Researchers find young galaxies not behaving as expected

April 30, 2014 by Nikki Cassis
Researchers find young galaxies not behaving as expected
The young galaxy SDSS090122.37+181432.3. It is distorted because of gravitational lensing. Credit: NASA/STScI; S. Allam and team; and the Master Lens Database (, L. A. Moustakas, K. Stewart, et al (2014).

( —New Herschel Space Observatory findings have given scientists a remarkable insight into the internal dynamics of two young galaxies. Surprisingly, they have shown that just a few billion years after the big bang, some galaxies were rotating in a mature way, seemingly having completed the accumulation of their gas reservoirs.

When form, they accumulate mass by gravitationally attracting vast, external gas clouds. As the gas clouds are consumed by the galaxy, they fall into haphazard orbits. These disordered paths cause in the , which can drive star formation.

To investigate the internal conditions of forming galaxies, James Rhoads and Sangeeta Malhotra, both from Arizona State University, and colleagues targeted two young galaxies, known as SDSS0901 and the Clone. The light from both galaxies has taken 10 billion years to reach us across space. Thus, we are seeing them when they were comparatively young.

Rhoads studies galaxy formation, galaxy evolution and the reionization of intergalactic hydrogen by early galaxies. Malhotra's research ranges from properties of dust and gas in the (relatively nearby) interstellar medium to some of the farthest known galaxies. In recent years they have also collaborated on finding and characterizing galaxies in the cosmic dawn, when the universe was less than a billion years old.

The current project focuses on a somewhat later time, the high noon of star formation in the universe – a time when the universe was about 3 billion years old, and when star birth in galaxies was much more active than it is today.

"The purpose of this project is to study the physical conditions of gas in those galaxies. We wanted to know: 'Are they similar to the galaxies around us, or is there some difference in their physical conditions?'" says Rhoads.

The two galaxies they choose to study are average galaxies for that time in cosmic history. This means that they are about 10 to 20 percent the size of our Milky Way, which is considered an average galaxy in the present-day universe.

Studying galaxies so far away is usually challenging because they appear too dim to study effectively, but in this case, the researchers were helped by a cosmic mirage known as a gravitational lens. The two galaxies both sit behind intervening groups of galaxies, whose gravity warps space. As described by Albert Einstein's General Theory of Relativity, this warping acts like a lens. Although it distorts the images of the young galaxies, it helps by magnifying their light, thus bringing them within reach of Herschel's HIFI instrument.

The researchers used HIFI to investigate the infrared light of ionized carbon, which is emitted at a wavelength of 158 micrometers. This spectral line is produced in the clouds that surround star-forming regions. HIFI showed the line was broadened into a double peak, and this allowed the motion of the gas to be fitted with a model.

"The two peaks represent two sides of a rotating galaxy. One side is rotating away from us and the other is coming toward us. The broadening of the peaks gives us an indication of the randomness of the motion on top of rotation," explains Malhotra.

First, the team fitted the overall rotation of the galaxy, and then the turbulence in the . To their surprise, they found that galaxy S0901 was extremely well behaved. Instead of turbulence, it was found to be in orderly rotation, much more akin to the majestic galaxies of today.

"Usually, when astronomers examine galaxies at this early era, they find that turbulence plays a much greater role than it does in modern galaxies. But S0901 is a clear exception to that pattern, and the Clone could be another," says Rhoads.

The Clone, the second galaxy in their study, could also be fitted by an orderly rotation. However, because it was somewhat dimmer, the quality of the data was not so good. This meant that the data could also be fitted with a highly turbulent model, as conventional wisdom would expect.

"Galaxies 10 billion years ago were making stars more actively than they do now," says Malhotra. "They usually also show more turbulence, likely because they are accumulating gas faster than a modern galaxy does. But here, we have cases of early galaxies that combine the 'calm' rotation of a modern one with the active star formation of their early peers. This suggests first that these galaxies have finished accumulating their gas, at least for now. But it also seems that turbulence is not actually required to trigger that early, active ."

