Research on urban ghettos must recognize differences among cities

Feb 15, 2014
University of Chicago sociologist Mario Small will discuss "Poverty and Organizational Density" Feb. 15 at the 2014 annual meeting of the Association for the Advancement of Science in Chicago. Credit: University of Chicago

Research on urban neighborhoods must take into account differences among cities and rely on some techniques that have not been used extensively by sociologists studying neighborhood effects, according to Mario Small, professor of sociology at the University of Chicago.

Small, who is also dean of UChicago's Division of the Social Sciences, studies urban neighborhoods and has studied the diversity of experiences for people living in in cities across the country.

Studying only a few neighborhoods extensively fails to capture important differences, he said in a talk, "Poverty and Organizational Density," at a session Feb. 15 at the annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science in Chicago.

His presentation was part of a seminar, "A New Era for Urban Research: Open Data and Big Compu-tation." At that session, scholars discussed the impact of urban growth, which over the next two dec-ades will see the world's urban population grow from 50 to 70 percent, bringing an additional 3 bil-lion people to live in cities.

These trends require new, interdisciplinary studies and the emergence of new research techniques to better understand the changes, scholars point out.

In order to develop a more comprehensive theory about why some groups in the United States are marginalized economically, scholars need to understand the ways people respond differently to neighborhood circumstances and how neighborhood resources vary, Small explained.

Poor neighborhoods in Chicago have been studied extensively as some scholars consider them examples of nationally. Small's work has shown that those neighborhoods are not necessarily representative because they are often less dense in population and services than poor in other cities.

For instance, the average predominantly black, poor ghetto of Chicago has 82 percent fewer small restaurants, 95 percent fewer small banks, and 72 percent fewer small convenience stores than a predominantly black, poor ghetto in the average U.S. city.

The level of civic and governmental resources vary as well and create differences in services such as the number of childcare centers in different urban communities with similar kinds of populations.

"The experience of poverty varies from city to city, influenced by neighborhood factors such as commercial activity, access to transportation and social services, and other facets of organizational density," Small said.

He explained that new sources of information, ranging from open city data to detailed, high-resolution imagery from commercial mapping services, provide new opportunities to compare the experience of the poor among multiple cities, in turn pointing cities and service providers toward optimal decision-making about policies, investment, or other interventions.

Explore further: Science magazine retracts study on voters' gay-rights views

Related Stories

Longer commutes disadvantage African-American workers

Feb 15, 2014

African-Americans spend more time than any other group getting to work and in some cases spend about 15 minutes more a day than whites commuting, according to research by Virginia Parks, associate professor at the University ...

Effects of segregation negatively impact health

Nov 07, 2013

St. Louis remains one of the most segregated cities in the United States, as recently discussed in a BBC documentary highlighting the "Delmar Divide" as an example. It is an issue of pressing concern in a policy brief titled ...

Urban poor plagued by 'burdens of place'

Aug 09, 2012

Most of America's urban cores were designed for walking but offer little in the way of supermarkets, healthy restaurants and other amenities for residents to walk to, according to a study led by a Michigan ...

Retail investment: A barometer for teen obesity?

Sep 23, 2013

When it comes to addressing the obesity epidemic, fast food restaurants are a favorite target, with some communities, such as the city of Los Angeles, going so far as to ban the construction of new, standalone fast food restaurants ...

Recommended for you

How well does technology solve social problems?

9 hours ago

University of Michigan professor Kentaro Toyama was in India leading a team studying how to make computers work better in the classroom when he noticed that students far outnumbered computers at the underfunded ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

The Shootist
not rated yet Feb 15, 2014
For instance, the average predominantly black, poor ghetto of Chicago has 82 percent fewer small restaurants, 95 percent fewer small banks, and 72 percent fewer small convenience stores than a predominantly black, poor ghetto in the average U.S. city.

Only because of crimes of violence and against property, not because of race. Prior to 1966, this sad state of affairs did not exist in historically black neighborhoods, be it South Side, Camp Belton Rd, Harlem or Northeast DC.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.