Rain shortfall pushes farm diversification

March 28, 2014 by Aaron Fernandes
Dairy enterprises were the most profitable, both in $/ha and in $/farm, however their profit also varied more than the other enterprises, particularly under low rainfall situations," Ms Browne says. Credit: DEPI Ellinbank

Dairy farmers are being urged to diversify their farms to protect profit margins amid declining rainfall and fluctuating production costs.

Collaborative research between Western Australian and Victorian institutions shows profitability is affected more by changes in than , with dairy enterprises the most profitable on a $/ha basis.  

Profitability of , steer and prime lamb enterprises however, proved most resilient during times of low rain.

Compared to Victoria, WA's dairy industry is relatively small, producing around 335 million litres of milk annually compared to Victoria's 6,040 million litres.  

However, WA's wheat production is more than double that of Victoria.

The study used correlated price and cost datasets over the past nine years to analyse fourteen representative farm enterprises in south eastern Australia. These sets were used to assess profitability under low, average and high rainfall scenarios.

University of Melbourne expert and lead researcher Natalie Browne says the farms involved in the study included Merino wool, prime lamb, beef cattle, milk, wheat and canola. 

"Computer modelling of farm systems allows a number of different scenarios to be tested, such as how the profitability of numerous farm enterprises were affected by low, median and high rainfall scenarios," she says.

"Dairy enterprises were the most profitable, both in $/ha and in $/farm, however their profit also varied more than the other enterprises, particularly under low rainfall situations.

"Overall, the results showed that low rainfall had a greater impact on profitability than low commodity prices for things like meat, milk and wheat, on all farms except the wheat enterprise."

The models were examined for 30 years to capture the variations that occur in climate and pasture composition over that time.

University of Western Australia Professor Ross Kingwell says wheat-growing in many parts of southern Australia has been affected by a drying trend in recent decades, but technologies like dry-sowing, direct seeding and use of liquid nitrogen have softened the potential impact.

"The other challenge for wheat farmers across Australia is managing their price risk," he says. 

"Since marketing deregulation and the emergence of seemingly more frequent price spikes, wheat farmers now face the challenge of more volatile prices for their wheat.

Ms Browne says farm diversification involving combinations of enterprises with negatively correlated profits will enable the variance in farm profits to be reduced.

This should form part of farms' adaptation strategies to climate and price variability, she says.

"Rainfall is estimated to decline in the future for the study region as a result of climate change," she says. 

Explore further: Mixed feeding trialled for more milk

More information: Natalie Browne, Ross Kingwell, Ralph Behrendt, Richard Eckard, "The relative profitability of dairy, sheep, beef and grain farm enterprises in southeast Australia under selected rainfall and price scenarios," Agricultural Systems, Volume 117, May 2013, Pages 35-44, ISSN 0308-521X, dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.agsy.2013.01.002.

Related Stories

Mixed feeding trialled for more milk

February 12, 2014

For the past 18 months dairy farms in Western Australia have been taking part in trials to determine if a partial mixed ration (PMR) system in pasture-based dairying is cost effective.

Put more nitrogen into milk, not manure

May 28, 2010

The more efficient dairy farmers are in managing nitrogen, the more milk their cows will produce and the less nitrogen will be wasted in manure and urine, according a study by Agricultural Research Service (ARS) scientists ...

Recommended for you

Team finds Southern East Africa getting wetter, not dryer

October 21, 2016

The prevailing notion that the African continent has been getting progressively drier over time is being challenged by a new study that finds that drought has actually decreased over the past 1.3 million years and that the ...

Mt. Aso could erupt much sooner, scientists warn

October 20, 2016

Damage from the 2016 Kumamoto earthquake could hasten Mt. Aso's eruption, volcanologists warn. In a paper published on Science, Kyoto University researchers and colleagues report new faults in the vicinity of Mt. Aso's magma ...

Risk analysis for common ground on climate loss and damage

October 20, 2016

The Paris Agreement included groundbreaking text on the need for a mechanism to help identify risks beyond adaptation and support the victims of climate-related loss and damage—but how exactly it will work remains unclear. ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.