Massive logging leaves deep scars in Eastern Europe

Feb 23, 2014 by Mihaela Rodina
Ilegally deforested mountains in Pojarna Valley, in the heart of the Romanian Carpathians are pictured on January 16, 2014

With its steep, forested mountains set against blue skies, Romania's central Pojarna Valley once looked like a postcard landscape but illegal logging has turned the site into an ugly scar.

"The guys who did this used excavators. They even destroyed the young trees," said Gheorghe Ridichie, an official at Romania's forestry ministry, pointing to thousands of stumps poking out of the valley's now-barren slopes.

Last year, authorities rallied to halt rampant deforestation in the Balkan state.

But the draft law, setting stricter controls and heavier penalties for offenders, still awaits a vote in the lower house of parliament after making it through the upper house.

Official figures show that in 2012, in Romania—some of it in lush, century-old forests—had doubled over five years.

"If this goes on, there will be no wood left for the economy and no forests to walk in," Minister Delegate for water and forests Lucia Varga told AFP.

"Over the past 20 years, some 80 million cubic metres of wood were illegally cut, causing five billion euros ($6.8 million) in damage," she said.

And "the worst part is that the pace of illegal logging is twice that of reforestation and regeneration."

Similar problems exist in other east European states, notably Bosnia and Bulgaria.

But some conversationists fear efforts to change matters may be too little too late.

Both officials and conservationists blame the surge on several factors, including alleged collusion between local authorities and offenders, corruption in post-communist states, loopholes in legislation and an insufficient number of forest guards.

The draft bill has angered forest owners and wood processors who fear it will create additional costs and legal roadblocks.

Environmentalists, meanwhile, suspect some local authorities are part of the "mafia" that controls the trade.

"The illegally cut wood is often accompanied by seemingly legal documents that are actually issued by dummy companies," Catalin Tobescu, president of Nostra Silva forest owners' association, told AFP.

"When the authorities eventually decide to check on these companies, it is too late, they no longer exist and their managers are gone."

' Irreversible impact'

In a robust sector with high demand, wood processing companies do not always check the origin of the raw material.

Romania's own market is estimated at four billion euros a year, dominated by the 400-year-old Austrian firm Schweighofer which moved into the country a decade ago.

Schweighofer's plans to open a fifth plant in Romania have annoyed conservationists and local woodworkers who say it will have an "irreversible impact" on forests here.

But Schweighofer spokeswoman Theresa Willmann disputes this.

The new site involved "a reorganization of the market", she said, and would create 650 jobs in the sawmill and an additional 2,000 indirectly.

"The total forest fund in Romania will not be affected by the logs Schweighofer needs," she told AFP in an email.

In a region that hosts Europe's largest old-growth forests outside Russia—and one that is home to 8,000 brown bears, 4,000 wolves and 3,000 lynx—Romania is not the only state threatened by deforestation.

In Bosnia, whose rich, 43 percent woodland is greater than the European average of 32 percent, conservationists estimate that hundreds of thousands of trees are felled illegally every year.

Mersudin Avidbegovic, the head of a Sarajevo-based association of forestry experts, said it was unclear "if this is to blame on poverty or on a mafia".

"But the main reason is the absence of steps to fight illegal logging," he said.

Likewise in Bulgaria, "illegal logging is an extremely serious problem," Neli Doncheva, Worldwide Fund for Nature (WWF) programme coordinator, told AFP.

But authorities have passed a new penal code to try to end the scourge. Not only can companies breaking the law lose their permits and incur fines of up to $7,000 (5,000 euros), but offenders can get up to five years in jail.

In Romania, the draft bill sets fines up to 3,000 euros and the state has undertaken an active reforestation effort to plant one million hectares by 2030.

But Dorina Danciu of Greenpeace remains skeptical.

"Even if we start planting trees now, it will take dozens of years for the scars left by illegal logging to heal," he said.

Explore further: Sustainable use of energy wood resources shows potential in North-West Russia

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Illegal logging 'ravaging DR Congo forests'

Jun 03, 2013

Multinational companies are profiting hand over fist from abusive forestry practices in the Democratic Republic of Congo, where illegal logging, mislabelled timber and false permits are widespread, according ...

Suspected celebrity hacker Guccifer arrested

Jan 23, 2014

A man suspected of breaking into the email accounts of Romanian and US celebrities, including the Bush family, under the nickname "Guccifer" has been arrested in Romania with US help.

WWF urges Romania, Bulgaria to protect wild sturgeon

Jun 18, 2013

Conservationist group WWF on Tuesday urged Romania and Bulgaria, home to the last viable wild sturgeon populations in the European Union, to protect the species, threatened by illegal fishing and caviar trade.

Recommended for you

New York state bans fracking

3 hours ago

Governor Andrew Cuomo said Wednesday he would ban hydraulic fracking in New York State, citing health concerns about the controversial oil and gas drilling technique.

User comments : 5

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

ForFreeMinds
2 / 5 (3) Feb 23, 2014
"Environmentalists, meanwhile, suspect some local authorities are part of the "mafia" that controls the trade."

When government picks winners and losers, you can bet those in government will also be winners. The article doesn't say, but it seems fair to assume the illegal logging is occurring on government land. Selling the land would solve the problem, as then the owners would call the authorities to have the illegal loggers prosecuted, and sued.

As is often the case, environmental problems are on government property and or caused by government. Because then to deal with it, citizens sue the government, and essentially are suing themselves if they get anywhwere. Where the real winners are lawyers for both the governmnet and those representing environmentalists.
EnricM
3 / 5 (2) Feb 23, 2014
Climate Change in the make.

I would like to hear what some denialists have to say :)

Of course, you don need global warming for that but as it happens denialists even try to deny that such (human) interneventions have an impact on the (local) climate.

BUT we have a very good example of that in Europe: Spain. Specially the regions loved by the British for building and buying holiday houses. At the begin/middle of the XX Century these regions were dense mediterranean forrests. But the Spaniards did exactly the same as the Romanian cutting down the tree cover to make charcoal. The agricultural "Green Revolution" did some extra work and in no time woods and fertile lands became the barren lunar landscape you can see today. the climate has shifted from mediterranean moderate to desertic. Water is a scarce commmodity and underground waters are poisoned with nitrates, pesticides and other chemicals and nothing but a stinky mud. Source: I lived there :)
Returners
2.3 / 5 (3) Feb 23, 2014
And supposing the logs weren't harvested illegally, you'd still need more lumber, so somebody would have to cut it anyway, unless you expect everyone to live in straw huts...
verkle
not rated yet Feb 23, 2014
Note to editors: "$6.8 million" should read "6.8 billion"
Caliban
5 / 5 (1) Feb 23, 2014


When government picks winners and losers, you can bet those in government will also be winners. The article doesn't say, but it seems fair to assume the illegal logging is occurring on government land. Selling the land would solve the problem, as then the owners would call the authorities to have the illegal loggers prosecuted, and sued.


Nope --it's a direct consequence of markets that turn a blind eye to raw material sourcing, and occurs the whole world over, on both Public and Private land, 24/7, and especially in equitorial Africa, S.E. Asia, and South/Central America.

The Libertarian Utopia you envision is nothing but a pipe dream.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.