Question of race not simple for Mexican Americans

March 6, 2014 by Craig Chamberlain
Question of race not simple for Mexican Americans
When Mexican Americans say they are “white” on the U.S. Census, it’s often not for the reasons many assume, says Julie A. Dowling, a professor of Latina and Latino studies and author of a new book.

About half of Latinos check "white" in response to the question about race on the U.S. Census. About half check "other race."

They identify they are Latino in response to a previous question just for that purpose.

Their choice of "white" or "other " may have little to do with their skin color, their use of English or Spanish, or their comfort within the larger culture, contrary to common assumptions, says Julie A. Dowling, a University of Illinois professor of Latina and Latino studies.

Those are assumptions drawn from the experience of European Americans, but they don't match with the experience of Latinos, particularly those of Mexican origin in Texas, according to Dowling, the author of the new book "Mexican Americans and the Question of Race" (University of Texas Press).

For most European Americans, marking "white" likely means they experience little discrimination based on their racial background, Dowling said. For a Mexican American, it's often a response to discrimination. "It's for them a way of saying, 'I belong, I'm an American citizen, and I want to be recognized as such,' " she said.

Her case in point: the border counties of southern Texas. Most are more than 80 percent Latino, and more than 80 percent of those Latinos marked "white" on the 2010 census.

Go there, however, and you won't find the "wave of whiteness" those numbers suggest, she said. "If you walk into those towns, you would not see people who are all light-skinned, and speak only English."

What you'll find, Dowling said, based on in-depth interviews for her book, is that many Latinos marking "white" on the census would not describe themselves as white in any other context.

"Checking 'white' doesn't mean that they no longer identify strongly with their Mexican heritage or that others are treating them as if they're white," Dowling said. "It's about their ideology, it's about the framework that they're using to explain their experiences with race."

Most of those who mark "white" have likely experienced discrimination, but may downplay those experiences "because it doesn't match what they want to say about themselves," she said. "They manage that disconnect by minimizing those experiences."

Further complicating the matter in Texas, Dowling said, is that Mexican Americans historically were segregated in schools and elsewhere in a manner similar to African-Americans. A key argument in court cases that fought such segregation was that Mexican Americans were white.

Dowling's conclusions are based on an analysis of census data, as well as on interviews with 86 Mexican-origin respondents split about equally among three Texas locations: the border cities of Mission and McAllen in far southern Hidalgo County, the border city of Del Rio about 320 miles to the northwest and Dallas/Fort Worth in the northern part of the state.

About 25 percent of the respondents were immigrants, about 40 percent were second generation in the U.S., and about one-third were third generation or later.

Dowling's book is timely given a proposal being considered by the U.S. Census Bureau that would change the way the census form deals with race, ethnicity and national origin. Dowling has consulted with the bureau as part of its process and supports the change.

Under the proposal, separate questions on race and Latino ethnicity would be removed in favor of a single combined question about race or origin. The respondent would be asked to check one or more of seven major categories, among them white and Hispanic/Latino/Spanish. Under each category, the respondent then would be asked to write in a specific term, such as German or Irish under white, and Mexican American or Puerto Rican under Hispanic/Latino/Spanish.

In Census Bureau tests, this combined question format resulted in data that better reflected how people actually identify themselves, confirmed by extensive follow-up interviews, Dowling said. The number of Latinos checking "white" dropped from about 50 percent to between 9 and 16 percent, she said. The proposed new format also did not produce the undercount of Latinos that some had feared.

The change is needed, Dowling said, because "other race" has become the de facto Latino racial category. Latinos made up 97 percent of "other race" in the last census, making it the third largest racial category, behind white and black.

The separate question about Latino ethnicity on the current form also can have a stigmatizing effect, Dowling said, citing focus group studies conducted by the Census Bureau. "Some Latinos feel singled out, and that has implications for how they feel about answering the census form, as well as how other people see them as a group.

"The Census Bureau has found a way to capture the numbers that also better reflects how people actually identify themselves, and that is really exciting."

Explore further: Despite efforts, not all Latino immigrants accepted as 'white'

Related Stories

Racial identity is changing among Latinos

December 26, 2011

( -- In a paper published in Social Science Research, USC Dornsife’s Amon Emeka and Jody Agius Vallejo look at why many people with Latin American ancestry are not identifying themselves as Hispanic on U.S. ...

US Census data may undercount Mexicans, Arabs, others

September 4, 2013

The number of Mexican-Americans known to be legally in the United States would increase nearly 10 percent if the federal census broadened its standard definition to include people who don't identify themselves as Hispanic ...

Minority political candidates just need a chance

February 11, 2014

It's not necessarily voters who should be blamed for the lack of minorities in state legislatures, but instead the two major political parties for not recruiting enough candidates, indicates new research by a Michigan State ...

Book examines 'Latino gender gap,' future of US politics

February 12, 2014

Political pundits and operatives today spend plenty of time dissecting the modern gender gap, mainly why women vote at higher rates than men and tend to support more liberal policies and Democratic candidates.

Recommended for you

Four pre-Inca tombs found in Peru's Lima

November 27, 2015

Archaeologists in Peru have found four tombs that are more than 1,000 years old in a pyramid-shaped cemetery that now sits in the middle of a residential neighborhood in Lima, experts said.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Vera Paunova
not rated yet Mar 06, 2014
Only in America. While scientists are moving away from idea of 3 (THREE!) races (there NEVER have been more), America is more than happy to come up with ever more, totally arbitrary ways of dividing its citizens. Great job (and explains why so many think that Latino (whatever the fuck that means) or Middle-Eastern is a race. Sometimes it's hard not to despair.
not rated yet Mar 06, 2014
Most Latinos are not unlike most Americans that identify themselves as blacks, in that they are of multi-racial backgrounds. Most American "blacks" have a mixed heritage of African and European descent while most Latinos are of a mixed heritage of Asian and European.
Firefly Mal
2.4 / 5 (5) Mar 08, 2014
This article is a good example how academics, hand in hand with government, are perpetuating a society of academically-defined victim-groups. This is about academia helping bureaucracy create the justification for more bureaucracy, for more social workers, for more professionally outraged pressure-groups to feed the predatory law firms who profit on victimization, in the end justifying more ways government can step in to regulate and manage individual lives and individual relationships within a society of free people – in the end diminishing freedom itself.

This is the only end to which government collects such information.
1.8 / 5 (5) Mar 08, 2014
The only reason the 'progressives' care about 'race' is to use it as a tool of division to create more dependents of the state.
5 / 5 (1) Mar 10, 2014
There is only one race, the human one. There are a hell of a lot of populations though.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.