Foul fumes derail dinner for hungry moths

Jun 26, 2014
A pollinating moth Manduca sexta, this one with a wing span of about 4 inches, feeds from a Sacred Dutura, or Datura wrightii, flower. Credit: Kiley Riffell

Car and truck exhaust fumes that foul the air for humans also cause problems for pollinators.

In new research on how pollinators find flowers when background odors are strong, University of Washington and University of Arizona researchers have found that both natural plant odors and human sources of pollution can conceal the scent of sought-after flowers.

When the calories from one feeding of a flower gets you only 15 minutes of flight, as is the case with the tobacco hornworn moth studied, being misled costs a pollinator energy and time. "Local vegetation can mask the scent of flowers because the background scents activate the same moth olfactory channels as floral scents," according to Jeffrey Riffell, UW assistant professor of biology. "Plus the chemicals in these scents are similar to those emitted from exhaust engines and we found that pollutant concentrations equivalent to urban environments can decrease the ability of pollinators to find flowers."

Riffell is lead author of a paper on the subject in the June 27 issue of Science.

"Nature can be complex, but an urban environment is a whole other layer on top of that," said Riffell. "These are not important pollinators in urban environments, but these same volatiles from vehicles may affect pollinators like honeybees or bumblebees, which are more prevalent in many urban areas."

The scientists used a chemical detection device called a proton-transfer reaction mass spectrometer to, for the first time, track the odors emitted by flowers in the wild just as moths might encounter them. With wing spans of 4 inches, adult Manduca sexta moths can travel up to 80 miles in an evening looking for food and mates.

The moths are about equivalent to dogs in their ability to detect scents and both are several thousand times more skillful than humans. In the Southwest United States, where the field work was conducted, the moth navigates to and pollinates the white trumpet-like blossoms of Sacred Datura, or Datura wrightii.

The moths can detect and home in on flowers hundreds of yards away if there aren't too many competing scents. In the Southwest, moths in search of Sacred Datura can be hindered because the flowers often grow in dense stands of creosote bush, or Larrea tridentatae. Despite having "creosote" as part of its name – creosote being a component of tar – the plant actually smells of almonds and cherry soda and emits some of the same aromatic volatiles as Sacred Datura.

Even while sampling in the desert environment the scientists found the odors the moths were seeking could be "swamped out" by the natural vegetation, Riffell said.

Back in the lab, using a wind tunnel and computer-controlled odor-stimulus system, the moths in free flight were tested to see just how finely they could discern different frequencies of Sacred Datura odor as well as mixes of background odors from creosote bushes. The neuron pathways activated in the moths were tracked by inserting a 16-channel electrode into the moth's antennal lobe, where the moth processes odor information from its antennae.

To analyze the neural recordings the researchers developed an odor-recognition data classifier and computational model that allowed them to compare the recognition scores between the natural flower scents and those embedded with various backgrounds.

The computational analysis showed remarkable similar results to those in the wind tunnel: backgrounds scents significantly modified the representation of the flower odor, and altered the neural perception of the flower.

The scientists were surprised that scents that were only loosely similar to ones attractive to moths, such as those from auto and truck exhaust, also misled them.

"We'd assumed that the moth's ability to smell the flowers would be more specific. Instead, other volatiles also activated those same olfactory pathways," Riffell said. Co-authors on the paper from UW biology are Elischa Sanders, Billie Medina and Armin Hinterwirth; from UW applied mathematics, Eli Shlizerman and Nathan Kutz; and from the University of Arizona, Leif Abrell.

"Beyond our work with moths, we'd also like to see if these volatiles affect other pollinators, like honeybees," Riffell said. "Such work could provide insight into whether urban emissions affect in farms neighboring urban centers."

Explore further: Like a moth to a street light

More information: "Flower discrimination by pollinators in a dynamic chemical environment," by J.A. Riffell et al. www.sciencemag.org/lookup/doi/… 1126/science.1251041

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Moths wired two ways to take advantage of floral potluck

Dec 06, 2012

Moths are able to enjoy a pollinator's buffet of flowers – in spite of being among the insect world's picky eaters – because of two distinct "channels" in their brains, scientists at the University of ...

Like a moth to a street light

Feb 05, 2014

A new research project will investigate how street lighting impacts on the many hundreds of species of moths that can be found in Britain. 

Plants mimic scent of pollinating beetles

Apr 03, 2012

The color and scent of flowers and their perception by pollinator insects are believed to have evolved in the course of mutual adaptation. However, an evolutionary biologist from the University of Zurich has ...

Recommended for you

Rising temperatures can be hard on dogs

21 hours ago

The "dog days of summer" are here, but don't let the phrase fool you. This hot time of year can be dangerous for your pup, says a Kansas State University veterinarian.

Monkeys fear big cats less, eat more, with humans around

Jul 25, 2014

Some Monkeys in South Africa have been found to regard field scientists as human shields against predators and why not if the alternative is death by leopard? The researchers found the monkeys felt far safer ...

User comments : 0