Malhotra acknowledges the preliminary nature of their study. "This is not the last word on this. We need a bigger sample to be sure of our conclusions," she says.

But that bigger sample will not be investigated by Herschel. As predicted, the liquid helium coolant needed to keep HIFI and Herschel's other instruments working ran out in April 2013. Instead, the researchers hope to continue the work pioneered by Herschel using the Atacama Large Millimetre Array (ALMA), a ground-based array of 66 radio dishes in Chile.

"It is mind-boggling that with Herschel/HIFI – admittedly with the help of gravitational lensing – it has been possible to study the internal gas kinematics in galaxies when the universe was only a few billion years old, and what we can learn about them this way. This pioneering work by Herschel is bound to be continued," says Göran Pilbratt, Herschel Project scientist at the European Space Agency.

Explore further: Herschel paints new story of galaxy evolution

Related Stories

Herschel paints new story of galaxy evolution

September 13, 2011

( -- ESA's Herschel infrared space observatory has discovered that galaxies do not need to collide with each other to drive vigorous star birth. The finding overturns this long-held assumption and paints a more ...

Galactic star 'baby boom' ended five billion years ago

January 16, 2014

Luminous galaxies far brighter than our Sun constantly collide to create new stars, but Oxford University research has now shown that star formation across the Universe dropped dramatically in the last five billion years.

Universe's early galaxies grew massive through collisions

January 29, 2014

It has long puzzled scientists that there were enormously massive galaxies that were already old and no longer forming new stars in the very early universe, approx. 3 billion years after the Big Bang. Now new research from ...

Astronomers complete cosmic dust census

March 18, 2014

An international team of astronomers has completed a benchmark study of more than 300 galaxies, producing the largest census of dust in the local Universe, the Herschel Reference Survey. Led by Dr Luca Cortese from Swinburne ...

Red stars and big bulges: How black holes shape galaxies

April 22, 2014

( —The universe we can see is made up of billions of galaxies, each containing anywhere from hundreds of thousands to hundreds of billions of stars. Large numbers of galaxies are elliptical in shape, red and mostly ...

Recommended for you

Astronomers discover three 'Qatar' exoplanets

June 29, 2016

(—An international team of astronomers has discovered three new exoplanets using a Qatar-based planet-searching survey. The newly discovered gas giant exoworlds belong to the so-called "hot Jupiter" family of planets ...

Measuring the shape of the Milky Way's black hole

June 24, 2016

At the heart of our galaxy's center is SagA*, a supermassive black hole containing about four million solar-masses of material. SgrA* is relatively faint, unlike the supermassive black holes in some other galaxies. This is ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (3) Apr 30, 2014
..."But here, we have cases of early galaxies that combine the 'calm' rotation of a modern one with the active star formation of their early peers. This suggests first that these galaxies have finished accumulating their gas, at least for now. But it also seems that turbulence is not actually required to trigger that early, active star formation."...

All based on the assumed validity of the Huge Bang Fantasy. Active galaxies are likely the ones first observed at this vast distance. Since they grow from within by core ejections of newly-formed matter over time, they could be smaller, but look similar to those today. Since periodic core ejection fuels the star formation conditions, early galaxies can be well-developed in a stable, non-turbulent configuration. Merger mania needs another patch! Quick!
1 / 5 (2) Apr 30, 2014
The prediction of steady state Universe model is, the most distant galaxies will appear in the same way, like these nearby ones. It's not smart to accept it just after when all other options will fail. Such an attitude would indicate a cognitive bias in the subject matter.
3 / 5 (1) Apr 30, 2014
Another possibility is that this galaxy formed from a localized 'cloud" of primordial hydrogen, that just happened to be of relatively uniform density at the start. Which could account for its remarkable uniformity.

The assumption that the early universe was uniform omnidirectionally, when no such local-scale unififormity is observed today has always seemed a deeplu flawed one to me.

It seems a much more reasonable assumption to me that there were variations in local and long range densities in the universe from the beginning right up to the present, and that this galaxy is just an example of high/uniform density + local scale that can be expected to occur at some point along the spectrum of initial conditions and evolved over time.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.