Moon rocks reveal surprising meteorite history

Feb 13, 2014 by Michelle Wheeler
A/Prof Nemchin's discovery challenges the long-held view that there was a single spike in huge meteorite impacts 3.9 billion years ago. Credit: PictureWendy

A WA geologist analyzing lunar rock samples collected during the Apollo missions has uncovered evidence of a huge meteorite strike 4.2 billion years ago.

Curtin University Associate Professor Alexander Nemchin made the discovery when he dated a section of from the Moon that melted in heat of the meteorite impact.

The object that hit the Moon was probably tens of kilometers across and would have left a crater several hundred kilometers wide.

A/Prof Nemchin says the strike happened at least 300 million years before the youngest known lunar impact basins and his discovery challenges the long-held view that there was a single spike in huge impacts 3.9 billion years ago.

He says this period of intense meteorite bombardment, which would have affected both the Moon and the Earth, was previously thought to be a one-off event.

"A few years ago we started to see evidence that it's probably not quite the case," A/Prof Nemchin says.

"It's possible that there are some impacts not related to this 3.9 [billion years] spike … there are some that happened much earlier.

"It has implications for a number of things including how life evolved on Earth."

A/Prof Nemchin analysed the rock using an ion probe instrument at Curtin University known as SHRIMP, which allows researchers to determine the age of tiny amounts of rock by examining the atoms that make up the sample.

He was able to borrow the rock, which was collected from the rim of North Ray crater during the Apollo 16 mission, because of NASA's relatively open approach to the use of moon rocks for scientific research.

"All you need is to have record of doing scientific research, you need to demonstrate that you've got a way to keep the samples safe and you know how to work with small, rare samples," A/Prof Nemchin says.

"It's really very open in many ways."

A/Prof Nemchin says currently the best explanation for any increase in throughout the Solar System 3.9 billion years ago is that some planets were thought to be displaced from their normal orbits at that time.

He says the movement of Jupiter and Saturn, with their huge mass, destabilised Neptune and sent smaller asteroids and comets "randomly flying around" in the Solar System.

"Of course when they go all over the place they start hitting all the other planets," A/Prof Nemchin says.

Explore further: Team uncovers secrets of Mars' birth from unique meteorite

Related Stories

Curtin geologists make a 'shocking' discovery

Jan 24, 2012

Research led by Curtin University geologists has uncovered a wealth of new evidence in the mineral zircon from lunar rock samples recovered during NASA’s Apollo missions, revealing indisputable proof ...

Scientists find Moon, asteroids share history

Mar 25, 2013

(Phys.org) —NASA and international researchers have discovered that Earth's moon has more in common than previously thought with large asteroids roaming our solar system.

Water hidden in the Moon may have proto-Earth origin

Sep 10, 2013

Water found in ancient Moon rocks might have actually originated from the proto-Earth and even survived the Moon-forming event. Latest research into the amount of water within lunar rocks returned during ...

Lunar scientists shed light on Moon's impact history

Feb 28, 2012

(PhysOrg.com) -- A team of researchers from the NASA Lunar Science Institute (NLSI) at NASA Ames Research Center, Moffett Field, Calif., have discovered that debris that caused a "lunar cataclysm" on the moon ...

Recommended for you

Video: A dizzying view of the Earth from space

5 hours ago

We've got vertigo watching this video, but in a good way! This is a sped-up view of Earth from the International Space Station from the Cupola, a wraparound window that is usually used for cargo ship berthings ...

NEOWISE spots a comet that looked like an asteroid

5 hours ago

Comet C/2013 UQ4 (Catalina) has been observed by NASA's Near-Earth Object Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (NEOWISE) spacecraft just one day after passing through its closest approach to the sun. The comet ...

What the UK Space Agency can teach Australia

6 hours ago

Australia has had an active civil space program since 1947 but has much to learn if it is to capture a bigger share of growing billion dollar global space industry. ...

Discover the "X-factor" of NASA's Webb telescope

6 hours ago

NASA's James Webb Space Telescope and Chandra X-ray observatory have something in common: a huge test chamber used to simulate the hazards of space and the distant glow of starlight. Viewers can learn about ...

User comments : 2

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

SnowballSolarSystem _SSS_
1 / 5 (1) Feb 21, 2014
This finding may represent the first in a late-heavy bombardment (LHB) double pulse as the solar-system barycenter between the Sun and a former companion star overtook Uranus around 4.2 Ga followed by Neptune around 3.9 Ga. Only a former binary companion star spiraling out into the Oort cloud could explain a Hills cloud (Inner Oort cloud) with more angular momentum than the planets that supposed hurled them out there: scratch the Nice model.
Captain Stumpy
not rated yet Feb 21, 2014
This finding may represent the first in a late-heavy bombardment (LHB) double pulse as the solar-system barycenter between the Sun and a former companion star overtook Uranus around 4.2 Ga followed by Neptune around 3.9 Ga. Only a former binary companion star spiraling out into the Oort cloud could explain a Hills cloud (Inner Oort cloud) with more angular momentum than the planets that supposed hurled them out there: scratch the Nice model.

@SnowballSolarSystem _SSS_
is there ANY empirical data to back up your claims?
any REPUTABLE science?
ANYTHING that can be considered a peer reviewed study?
P.s. leave out the EU sites and all that, as that is pesudoscience and not a legitimate resource unless you are talking cults or religious organizations