Sports teams may lose out from having 'too much talent'

Jun 11, 2014
Credit: Gustavo Rezende/public domain

As the FIFA World Cup kicks off and the NBA finals "heat" up, new research suggests that there is such a thing as having too much talent on a sports team. The research indicates that, after a certain point, the addition of more superstar talent to a team can actually be detrimental, resulting in poorer team performance.

The findings are forthcoming in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science.

The research, led by INSEAD Professor Roderick Swaab, showed that the presence of too many individuals with top talent can undermine players' willingness to coordinate, which can compromise effective teamwork and overall team performance. The findings also reveal, however, that most people assume the opposite, believing that piling on more top talent is the key to team success.

"Most people believe that the relationship between talent and team performance is linear – the more their team is packed with talent, the better they will do," explains Swaab. "Yet our latest research documenting a 'too-much-talent effect', reveals that for teams requiring high levels of interdependence, like football and basketball, talent facilitates team performance… but only up to a point. Beyond this point, the benefits of adding more top talent will decrease and eventually hurt the team performance because they fail to coordinate their actions."

The research indicates that the too-much-talent effect only emerges in sports that require a high level of interdependence between players. For more individualistic sports, such as baseball, very high levels of talent do not seem to hurt performance.

So, while Miami Heat fans may currently be rejoicing in their "big three"—LeBron James, Dwyane Wade and Chris Bosh—the team of researchers cautions Miami fans not to forget the Heat's NBA title loss to the Dallas Mavericks in 2011, a team built around one star player—Dirk Nowitzki—and a number of lesser-known sportsmen. While the Mavericks were successfully complementing each other's strengths, Miami's newly acquired superstars were jostling for the spotlight, and paid the price.

"As the FIFA World Cup 2014 draws near, we expect to see plenty of team-sheets boasting impressive lineups with top talented players," says Swaab. "However, coaches that simply select their side with superstars may, contrary to popular belief, be the ones taking an early exit from Brazil!"

While team managers from the World Cup, NBA, and MLB may do well to bear these findings in mind, lessons can also be taken to the boardroom.

"Like sports teams, teams in organizations vary in their levels of interdependence. When team success merely depends on the accumulation of individual performance (e.g. sales teams), hiring and staffing could simply focus on getting the most talented individuals on board," Swaab explains. "However, these same strategies can hurt a willingness to coordinate effectively when team success depends on high levels of interdependence (e.g. strategy teams). When interdependence between team members is high, organizations could either hire a better mix of top talent and non-top talent and/or invest more in training to formalize roles, ranks, and responsibilities."

"These are important lessons," says Swaab, "because selection decisions in organizations tend to produce a too-much-talent effect because of misguided perceptions around the link between top talent and performance."

The research was conducted using data from the FIFA World Cup 2010 and 2014 qualifying periods and the 2002-2012 National Basketball Association (NBA) and Major League Baseball (MLB) seasons. The research identified individual talent using individual elite club affiliations in football, Estimated Wins Added (EWA) in basketball, and Wins Above Replacement (WAR) in baseball. This, along with an unparalleled amount of information, including on-court intrateam coordination data, allowed measurement of team performance in relation to the amount of talent on the books.

Explore further: Basketball study says cooperative play lessens during playoffs

More information: The data for Studies 1a and 1b have been made publicly available via Open Science Framework and can be accessed at osf.io/bw48s. The materials for Studies 1a and 1b have also been made publicly available via Open Science Framework and can be accessed at osf.io/y4c82.

The complete Open Practices Disclosure for this article can be found at pss.sagepub.com/content/by/supplemental-data .

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

In life and baseball, people love 'The Naturals'

Oct 04, 2013

(Medical Xpress)—As baseball playoffs begin this week, Yale psychologists have a prediction: Your favorite player is likely to be a natural talent rather than someone who worked hard for success. And it ...

Recommended for you

Study identifies why re-educating torturers may not work

Nov 21, 2014

Many human rights educators assume – incorrectly, as it turns out – that police and military officers in India who support the torture of suspects do so because they are either immoral or ignorant. This ...

Research helps raise awareness of human trafficking

Nov 21, 2014

Human trafficking –– or the control, ownership and sale of another human being for monetary gain –– was a common occurrence centuries ago, but many believe it doesn't exist in this day and age and not in this country.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Nik_2213
not rated yet Jun 11, 2014
This is one reason that UK soccer's annual knock-out competitions are so unpredictable-- Any minor, but co-ordinated team may just out-wit the opposing squad of ego-heavy Mega-Stars.

FWIW, this year's jungle-jaunt in Brazil may take 'Team England' further than their usual 'group stage' elimination. When you look at the squad, they're drawn from the usual top UK clubs. But, this time, a surprising number have come in groups, long accustomed to playing together at club level...

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.