Researchers find rice seed treatments effective, worth investment

Feb 17, 2014
The rice water weevil, such as this adult on a rice leaf, is one of the most troublesome insect pests in rice, but seed treatments have proven to be effective in controlling them. The scars on the leaf are evidence of the rice water weevils’ feeding. Credit: Delta Research and Extension Center/Jeff Gore

When every extra expense makes a difference in profitability, farmers often wonder which management decisions are worth the extra cost.

One recent example is the development of seeds treated with insecticides to discourage early damage by crop pests. Researchers at Mississippi State University have been evaluating the effectiveness of seed treatments to find out what producers can expect from the extra investment. Their research saves farmers time and money while helping them make informed decisions about managing their fields.

After testing scores of samples taken from rice fields across the state, MSU scientists found that seed treatments are effective in managing the crop's most troublesome insect pests.

"In Mississippi, we've been evaluating seed treatments for about five years," said Jeff Gore, entomologist with the Mississippi Agricultural and Forestry Experiment Station and MSU Extension Service. "Our research has shown that rice grown with a seed treatment typically yields from 8 to 12 bushels more per acre than untreated rice. The main reason for that yield increase is rice water weevil control."

Gore said seed treatments are effective in both conventional rice varieties and hybrids.

"Although they do not provide 100 percent control of rice water weevil, seed treatments do provide significant benefits in rice," he said. "Because control is not absolute, a foliar insecticide application may be necessary to maximize control in some situations."

Insect management

Gore works at the Delta Research and Extension Center in Stoneville. He said researchers take core samples about 4 inches in diameter and 8 inches deep from farms across the Delta, wash them and count the rice water weevil larvae.

"An infestation of one larva per core will result in about a 1 percent yield loss," Gore said. "Typical infestations in the Delta range from 10 to 25 weevils per core in untreated fields, resulting in a 10 to 25 percent yield loss."

Gore said that seed treatments provide other benefits to rice producers, too.

"Seed treatments provide good control against a whole complex of other rice pests," he said. "Seed treatments help manage chinch bugs, grape colapsis, thrips and soil insects, such as wire worms and white grubs, and get the plants off to a good, healthy start."

Performance under flood

Seed treatments for row crops, such as corn, cotton or soybean, target early-season pests that are in the soil when the seed is planted. But rice seed treatments are different.

"We're targeting primarily rice water weevils, and they only move into the field when producers establish the permanent flood about three to six weeks after planting," Gore said. "So seed treatments for rice have to last longer than in other crops, because they are sitting in the field a lot longer."

Gore said all of the seed treatments are water soluble, and water can have both positive and negative effects on seed treatments.

"Because rice is grown in aquatic or semi-aquatic environments, we needed to find out how different water management practices might impact the seed treatments' performance," he said.

Andrew Adams, an MSU graduate student from Greenville, set up tests in grower fields across the Delta and at the Delta Research and Extension Center.

"To determine the impact of a delayed flood, we looked at flood timings of six and eight weeks after planting, which is about two months that the seed treatment was sitting in the soil without having insect pressure," Adams said. "Where we delayed the permanent flood until eight weeks after planting, the seed treatment was not compromised and no yield losses were observed."

Flushing fields

Adams also looked at the impact of flushing fields. Flushing a field is a form of irrigation where the field is brought to a shallow flood and then drained.

"Flushing is used for herbicide incorporation, seed germination or for irrigation during hot and dry conditions," he said.

Adams tested zero, one and two flushes with water across a rice field to check the efficacy of three different seed treatments.

"We found that zero and one flush had no negative impact," he said. "The seed treatments Cruiser and NipsIt were negatively impacted with the application of the second flush and yield losses were observed. However, Dermacor wasn't negatively impacted by the application of the second flush."

Seed treatment rates

Gore and Adams also tested the efficacy of seed treatment rates in hybrid rice.

"Hybrid rice varieties are grown at 20 to 25 pounds of seed per acre, versus 75 to 85 pounds with conventional varieties," Gore said. "Because seed treatment rates are based on a per-seed basis, we wanted to know if the lower seeding rate, and hence the lower seed treatment rate on a per acre basis, impacted insect control. It did not."

No additional benefit was observed from increasing the seed treatment rate. Currently labeled rates for hybrid rice production are correct, Gore said.

"The management practice that showed significant improvement in rice water weevil control beyond the seed treatment was a foliar overspray with a pyrethroid on hybrid rice," Gore said.

Explore further: Better mouse model enables colon cancer research

Related Stories

Seeds of hope amidst Philippine floods

Aug 14, 2012

Amidst horrendous flooding around Manila and major rice-growing across Luzon in the Philippines, some good news has emerged for rice farmers – Submarino rice – rice that can survive around 2 weeks of being under ...

Grape seed promise in fight against bowel cancer

Feb 13, 2014

University of Adelaide research has shown for the first time that grape seed can aid the effectiveness of chemotherapy in killing colon cancer cells as well as reducing the chemotherapy's side effects.

Guardian angels for seeds

Nov 10, 2010

The seeds that you plant in your backyard garden next spring -- and farmers sow in their fields -- may have a guardian angel that helps them sprout, stay healthy, and grow to yield bountiful harvests. It's a thin coating ...

Recommended for you

Sex chromosomes—why the Y genes matter

5 hours ago

Several genes have been lost from the Y chromosome in humans and other mammals, according to research published in the open access journal Genome Biology. The study shows that essential Y genes are rescue ...

Better mouse model enables colon cancer research

18 hours ago

Every day, it seems, someone in some lab is "curing cancer." Well, it's easy to kill cancer cells in a lab, but in a human, it's a lot more complicated, which is why nearly all cancer drugs fail clinical ...

How to get high-quality RNA from chemically complex plants

May 26, 2015

Ask any molecular plant biologist about RNA extractions and you might just open up the floodgates to the woes of troubleshooting. RNA extraction is a notoriously tricky and sensitive lab procedure. New protocols out of the ...

Plant fertility—how hormones get around

May 26, 2015

Researchers at Tokyo Institute of Technology have identified a transporter protein at the heart of a number of plant processes associated with fertility and possibly aging.

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.