tuesday said that it has bought Songza, a free online streaming music service that recommends tunes based on what people might be in the mood to hear.

Apple dances to new tune with Beats deal

May 30, 2014

If Wall Street struggles to see the logic in Apple's $3 billion deal for Beats Music, it may look across the river to Brooklyn, hometown of Beats co-founder Jimmy Iovine.

Recommended for you

Japan's NTT to buy German data centre operator

16 hours ago

Japanese telecom giant NTT Communications is looking to acquire German data centre operator e-shelter, as it seeks to cash in on growing demand in Europe, a newspaper reported Saturday.

Google hits back at rivals with futuristic HQ plan

Feb 27, 2015

Google unveiled plans Friday for a new campus headquarters integrating wildlife and sweeping waterways, aiming to make a big statement in Silicon Valley—which is already seeing ambitious projects from Apple ...

Ericsson sues Apple over patent violations

Feb 27, 2015

Swedish telecoms group Ericsson announced Friday a lawsuit against Apple claiming that the US tech giant continued to use its technology in iPhones and other wireless devices after refusing to renew a licencing ...

Stock market shrugs off net neutrality vote

Feb 27, 2015

(AP)—The stock market largely shrugged off the Federal Communications Commission's vote to impose tougher rules on broadband providers like Comcast, Verizon and AT&T to prevent them from creating paid fast lanes for the ...

User comments : 2

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

supamark23
1 / 5 (1) Jul 25, 2014
Lol, one maker of crappy audio equipment suing another...
gopher65
not rated yet Jul 26, 2014
It doesn't get any worse than Beats equipment. Might as well shop at the dollar store:P.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.