Sublime design of the PB/5 pedestrian button

Jun 30, 2014 by Miles Park, The Conversation
Irrespective of your button pressing technique, unfortunately the wait will always be the same. Credit: Dave Young

We are more likely to thump this instantly recognisable design, on a daily basis, than to give it much thought. The PB/5 pedestrian button, a type of "Audio-Tactile Pedestrian Detector" (ATPD), is a successful Australian design that has been populating towns and cities across Australia since 1984 and exported to countries including Ireland, the US, New Zealand and Singapore.

The button, commissioned by the then NSW Department of Main Roads, addressed pedestrians' safety at traffic light crossings and, most notably, the growing concerns for the safety of vision and hearing-impaired pedestrians.

Successfully commercialised manufactured products are always the result of many people's efforts. The team behind the PB/5 pedestrian button was led by industrial designer David Wood from Nielsen Design Associates, acoustical engineer Louis Challis, and roads and traffic authority (RTA) engineer Frank Hulscher.

Audio design

The PB/5 pedestrian button embodies an audio-tactile device combining a two-rhythm buzzer, a vibrating touch panel, and braille direction arrow. Earlier attempts at an audio signalling pedestrian button in the 1960s incorporated a bell and buzzer audio signalling feature. In addition to the green "walk" signal, visually-impaired pedestrians were meant to cross when the sound of a ringing bell changed to a buzzer.

Unfortunately these earlier audio pedestrian buttons caused confusion due to their inconsistent installation from location to location and the sound transition was far from intuitive as a signal to "walk". Furthermore, when the bell mechanism malfunctioned it could be mistaken as sounding like a buzzer and cause deadly confusion.

An inconspicuous design classic, the PB/5 pedestrian button. Credit: Rory Murdock

In 1976, in response to these concerns, acoustic consultants Louis A. Challis and Associates were tasked to redesign the audio signalling. They devised the now familiar two-rhythm buzzer and added a vibrating touch panel. The slower rhythm transitioning to a faster rhythm indicates a positive walk (cross) signal. A locating tone, that can adjust automatically to compensate for ambient road noise, assists users to find the push button and unmistakably indicate a "don't walk" phase.

Industrial design

The design that we are familiar with today unifies the audio-tactile signalling features with a distinctive and robust form expressed as a diecast aluminium housing and polished stainless steel button. A braille and printed arrow on the vibrating plate indicates the direction for crossing.

The product form was derived from the shape of traffic lights. The epoxy power-coated aluminium castings and tamper proof fasteners ensure that the design is weather and vandal proof. Carl Nielsen (of Nielsen Design Associates) later referred to this need when designing products for public environments as "pre-vandalising" - leaving nothing to fail when installed.

The distinctive push button was designed to withstand millions of pushes. This was achieved by mechanically isolating the movement of the button from the electrical switching mechanism. The button floats on a sliding shaft. Magnets offer the button an initial resistance when pressed before sliding in on its shaft. A change in magnetism of this action triggers an electronic reed switch initiating the request to "walk".

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.

So it matters little if you lightly press it once or give it quick succession of light jabs. The designers were well aware of human behaviour, our impatience and tendency to overestimate the time we actually wait for the lights to change. So, irrespective of your specially developed button pressing technique, unfortunately the wait will be the same.

A design classic?

Given its success in improving at crossings and its longevity as a widely used design, it certainly demonstrates the qualities of a good design. The PB/5 pedestrian button is unlikely to be on many people's "top ten" lists as a "design classic", but it does possess a number of classic design attributes, including: form, function, safety, sustainability, quality, commerciality and innovation.

I would like to add an extra attribute: inconspicuous. A product design should do its job quietly and efficiently without drawing undue attention to itself. So my inconspicuous design classic is the PB/5 pedestrian button … even if using it won't change the lights fast enough.

Explore further: At stoplights, pedestrians experience longer delays while cars are given priority

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

London launches hi-tech trial for pedestrian safety

Mar 11, 2014

(Phys.org) —London is trying out intelligent pedestrian technology to make crossing the road easier and safer. Announced earlier this month, the technology is said to be the first scheme of its kind in ...

Victoria leads charge for child-safe batteries

Jun 12, 2014

Design lecturer Jeongbin Ok has hit upon a solution to minimise the damage of swallowing coin-sized, button cell lithium batteries, commonly found in electronic devices such as toys and remote controls, which ...

Walk, but stay safe: tips for pedestrians

Jan 20, 2014

(HealthDay)—Walking is a great way to get exercise, but it's important to follow certain safety rules to protect yourself from cars and other hazards, experts say.

Jaywalking not worth the risk, expert says

Dec 16, 2013

The hectic holidays may have many looking to save a few extra minutes wherever they can be found, but a University of Alabama at Birmingham expert says one seemingly small action—jaywalking—should be ...

Recommended for you

Napster co-founder to invest in allergy research

10 hours ago

(AP)—Napster co-founder Sean Parker missed most of his final year in high school and has ended up in the emergency room countless times because of his deadly allergy to nuts, shellfish and other foods.

LA mayor plans 7,000 police body cameras in 2015

21 hours ago

Mayor Eric Garcetti announced a plan Tuesday to equip 7,000 Los Angeles police officers with on-body cameras by next summer, making LA's police department the nation's largest law enforcement agency to move ...

Merriam-Webster names 'culture' word of the year

Dec 15, 2014

A nation, a workplace, an ethnicity, a passion, an outsized personality. The people who comprise these things, who fawn or rail against them, are behind Merriam-Webster's 2014 word of the year: culture.

In Curiosity Hacked, children learn to make, not buy

Dec 14, 2014

With her right hand, my 8-year-old daughter, Kalian, presses the red-hot soldering iron against the circuit board. With her left hand, she guides a thin, tin wire until it's pressing against both the circuit board and the ...

Top pilot sees risk in unregulated US drones

Dec 10, 2014

Small drones pose a danger in US skies so long as clear rules governing their operation are not in place, the head of the world's biggest pilots' union said Wednesday.

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.