Counting species an inaccurate science

May 29, 2014
Credit: Martin Westgate

Species could be going extinct right under the noses of scientists without them realising, researchers have found.

Dr Martin Westgate from the Fenner School and Environment and Society led the group that concluded that methods for measuring the full gamut of animal in a particular location are flawed. This means that efforts to protect may not be as effective as they could be.

"Our study shows methods for measuring are built on assumptions that do not hold in all circumstances, and this might lead to poor environmental decisions," said Dr Westgate, lead author of the paper published in Nature Communications.

"For example, poor measurement might cause us to think that biodiversity is stable or increasing, when in fact some species are in decline."

To date around 1.5 million species have been described on Earth, but many more remain undocumented. Estimates of the total number of species on our planet vary widely, but have been as high as 100 million species, any of which could hold the key to a new cancer cure or painkiller. Without knowing where these species can be found, preventing them from going extinct can be difficult, or even impossible.

In the absence of complete data about species' distributions, policymakers are forced to estimate areas of high biodiversity through a range of techniques. One method is by counting a well-known group, such as birds, and assuming they represent the diversity of other groups.

The group compared many of these different estimation methods, by whittling over 8,000 biodiversity papers down to 81 papers that could be directly compared.

The comparisons found a serious lack of consistency between the different assessments of biodiversity. In particular, they found that studies at different latitudes or spatial scales rarely find similar results, even when they consider the same groups of plants or animals.

"New methods are needed for understanding biodiversity," Dr Westgate said.

Co-author Dr Philip Barton said is a global problem with huge implications for human well-being.

"But so much science is being produced around the world that it can be difficult to see the big picture," Dr Barton said.

"Measuring biodiversity and understanding how it is distributed across the globe is a complex science, and our study shows us where more work needs to be done.

"Our results were very surprising, but they open up huge possibilities for future research."

Explore further: Research challenges understanding of biodiversity crisis

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Mapping out how to save species

Jun 27, 2013

In stunning color, new biodiversity research from North Carolina State University maps out priority areas worldwide that hold the key to protecting vulnerable species and focusing conservation efforts.

Extinctions reduces speciation

Apr 04, 2014

The same factors that increase the risk of species extinctions also reduce the chance that new species are formed. This is concluded by two biologists at Umeå University. Their findings are published in ...

Recommended for you

Study indicates large raptors in Africa used for bushmeat

2 hours ago

Bushmeat, the use of native animal species for food or commercial food sale, has been heavily documented to be a significant factor in the decline of many species of primates and other mammals. However, a new study indicates ...

Noise pollution impacts fish species differently

5 hours ago

Acoustic disturbance has different effects on different species of fish, according to a new study from the Universities of Bristol and Exeter which tested fish anti-predator behaviour.

Invertebrate numbers nearly halve as human population doubles

5 hours ago

Invertebrate numbers have decreased by 45% on average over a 35 year period in which the human population doubled, reports a study on the impact of humans on declining animal numbers. This decline matters because of the enormous ...

Insecticides similar to nicotine widespread in Midwest

6 hours ago

Insecticides similar to nicotine, known as neonicotinoids, were found commonly in streams throughout the Midwest, according to a new USGS study. This is the first broad-scale investigation of neonicotinoid ...

User comments : 0