More than four percent of death row inmates likely innocent, study finds

Apr 28, 2014
Prison
Cell block in Baghdad Central Prison (Abu Ghraib, Iraq)

About one in 25 inmates sentenced to death in the United States was likely wrongly convicted, a study said Monday.

Estimating the rate of false convictions, which the study put at 4.1 percent, is no easy task since there is no and many are never identified, in part because some sentences are commuted.

Nevertheless, " are far more likely to be detected among those cases that end in than in any other category of ," said the article published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

"Everyone, from the first officer on the scene of a potentially capital crime to the Chief Justice of the United States, takes capital cases more seriously than other criminal prosecutions—and knows that everybody else will do so as well."

The study, the first of its kind, used a statistical method known as survival analysis. The method is usually used to determine the effectiveness of a medical treatment in reducing .

Researchers were thus able to estimate the proportion of death row inmates whose innocence would have been established if they had stayed in prison and thus benefited from resources to defend themselves.

"Even if you are sentenced to death... the chance to be exonerated is much higher if you're still on death row," lead author Samuel Gross told AFP.

However, "the great majority of innocent people who are sentenced to death are never identified and freed."

The researchers used data from the 7,482 people sentenced to death from January 1974 to December 2004.

Among that group, 12.6 percent were executed, 1.6 percent were exonerated, four percent died while on death row, 46.1 percent remained on death row and 35.8 percent were taken off death row but stayed in prison after their capital sentences or convictions were reversed or changed.

Based on the analysis showing a more than four percent error margin in trials, the study said it was "all but certain" that several of the 1,320 people executed since 1977 were in fact innocent.

"Most innocent defendants who have been sentenced to death have not been exonerated, and many—including the great majority of those who have been re-sentenced to life in prison—probably never will be," it added.

"The net result is that the great majority of innocent defendants who are convicted of capital murder in the United States are neither executed nor exonerated. They are sentenced, or re-sentenced to prison for life, and then forgotten."

Explore further: US Supreme Court set for death row IQ appeal

More information: Rate of false conviction of criminal defendants who are sentenced to death, PNAS, 2014. www.pnas.org/content/early/2014/04/23/1306417111

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

US Supreme Court set for death row IQ appeal

Mar 02, 2014

A Florida inmate is challenging the US state's use of a rigid IQ number to determine intellectual disability, in a case that spotlights the issue of the mentally ill on death row.

Are Southern death-row inmates more polite?

Apr 08, 2014

Southern states are known to uphold a culture of honor and adhere to traditional politeness norms, but does this hold true for death-row convicts? A new article published today in SAGE Open finds that Southern death-row offend ...

It's who you kill that matters, according to new research

Mar 05, 2010

A defendant is much more likely to be sentenced to death if he or she kills a "high-status" victim, according to new research by Scott Phillips, associate professor of sociology and criminology at the University of Denver ...

Recommended for you

Poverty rate drops for the first time since 2006

7 hours ago

The poverty rate in the United States has dropped for the first time since 2006, bringing a bit of encouraging news about the nation's economy as President Barack Obama and Congress gear up for the November elections.

User comments : 0