Apple, Samsung trade barbs as new patent trial opens

Apr 02, 2014 by Glenn Chapman
Apple has vowed to prove that Samsung flagrantly copied iPhone features and should pay more than $2 billion in damages, as the two smartphone giants squared off anew in a California courtroom

Lawyers for Apple and Samsung exchanged barbs as a major new patent trial opened, debating the role of a company not even part of the case—Google.

Apple's legal team vowed to prove that Samsung flagrantly copied iPhone features and should pay more than $2 billion in damages, as the two smartphone giants squared off anew in a California courtroom.

Apple attorney Harold McElhinny opened his presentation with a video showing legendary Apple co-founder Steve Jobs introducing the first iPhone in 2007.

By putting computing power in smartphones powered by fun software and easy-to-use touch-screens, Apple transformed the market, sending Samsung onto its heels, according to McElhinny.

The attorney told jurors in his opening statement that they would see internal Samsung documents and messages showing that the company felt it was suffering "a crisis of design" with the difference between its devices and the smartphone "a difference between Heaven and Earth."

Apple said evidence will show that the South Korean electronics giant sold more than 37 million infringing smartphones and tablets in the United States.

California-based Apple would have demanded royalties of about $40 per device to license the patented technology to Samsung, according to McElhinny.

The overall amount being sought by Apple in damages from Samsung will top $2 billion, the lawyer explained.

"This case is not about Google," McElhinny told jurors.

"It is Samsung, not Google, that chose to put these features into its phones."

But Samsung's lawyer told the jurors in the San Jose, California court that the case was indeed about Google, and Apple's struggle against the maker of the Android operating system which is now winning in the global marketplace.

A graphic showing global market share of major smartphone makers

'Attack on Android'

"It's an attack on Android, that is what this case is," attorney John Quinn said.

"Apple is trying to limit consumer choice and gain an unfair advantage over Google's Android."

Quinn contended that four of the five patents at issue in the trial are not used in Apple mobile devices, but because of features built into Android software by Google engineers litigation was pursued.

He promised jurors that Google engineers would be called to testify to how they independently designed Android software and did not copy Apple.

Samsung is the world's leading maker of smartphones and tablets built using Google's free Android mobile operating system.

Lawyers for Apple and Samsung have exchanged barbs as a major new patent trial opens in California, debating the role of a company not even part of the case—Google

Android smartphones dominate the global market, particularly in devices offered for lower prices than iPhones.

"Apple is an amazingly innovative company, but in some respects, Google's Android has passed them," Quinn said.

"Apple is trying to gain from you in this courtroom what it has lost in the marketplace."

In August 2012, a separate jury in the same court decided that Samsung should pay Apple $1.049 billion in damages for illegally copying iPhone and iPad features, in one of the biggest patent cases in decades.

The damage award was later trimmed to $929 million and is being appealed.

If this new trial goes in Apple's favor, it could result in an even bigger award since it involves better-selling Samsung devices, such as the Galaxy S3 smartphone.

A South Korean customer looks at Samsung's Galaxy S5 smartphone at a mobile phone shop in Seoul on March 27, 2014

Quinn attacked expert witnesses Apple planned to call to back its case in the sky-high damages claim. The attorney contended the lawsuit extended from a war that Jobs declared on Google because of Android in 2010.

"A holy war on Android, that was Apple's strategy," Quinn said. "This lawsuit is part of a strategy to catch up with Google."

Dark side

Apple lawyers accused Samsung of going far beyond competitive intelligence to the "dark side" of intentional copying.

Jurors will also consider Samsung's claims that Apple infringed on patents related to transmitting digital video and storing digital images.

McElhinny called Apple vice president of worldwide marketing Philip Schiller as the first witness in the case.

Under questioning, Schiller described how Apple took a big risk betting on the iPhone, which was created during a top-secret project over the course of three years.

The launch of the iPhone in 2007 was an "historic" moment for Apple, with customer surveys showing that ease of use was a major appeal for customers, according to Schiller.

He said he reacted with "shock" when Samsung introduced its Android-powered Galaxy smartphone because it appeared to him that Samsung was copying the iPhone.

Explore further: Samsung: Patents developed by Google engineers (Update)

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Apple says Samsung knew iPhone would be big seller

Apr 01, 2014

Samsung knew Apple's iPhone would be a big seller when it first went on the market, but the South Korean company didn't have a product that could compete so it stole Apple's technology, an attorney for Apple ...

Apple targets Google in patent suit

Nov 07, 2012

A US judge on Wednesday was considering a request by Apple that would pull Google from the sidelines in a long-running patent war with Samsung over mobile gadgets powered by Android software.

Apple, Samsung fail to settle before March trial

Feb 22, 2014

Apple Inc. and Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. have failed to settle their latest patent dispute despite a daylong meeting between top Samsung executives and Apple CEO Tim Cook hosted by a mediator earlier this ...

Recommended for you

Apple's stock bounces back to hit a new high (Update)

2 hours ago

Apple's stock touched a new high Wednesday, reflecting investors' renewed faith in CEO Tim Cook's ability to outwit the competition and expand the technological hit factory built by the late Steve Jobs.

Apple's freshly sliced shares climb

7 hours ago

Freshly split Apple shares closed at a high on Tuesday, with investors evidently betting the California company will debut popular new gadgets, perhaps a smart watch and an iPhone 6.

User comments : 0